Politics Magazine

A Quick and Dirty Guide to Speakers’ Mutual Intelligibility (MI) Perceptions: How Rough Speaker MI Characterizations Line Up with Actual MI Percentages

Posted on the 20 May 2016 by Calvinthedog

Many times, when asking speakers how much they understand of another language, a process known as determining mutual intelligibility (MI) of two languages, speakers will give you a rough impressionistic description of how much they understand of the other language, but they will not give you even an estimated % for how much they understood.

I have been studying the mutual intelligibility of different lects for years now. Most of my work has been in Slavic, Turkic, Germanic, Sinitic and Romance. Over that period, I have heard many offhand MI descriptions of two lects many times. I also heard a number of MI% estimates of the same two lects. In many cases a speaker would give me both an MI impressionistic description and an MI% estimates. After a while, I learned that some impressionistic MI descriptions lined up quite well with certain MI%’s.

Obviously the best way to determine MI between two lects is via a scientific MI study. However, these are not commonly done, and many researchers do not want to do them.

The typical situation for the linguist looking to estimate MI between lects is that no scientific study has been done on these two lects, nor is one likely to be done in the forseeable future. Linguists have to make use of the information we have at the moment, and linguists commonly give estimates for MI of pairs of lects that are not based on scientific studies. Raw MI estimates are used very commonly in Linguistics, even in academic Linguistics journals and books.

With that in mind, here are the results that I learned over years of MI study:

“I couldn’t understand it at all. I maybe recognized 3 words.” = 0-5% MI

“I understand almost nothing, no more than a few words.” = 5-10% MI

“I understood  handful of words here and there.” = 10-20% MI

“I can’t even get the gist of it.” 20-30% MI

“I can get the gist of it or the general meaning but not much else.” = 30-40% MI

“It’s hard to understand.” = 40-60% MI

“I can understand it, but not completely!” = 60-80% MI

“I understood almost everything” = 80-90% MI

Some variation of “I understood it perfectly, no problem.” = 90-100% MI


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • My Umbrella and I

    Umbrella

    I bet each one of you has an umbrella story (or several) to tell. My first memory of an umbrella is probably from the time I was five-or younger-huddling under ... Read more

    The 17 July 2018 by   Vidyasury
    DIARIES
  • Downward Causation

    Downward Causation

    I've argued for the idea that social phenomena are generated by the actions, thoughts, and mental frameworks of myriad actors (link). This expresses the idea... Read more

    The 17 July 2018 by   Dlittle30
    SOCIETY
  • Ikk Panjab Rajouri Garden Food and Restaurant Review #FoodReview

    Ikk Panjab is a synonym of the blissful dining experience. Nothing falls short of expectation here. A place to rediscover lost recipes. There are many factors t... Read more

    The 17 July 2018 by   Jaideep Khanduja
    DIARIES, SELF EXPRESSION
  • A Food-Lover’s Guide to Greece

    Food-Lover’s Guide Greece

    Ah, Greek food! Just the thought of a warm filo pastry with a mizithra cheese stuffing and a cup of dark Greek coffee brings back near-perfectly preserved... Read more

    The 17 July 2018 by   Niviya Vas
    LIFESTYLE
  • 2018 Monsoon Must Haves

    The monsoons have arrived and along with its relief, have come a few of monsoon’s undesired experiences. We tend to not put on our best clothes during the... Read more

    The 17 July 2018 by   Meet Rv
  • SAAM Arcade: Game Spaces

    What does "Game Spaces" mean to me? When we began discussing our plans for this year's Independent Developer Showcase, we knew that we wanted to focus on... Read more

    The 17 July 2018 by   Americanart
    ART & DESIGN, CULTURE
  • “There Was No Significant Association Between Saturated Fat and Cardiovascular...

    Does eating saturated fat increase the risk of heart disease? Or is something else the culprit? And which risk markers should we look at when investigating whic... Read more

    The 17 July 2018 by   Dietdoctor
    DIET & WEIGHT, HEALTH, HEALTHY LIVING, MEDICINE

Magazines