Business Magazine

Eurozone: Greece Back in the Spotlight After Most EU Countries Agree to New Fiscal Pact

Posted on the 31 January 2012 by Periscope @periscopepost
Eurozone: Greece back in the spotlight after most EU countries agree to new fiscal pact

Prime Minister David Cameron at the World Economic Forum in Davos last week. Photo credit: World Economic Forum, Moritz Hager

Britain again played the conscientious objector to an European Union measure aimed at keeping member nations from breaching budget deficit limits, voting against the pact during a summit meeting in Brussels on Monday.

“I don’t think this treaty on its own will sort the eurozone’s problems,” said Prime Minister David Cameron, after voting against the measure, which would have member nations agree to put balanced budget legislation into their national law. Under the new treaty, annual structural deficits will be capped at 0.5 percent of GDP, and any breach of that would trigger a quasi-automatic penalty of 0.1 percent GDP, with the fine being added to the EU bailout fund, the European Stability Mechanism. The new treaty will come into effect once it has been passed by 12 of the member nations’ parliaments. The only other nation to decline was the Czech Republic.

The half-day summit in Brussels was intended to come up with a strategy to revive growth in European nations, but disagreement over the new treaty, as well as over the “limits of austerity”, as The Telegraph put it, and whether an EU commissioner should be placed in Greece to monitor its budget decisions overshadowed the official discussion.

But with the treaty now agreed and due to be signed in March, markets, economists and commentators are again turning to the on-going problem of Greece; already, European shares are rising on the hopes of achieving a deal with the indebted nation by the end of the week. So is there hope?

“What we got yesterday we got more bickering at the sideline, agreement on a largely irrelevant treaty while the issue of the size of the ESM/EFSF was left till March. They could have used the opportunity to boost the size of the rescue fund now building on the more positive market sentiment of late and in the process increased the chance of getting additional support from the IMF,” complained analyst Elisabeth Asfeth at Investec, according to The Guardian. “I guess it could be described as a consistent approach to the crisis; a German focus on austerity and no agreement on anything else.”

Will the new “fiscal compact” help? German Chancellor Angela Merkel believes that the new “fiscal compact” will make for a more perfect monetary union, but critics, Cameron included, claim that it’s just a distraction from the real problems that will “condemn Europe to eternal austerity and stagnation”. “Most likely, it will do neither,” judged Marcus Walker at The Wall Street Journal. “The proposed treaty doesn’t overcome doubts about the euro zone’s long-term viability and membership, and its constraints on government budgets aren’t as tough as they appear at first glance.”

How about a little humility, Mr. Cameron? Philip Stephens, writing at the Financial Times, complained that Cameron’s “bombastic” performance and attempts to “lecture” German Chancellor Angela Merkel on how to run her economy were unwarranted. “A smidgen of self-awareness might have suggested otherwise,” he suggested: “Mr Cameron presides over a budget deficit to rival that of Greece, a fast-rising debt burden and an inflation rate double the European average. Living standards are falling, growth has stalled and unemployment is rising. There is no one old enough in Whitehall to recall the last time Britain ran a current account surplus.” Maybe instead of telling Germany to “to work less, to borrow more, and to produce shoddy cars and machine tools”, Cameron et al could instead learn something from Germany’s economic management?

Ed Miliband, Labour leader, complained that Cameron “sold Britain down the river”, effectively isolating the island nation, in voting against the fiscal tightening measure.

The Greeks need to go – and here’s how. The Times (£), in a leading editorial, again pounced on what they see as the main trouble for the euro: Greece. Greece needs to get out of the monetary union as much as the unions needs it to go, the paper claimed. “Greece will default on its debts. But there will be no escape for Greece from slump while it remains in the euro.” The paper proposed, as its entry to the Wolfson Prize for designing a strategy by which countries could leave the euro (without bring about Armageddon, presumably), “the reintroduction of a new drachma by Greece be part of an arrangement known as a currency board”, “where the value of a currency is pegged to the value of another”. The new drachma would be pegged, however, not just to the euro, which would merely replicate its problems, but to the dollar as well.  “This arrangement is no cure-all. The responsibility of Greeks to restore sense to their public finances cannot be evaded. Other countries will still need to stand behind them as they do it. But Greek departure from the euro is not only necessary. It can be done, and without a run on the banks.”

