Debate Magazine

Economic Myths: "those Who Have Worked Hard All Their Lives to Buy a Home"

Posted on the 17 November 2017 by Markwadsworth @Mark_Wadsworth

Sayid David was doing a fine job of playing both ends against the middle, as reported in The Daily Mail:
Mr Javid, a frequent critic of so-called Nimbys, said it was time to deliver 'moral justice' for the young – and warned older people they would not be permitted to stand in the way of a massive house building drive.
"What we need now is a giant leap … I still hear from those who say that there isn't a problem with housing... that affordability is only a problem for millennials that spend too much on nights out and smashed avocados.
"It's nonsense. The people who tell me this – usually baby boomers who have long-since paid off their own mortgage – they are living in a different world. They're not facing up to the reality of modern daily life and have no understanding of the modern market."

He's trying to claw back a few of the under-30 votes for the Tories with a couple of well-aimed blows at the NIMBYs and Boomers while ensuring that his party's major donors find it even easier to get planning permission.
He must know that you can give the land bankers as much planning permission as you like; it will not change their profit maximising level of output one iota - why would it? Even if they did increase output, it would only have a very short term and marginal downwards effect on prices.
But hey, he's a politician.
Here's the Economic Myth:
Lib Dem housing spokesman Wera Hobhouse last night criticised Mr Javid for his attack on baby boomers. She said: "This kind of language is divisive and unnecessarily sets one generation against another. It is patronising to tell those who have worked hard all their lives to buy a home and raise their children that they don't understand the housing market."
This "worked hard all your life" to buy a house is complete and utter bollocks (except for the very few people who bought something that was far too expensive). From the 1950s to the late 1990s, you could (if you wanted) have paid off the mortgage in ten or fifteen years and still been paying less per month than you would have been paying in rent for the same home. All these Homeys have paid considerably less than tenants have.
For sure, there were a couple of nasty years in the mid-1970s when interest rates were very high; but inflation was even higher, so in exchange for two or three years of pain you effectively had half your mortgage eroded by inflation. My mom admitted to me that they paid off the rest of the mortgage they took out in 1964 with petty cash sometime in the mid-1970s. I bought a nice house in 1998 with a 20% deposit and paid off the mortgage in ten years (because that was the longest fixed rate period on offer).
There were another couple of fairly nasty years in the early 1990s as well, but so what, it was still cheaper than renting for nine out of ten mortgage borrowers. We note that these two high interest rate periods followed a house price bust; they took a different approach after the last one and pushed interest rates to zero instead.
And yes, some people with mortgages lose their jobs and struggle, but that is irrelevant, they'd have struggled to pay the rent as well. It's your "Losing your job" bit that causes the pain, not the fact that you chose to save money by buying not renting.
But hey, she's a politician as well.

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Parkland Students Arrive In Washington For ‘March For Our Lives’

    Parkland Students Arrive Washington ‘March Lives’

    Parkland students are arriving in Washington, D.C. ahead of the  ‘March For Our Lives’ on Saturday to meet with lawmakers regarding gun control. Read more

    The 23 March 2018 by   Firstladyb
  • Video: The Barkley Marathons - The World's Most Difficult and Bizarre Sporting...

    Video: Barkley Marathons World's Most Difficult Bizarre Sporting Event?

    Earlier today I posted a story about Gary Robbins and his attempt to complete the Barkley Marathons, which may or may not be happening this weekend. Read more

    The 23 March 2018 by   Kungfujedi
  • Machine Learning

    Machine Learning

    The Center for the Study of Complex Systems at the University of Michigan hosted an intensive day-long training on some of the basics of machine learning for... Read more

    The 23 March 2018 by   Dlittle30
  • Friday Q&A: Yoga for Spondylolisthesis

    Friday Q&A: Yoga Spondylolisthesis

    Example of Spondylolisthesis: Backward Slip of Lumbar Vertebra 3 on Vertebra 4Q: Five weeks ago, my husband was diagnosed with Spondylolisthesis. Read more

    The 23 March 2018 by   Ninazolotow
  • At 18, Europa Bhoumik is a Badass Bodybuilder!

    Europa Bhoumik Badass Bodybuilder!

    দেশের কনিষ্ঠতম মহিলা বডি বিল্ডার এই বঙ্গতনয়াDon't you think I have a pretty odd name for an Indian girl?" asks Europa Bhowmik, pulling smoothly on the rowing... Read more

    The 23 March 2018 by   Abhirup Lahiri
  • Douglas A-4C Skyhawk

    Douglas A-4C Skyhawk

    @ Marana Regional Airport, AZ March 2018 Toured several locations around Marana Regional Airport on an ISAP tour, culminating with a photo shoot of this... Read more

    The 23 March 2018 by   Htam
  • Video: A Love Letter to Winter

    Video: Love Letter Winter

    Winter may now be officially over here in the Northern Hemisphere, but for those of us who don't mind playing in the snow and cold, it will be missed. Read more

    The 23 March 2018 by   Kungfujedi