Debate Magazine

Why School Shouldn’t Be Like School

By Stevemiranda

Researchers at UC-Berkeley and MIT recently generated a fascinating set of data. Here’s an excerpt from an article in Slate written by one of the researchers, Alison Gopnik:

In the first study, MIT professor Laura Schulz, her graduate student Elizabeth Bonawitz, and their colleagues looked at how 4-year-olds learned about a new toy with four tubes. Each tube could do something interesting: If you pulled on one tube it squeaked, if you looked inside another tube you found a hidden mirror, and so on. For one group of children, the experimenter said: “I just found this toy!” As she brought out the toy, she pulled the first tube, as if by accident, and it squeaked. She acted surprised (“Huh! Did you see that? Let me try to do that!”) and pulled the tube again to make it squeak a second time. With the other children, the experimenter acted more like a teacher. She said, “I’m going to show you how my toy works. Watch this!” and deliberately made the tube squeak. Then she left both groups of children alone to play with the toy.

All of the children pulled the first tube to make it squeak. The question was whether they would also learn about the other things the toy could do. The children from the first group played with the toy longer and discovered more of its “hidden” features than those in the second group. In other words, direct instruction made the children less curious and less likely to discover new information.

This makes sense. When someone is speaking to you in a “teacher” voice, you assume that they’re the expert and will tell you all the information you need to know. There’s no reason for the kids in the second group to think there’s anything to discover. If there were, the teacher would have told us to discover it, right?

* * *

The title of the article is “Why Preschool Shouldn’t Be Like School.” The author concludes, “Knowing this, it’s more important than ever to give children’s remarkable, spontaneous learning abilities free rein. That means a rich, stable, and safe world, with affectionate and supportive grown-ups, and lots of opportunities for exploration and play. Not school for babies.”

Wait a minute. If this is true, then we need a new article called, “Why School Shouldn’t Be Like School.” Why would we think it’s bad to stunt creativity and curiosity in pre-schoolers, but we’re fine with limiting those qualities in teens?

When a teenager walks into U.S. History class, sits in a chair and takes in a lecture per day as the teacher goes from September through June—from Columbus through the Reagan Revolution—he leaves for summer vacation satisfied that he has learned all of U.S. History. There is nothing left to discover. If there was, the teacher would have told us to discover it, right?

* * *

Maybe we need an article called, “Why School Should Be Like Preschool.” Then we could provide teenagers with rich, stable, and safe worlds, with affectionate and supportive grown-ups, and lots of opportunities for exploration and play. Teachers and students could spend an entire year playing with different events and ideas about U.S. History, and students would go home for summer having learned a lot, but also with the knowledge that there are more “hidden features” still to discover.

(Join the discussion at www.facebook.com/reeducate. Get updates at www.twitter.com/reeducate.)


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • If Kids Do Well in School, Then They’ll Be Happy. Right?

    I’ve been waiting for this book for a while.Teresa Amabile and Steven Kramer’s book The Progress Principle was just released, and I’m about halfway through it. Read more

    By  Stevemiranda
    DEBATE, FAMILY, SCHOOLING, SOCIETY
  • “Flipping School” in a Way That Matters

    “Flipping School” That Matters

    My sister sent me a video link to a story about two teachers in New York City who are achieving some remarkable results with an innovative strategy. Read more

    By  Stevemiranda
    DEBATE, FAMILY, SCHOOLING, SOCIETY
  • Why School Shouldn’t Be Like School (from the Archives)

    School Shouldn’t Like (from Archives)

    Researchers at UC-Berkeley and MIT recently generated a fascinating set of data. Here’s an excerpt from an article in Slate written by one of the researchers,... Read more

    By  Stevemiranda
    DEBATE, SCHOOLING, SOCIETY
  • In School, It’s Not That Kids Aren’t Curious. They Just Might Not Be Curious...

    School, It’s That Kids Aren’t Curious. They Just Might Curious About Things Want Them

    My friend Lisa said to me, “I’m reading a book right now called Being Wrong. Have you heard of it? You have to read it, it’s all about PSCS.” It’s not actually... Read more

    By  Stevemiranda
    DEBATE, SCHOOLING, SOCIETY
  • Fundraising for School Groups

    Fundraising School Groups

    It seems like arts funding in schools are always the first to be cut. It’s a hard decision but with school budgets they way they are the past couple of years... Read more

    By  Mregina
    CHARITY, SCHOOLING, SOCIETY
  • School Bus Safety

    The following tips come from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, www.nhtsa.gov, reminding us that young children need frequent reviews about... Read more

    By  Jean Campbell
    COMMUNITY, FAMILY, PARENTING, SCHOOLING
  • The High School Bully

    Links:Part 1: Bullies and Bullying - An IntroductionPart 2: The Primary School BullyThere are massive differences between the primary school bully and the high... Read more

    By  Gbollard
    FAMILY, PARENTING, SCHOOLING