Eco-Living Magazine

China Bans Airlines from Paying European Union Carbon Tax

Posted on the 17 February 2012 by 2ndgreenrevolution @2ndgreenrev

China Bans Airlines from Paying European Union Carbon TaxAt its outset in 2005, the European Union Emissions Trading System (EU ETS) was designed to reduce the greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions produced by factories, power plants, and other energy-intensive installations. At the beginning of this year, however, ETS began imposing the cap-and-trade system on all airlines with flights departing from or arriving at EU airports. In response, China barred its domestic airlines from complying with the system last week.

The Chinese government says the new rules outlined by the EU are both costly and illegal. The China Air Transport Association (CATA) estimates ETS will cost its airlines nearly $127 million this year, and nearly $2.8 billion over the next nine years. Industry air groups cited by the Wall Street Journal say it could cost the entire aviation industry more than $26 billion by 2020. The European Commission (EU executive branch) estimates the increase in airfare to be between €2 and €12, depending on the length of the flight.

In regard to its legality, the Civil Aviation Administration of China (CAAC) argues that the EU does not have the right to charge non-domestic airlines for carbon emissions. “ETS has violated the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change…and regulations of the International Civil Aviation Organization.” Several U.S. airlines also filed a lawsuit against the EU, saying it could not charge for carbon emissions outside EU airspace. However, the European Court of Justice dismissed it in December after ruling it does not infringe on “the principle of territoriality, nor the sovereignty of third countries[...and] does not constitute a tax, fee or charge on fuel.” Other prevailing arguments against the system are that it acts as a trade barrier and impedes international efforts to achieve a more agreeable approach to addressing climate change.

Besides China, more than two dozen other countries have expressed opposition or threatened counter measures to the EU. Last October, the U.S. House of Representatives approved a bill similar to China’s, which, if passed by the Senate and signed by President Obama (as expected), will make it illegal for domestic airlines to comply with ETS fees. As recently as November, Russia’s Transport Minister warned that overflight rights could be revoked as a countermeasure, and landing rights of EU airlines were threatened by India (Lufthansa Policy Brief). A few other notable countries that oppose ETS’s involvement in the aviation industry include Japan, Korea, Brazil, and Mexico.

The EU contends that including the aviation industry in ETS is not only legal and fair, but also necessary to control carbon emissions. By 2020, the EU projects that the system will reduce carbon dioxide emissions by 13 megatons in the aviation sector. Though small when compared to the estimated 170 megatons mitigated in other ETS-regulated industries, the EU hopes it will serve as a model for widespread global action.


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Dinesh Karthik Changes Fortune with a Great Cameo and Last Ball Sixer

    Dinesh Karthik Changes Fortune with Great Cameo Last Ball Sixer

    Not many may be remembering that 3rd ODI against England at London in Sept 2004 which India won by 23 runs and Sourav Ganguly was the man of the match. Read more

    The 18 March 2018 by   Sampathkumar Sampath
  • Sometimes…

    Sometimes life comes at you in unexpected ways. Sometimes straight on. You see it coming. You are either ready or not, but there it is. Read more

    The 18 March 2018 by   Redneckprincess
  • Change in Plans

    A few weeks ago I found a firm mass in my abdomen. I'm not very conversant with the usual makeup of my abdomen - it's not something I worry about most of the... Read more

    The 18 March 2018 by   Sherwoods
  • 6 Reasons Why Office Gossip Is Bad For Your Business

    Reasons Office Gossip Your Business

    As an entrepreneur, you should treat gossip among the members of your team as a reduction in productivity at best, and at worst, an indication of unhappy,... Read more

    The 18 March 2018 by   Martin Zwilling
  • #LondonWalks Walk Of The Week: Mountain Building & Meteorites in the City of...

    #LondonWalks Walk Week: Mountain Building Meteorites City London #UrbanGeology @R_Siddall

    On Sundays we pluck just one walk from the vast London Walks repertoire and put it centre stage. You can check out the full schedule at Read more

    The 18 March 2018 by   Lwblog
  • Hop Scotch


    Now there’s a touch of spring in the air, it’s time to resume with my travels, starting with a trip into the Kingdom of Fife for three of the matches in the... Read more

    The 18 March 2018 by   Smidrophenia
  • Bubble Guppies Live Review

    Bubble Guppies Live Review

    One night about a month and a half ago I was doing some work for my theater company, posting information about our upcoming production to various listings... Read more

    The 18 March 2018 by   Nesheaholic

Paperblog Hot Topics