Culture Magazine

Concert Review: The Woman Who Played With the Sea

By Superconductor @ppelkonen
Susanna Mälkki returns to the New York Philharmonic.
by Paul J. Pelkonen

Concert Review: The Woman Who Played With the Sea

The conductor Susanna Mälkki returned to the New York Philharmonic this week.
Photo by Sakari Viika © 2017 Helsinki Philharmonic Orchestra.

Just a couple of years ago, a number of names were tossed around as candidates for who should become the New York Philharmonic's next music director. One of the leading candidates was Susanna Mälkki, the Finnish conductor who is best known to New Yorkers for leading the 2016 New York premiere of her compatriot Kaija Saariaho's opera L'amour de Loin. Ms. Mälkki did not get the job, but she returned to the Philharmonic this week.
Most symphonic concerts follow this format: a short piece opens, usually an overture or a small tone poem. It is followed by a longer work, most often a concerto. The second half is devoted to symphony. However, Ms. Mälkki and soloist Baiba Skride elected to alter that order by opening this concert with Tchaikovsky's Violin Concerto. Now a staple of the repertory, the "Tchaik" faced rejection from its intended first soloist on the grounds that it was unplayable. Funnily enough, the same thing happened to the composer's first piano concerto too.
Ms. Skride proved herself to be an able interpreter, taking on the Olympian climb of the opening movement with gusto and guts. Tchaikovsky throws all sorts of curve balls at the soloist, a difficult, off-kilter rhythm for the main theme, elaborate figurations that recall the baroque writing of Handel and Vivaldi, and a monstrous cadenza that requires the soloist to play against themselves, providing the tutti melody in the low strings as the upper line soars forth on the high ones.
Ms. Mälkki and Ms. Skride mined the second movement for a burnished lyricism, with the woodwinds providing supple support and the whole orchestra sounding dark and soulful. The zippy finale followed, with more high-flying athleticism from the soloist over a brisk, quick-stepping accompaniment. The only issue here: a thin and reedy tone from the violin that may have been the fault of the finicky acoustic of David Geffen Hall.
Esa-Pekka Salonen has used his three years as Composer-in-Residence to excellent ends, giving the Philharmonic audience a wide variety of new pieces to consider. Helix is one of his more geometric, musically economic constructions: a slow-rising spiral of sound modeled on Ravel's La Valse. Onward and upward it wound, climaxing in a series of sharp and jarring chords, a characteristic Salonen finish carried off with style and aplomb by his compatriot on the podium.
Of 20th century orchestral compositions Debussy's roiling, swirling La Mer has proved among the most durable. It is essentially a three-movement symphony without the conventional musical structures that make up the form: substituting the composer's own ideas and concepts for the familiar shapes of Allegro, Scherzo and Andante. Indeed, the first movement is a case study in shifting keys, meters and tempos that can be as treacherous as a riptide or undertow for the unwary musical mariner.
Ms. Mälkki took a bold, forceful approach to the opening movement, using careful control of meter to force the waves of sound to dance to her baton. This was a faster than usual tour of the three movements, sacrificing some lyricism on the altar of structure and musical efficiency. That said, it was exciting, with the Jeux de Vagues a particular standout. In the final Dialogue du vent et la mer, the taut structures of the opening movement paid off as Debussy's thematic ideas rolled in like a particularly welcome high tide. 

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Looking for the BEST Copycat Crispy Famous Amos Chocolate Chip Cookies (Part...

    Looking BEST Copycat Crispy Famous Amos Chocolate Chip Cookies (Part Recipes)

    version;YES! I've found you!!!YES! You are the Famous Amos Cookies!!!YIPPEE!!!Please pardon me and my over-reacting ecstatic moments! *nervous chuckle*Am I mad... Read more

    9 hours, 54 minutes ago by   Zoebakeforhappykids
  • Jade Eagleson Debut EP Review

    Jade Eagleson Debut Review

    Jade Eagleson gave everyone a Wednesday morning surprise when he released his debut EP. The smalltown Ontario country singer is an emerging star in country... Read more

    The 17 October 2018 by   Phjoshua
  • The Pumpkin Spice Products I’m Buying This Fall

    Autumn is my favorite season and to celebrate I indulge in everything pumpkin spice. l buy the seasonal fall products I’ve come to love, while trying out some... Read more

    The 17 October 2018 by   A Girl In La - Style Blog
  • Singularity: Jon Hopkins Live Show

    Singularity: Hopkins Live Show

    I do not even remember when I first learned of Jon Hopkins‘ music. Maybe about 4 years ago I discovered his incredible album Immunity that made him a huge name. Read more

    The 17 October 2018 by   Flemmingbo
  • Loneliness


    Most of us are a mixture of extrovert and introvert and I’m no exception. I love getting out and meeting people, chatting and laughing, but, equally, I... Read more

    The 17 October 2018 by   Ashleylister
  • Connecting with the Tribe in Annapolis

    Connecting with Tribe Annapolis

    “Drink this. Now.” The Annapolis Boat Show was in full swing, but my friend Nica wasn’t handing me one of Pusser’s famous Painkillers with her demand. She had... Read more

    The 17 October 2018 by   Behan Gifford
  • A Quick Note About Voting in the Midterm Election, Part 1

    Voting in the November 6 midterm election has never been more important… or easier! Watch this short instructional video I whipped up, then REGISTER TO VOTE! Yo... Read more

    The 17 October 2018 by   Designerdaddy