Books Magazine

New York Review Of Books Eviscerates Oliver Stone’s ‘History’ Book

By Reasoningpolitics @reasonpolitics

Oliver-StoneOliver Stone’s new ‘history’ book, The Untold History of The United States, has been on the shelves for a few months now. Stone has already made his rounds on news programs such as Morning Joe to explain what his revisionist history is all about: to create a new 20th century narrative where the US malevolently grabbed power while smearing the reputation of The Soviet Union.. or something like that. I have already posted Michael Moynihan’s deconstruction of Stone’s book, but what the heck, lets pile on the bad reviews.

The New York Review of Books has an even more detailed and therefore satisfying take down of Stone’s selective revisionism. They begin by pointing out what Stone has already conceded: the ‘untold’ history in this book has already been told. Many times.

After that, they go on to disassemble Stone’s false narrative of US history. It’s too long to post, but their conclusion is worth noting:

Although the book by Stone and Kuznick is heavily footnoted, the sourcing, as the example of Wallace’s 1952 article suggests, recalls nothing so much as Dick Cheney’s cherry-picking of intelligence, particularly about the origins and early years of the cold war. The authors also devote many thousands of words to criticism of such destructive American policies as Ronald Reagan’s in Central America and George W. Bush’s in Iraq, but much of this will be familiar to readers of these pages, as will their objections to Barack Obama’s use of predator drones. This book is less a work of history than a skewed political document, restating and updating a view of the world that the independent radical Dwight Macdonald once likened to a fog, “caused by the warm winds of the liberal Gulf Stream coming in contact with the Soviet glacier”—but now more than twenty years after the dissolution of the Soviet empire.

In case you missed it, that’s a really polite way to say this book is pure propaganda. Earlier on in the review, the author gives us an even more condensed conclusion to his review:

In making this case, Stone and [co-writer] Kuznick simply ignore the scholarship that contradicts their basic assumptions.

And there you have it.


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Video: Antarctica in 4K by Drone

    We've seen drone footage from a number of spectacular locations around the world over the past few years, but I'm not sure that Antarctica was amongst them. Read more

    The 21 June 2018 by   Kungfujedi
    OUTDOORS
  • Metamorphosis

    Metamorphosis

    by JivanaBy Maria Sibylla MerianThe monarch butterfly spends two weeks as a caterpillar before metamorphosing into a butterfly. Read more

    The 21 June 2018 by   Ninazolotow
    FITNESS, HEALTH, HEALTHY LIVING
  • Top Rated Legal Steroids

    Rated Legal Steroids

    Legal steroids have hit the fitness world by flooding the market with fake claims and inferior products. So, we have written this article to separate the B.S an... Read more

    The 21 June 2018 by   Leesteve19
    SPORTS
  • Web.com to Be Acquired for $25 a Share Or $2Billion

    Web.com Acquired Share $2Billion

    Web.com the company that owns Register.com and Network Solutions is being purchased in an all cash deal worth approximately $2 billion. Web.com acquired... Read more

    The 21 June 2018 by   Worldwide
    BUSINESS, TECH
  • Three Golf Lessons Learned from U.S. Open Mistakes

    Three Golf Lessons Learned from U.S. Open Mistakes

    For those fans who stayed glued to their television sets during the 118th U.S. Open at Shinnecock Hills, the golf tournament proved exciting with lessons to be... Read more

    The 21 June 2018 by   Golfforbeginners
    GOLF, SPORTS
  • Fortnite, Snap Streak, Instagram and Other Summertime Addictions

    Yay!!!!! School's out for summer!!! I was shopping at my little neighborhood grocery today and bumped into one of my neighbors. I asked when her kids were done... Read more

    The 21 June 2018 by   Joanigeltman
    FAMILY, PARENTING
  • Summer Fashion with Lucky Brand

    Summer Fashion with Lucky Brand

    Today’s post is sponsored by Macy’s but all opinions are my own. #MacysLucky Winter seemed to drag on forever and it feels like we went directly from winter to... Read more

    The 21 June 2018 by   Thesamanthashow
    LIFESTYLE, SELF EXPRESSION