International debt inspectors have delayed a meeting with Greece’s labor minister to discuss reducing employment costs, a major “sticking point” in negotiations between Greece is its eurozone creditors, the Associated Press reported. Eurozone ministers want to see Greece engage in serious labor reform, before agreeing to the second bailout loan worth €130 billion, but the country continues to reject suggestions to cut minimum wage and private sector pay.

If Greece stays, it needs a minder. “I’m sorry, but I cannot agree with the general sense of outrage sparked by calls for an EU bureaucrat – or German gauleiter, as depicted in some quarters – to take control of the Greek economy,” protested Jeremy Warner at The Telegraph. “Greece lied its way into the single currency, and it has repeatedly failed to keep its promises since, even after agreeing the conditionality of IMF and Eurozone loans. If it wants to stay in the club, which bizarrely in my opinion, it still appears to, then some way of forcing it to obey the rules must be found. You don’t keep lending to a perpetually delinquent creditor.”

More on the economy

  • RBS boss Hester turns down massive bonus
  • Eurozone debt crisis continues to deepen
  • Will David Cameron really legislate on fat cat pay?
  • Is the UK economy doomed?

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • The Worst Christmas Specials Ever. Still.

    Worst Christmas Specials Ever. Still.

    Exactly ten years ago I shared this wonderful relic of the Olde Days of the Blogosphere, by John Scalzi. It was old then, and it's even older now. Still make... Read more

    10 hours, 2 minutes ago by   Russellarbenfox
    SOCIETY
  • Happiness Is... Getting Used to the Mayhem

    Happiness Is... Getting Used Mayhem

    I know, half of the school holidays has gone by in a flash and we are nearing mid-December already! How can it be, right? That means we only have a few more... Read more

    11 hours, 32 minutes ago by   A Happy Mum
    FAMILY, SELF EXPRESSION
  • How Speaking Up Can Create Greater Happiness and Success

    Speaking Create Greater Happiness Success

    It's not always easy to find the words when you don't know what the reaction will be, but just how much do we avoid speaking up? According to research, 72% of... Read more

    The 11 December 2018 by   Ncrimaldi
    BUSINESS, CAREER
  • MDM Recordings Introduces TJ Miller

    Recordings Introduces Miller

    MDM Recordings unveiled a new member of their label family on Monday night at the Canadian Country Music Association office in Toronto, introducing a small grou... Read more

    The 11 December 2018 by   Phjoshua
    LIFESTYLE, SELF EXPRESSION
  • 15 Non-toy Gift Ideas for Kids

    Non-toy Gift Ideas Kids

    With Christmas just two weeks away, the pressure is on. And if your kids or the kids you’re buying for are like my kids, they really don’t NEED anything. Read more

    The 11 December 2018 by   Thesamanthashow
    LIFESTYLE, SELF EXPRESSION
  • Handle with Care: Consolidating Bill Traylor’s Artwork

    Conservator Catherine Maynor has extensive expertise caring for works on paper at the Smithsonian American Art Museum, including many by self-taught artists,... Read more

    The 11 December 2018 by   Americanart
    ART & DESIGN, CULTURE
  • Recipe: South African Three Bean Salad1 Min Read

    Recipe: South African Three Bean Salad1 Read

    Summer in South Africa means Braai - their word for BBQ. This light and bright salad makes the ideal complement to traditional BBQ fare. Serve it alongside... Read more

    The 11 December 2018 by   Healthytravelblog
    TRAVEL

Paperblog Hot Topics