Home Improvement Magazine

Why Municipal Inspectors Wear Blinders

By Homesmsp @HomesMSP

 
I've taken many building code classes that were taught by the Building Official for the city of New Hope, Roger Axel.  He's a fantastic teacher.  In his classes, I remember him repeatedly telling us to take off the blinders; what he meant by this was to not miss the forest for the trees.  Sure, the deck ledgerboard has lag screws every six inches... but if the house was built with floor trusses, what are those lag screws going in to?  The wall sheathing?  Look at the big picture, keep an open mind, don't make assumptions, question everything.

Deck Lag Screw In To Nothing

Despite this sage advice, municipal inspectors often have to wear blinders.  This blog post isn't about deck construction.  This post is about why municipal inspectors have to wear blinders.  

Here's a common scenario: I inspect a home for a buyer, and I come up with a list of electrical defects that are potential fire hazards.  The buyer asks the seller to fix the stuff.  Two days later the seller calls me, and she's not happy.

Seller: "Hello Mr. Saltzman, you told my buyer a lot of bad information about my electric service.  I just had the Minnesota State Electrical Inspector out at my house last year, and they said everything was fine."

Me: "Why did you have the state inspector at your house?"

Seller:  "I had my basement finished off, and they approved all the work.  They wouldn't have signed off on it if there were problems!"

Ah, but that's not true.  When a permit gets pulled for work being done at a property, the permit fee covers the cost of the inspections to make sure the work being done is correct.  Again, the work being done... not all the work that was ever done at the house.

A $50 electrical permit for some wiring in the basement doesn't cover the inspection of the entire electric service at the house.  The electrical inspector is being paid to look at the work that's being done, and that's it.  If there is a glaring electrical defect that has nothing to do with the work being done, will the electrical inspector require repair?

That depends.  On one hand, the electrical inspector may not have the right to require repair.  If the municipal inspector is being hired to inspect the work that's being done, they have an obligation to the homeowner to approve the work if it's done properly, regardless of whatever else is going on at the house.  If an owner is replacing an electric panel, should the municipal inspector go through the entire house to make sure all the lights are wired properly, all the outlets grounded, and GFCI outlets installed to today's current code?  Probably not.

On the other hand, does the inspector have a moral obligation to report the other defects they see?  Maybe, but these defects shouldn't have any effect on the permit approval process.  If a municipal inspections department begins requiring repair of defects that aren't directly related to the work being done, what are homeowners and contractors going to start doing?  They might decide that it's too much of a hassle to pull permits, because some 'a-hole inspector' is going to start poking around for other problems as soon as he or she sets foot in the house.

Municipal inspectors need to have a delicate balance of what they look at and enforce; if they miss defects, they get labeled incompetent or lazy.  If they start requiring more repairs than what they're hired to look at, people think they're being jerks, and people stop pulling permits.  To a certain degree, municipal inspectors have to wear blinders.  I don't envy the job of the municipal inspector.

If a municipal inspector signs off on a permit, they're signing off on the work that's being done; not the entire house.

Reuben Saltzman, Structure Tech Home Inspections - Email- New Hope Home Inspections


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Through the Eyes of My Expat Child! Lessons Learned.

    Through Eyes Expat Child! Lessons Learned.

    People keep saying to me, “Oh your little girl must be loving the normality of being back home in Australia.” I smile, nodding meekly, not wanting to seem... Read more

    The 26 April 2017 by   Mint Mocha Musings
    EXPAT, SELF EXPRESSION, TRAVEL
  • Taking Stock – April 2017

    Taking Stock April 2017

    Another Month has come and gone!  We are travelling through 2017 far too quickly!   As much as I would love time to stand still for a moment – it can’t, and it... Read more

    The 26 April 2017 by   Mischieviousmum
    FAMILY, LIFESTYLE
  • Soda Sales at Deepest Valley Since 1985

    Soda Sales Deepest Valley Since 1985

    US soda sales are at the lowest since 1985. And they're not likely to pick up soon, as reports about the potentially brain-damaging properties of sugary drinks... Read more

    The 26 April 2017 by   Dietdoctor
    DIET & WEIGHT, HEALTH, HEALTHY LIVING, MEDICINE
  • Cartoon Guide to Biodiversity Loss XLI

    Cartoon Guide Biodiversity Loss

    Number 41 of my semi-regular instalment of biodiversity cartoons, and the first for 2017. See full stock of previous ‘Cartoon guide to biodiversity loss’... Read more

    The 26 April 2017 by   Bradshaw
    ENVIRONMENT
  • Snow in April

    Snow April

    Seriously what is going on with the weather? I woke up yesterday morning looked out the window and was greeted by beautiful blue skies, brilliant I though to... Read more

    The 26 April 2017 by   Ashley Crombet-Beolens
    ENVIRONMENT
  • 10 Reasons to Front-toss

    Reasons Front-toss

    Sitting or standing, underhand or overhand, front-toss is tough to beat.There are several ways to practice hitting. Live BP and hitting off a tee are popular... Read more

    The 26 April 2017 by   Meachrm
    BASEBALL, SPORTS
  • Crooked Federal Judge R. David Proctor, with His Deep-seated Ties to Perjurious...

    Crooked Federal Judge David Proctor, with Deep-seated Ties Perjurious Trump Jeff Sessions, Proves Apple Fall from Tree

    Judge R. David Proctor (center), with family members whohave benefited from ties to corrupt Trump AG Jeff Sessions(From facebook.com)How many ways can a... Read more

    The 26 April 2017 by   Rogershuler
    LEGAL, SOCIETY