Debate Magazine

When Did Moralising Gods Emerge?

By Tomrees8
When did moralising gods emerge?Looking at societies cross the world, you're stuck by the enormous variety of mystical beliefs out there - to the point where, infamously, even trying to come up with a definition of religion that everyone agrees on is pretty much impossible.
Yet there are common themes. Many societies do believe in some kind of chief god, and many of those believe that this god is some kind of parent or leader figure - one that takes an interest in his people, and punishes bad behavior.
So the question is, do societies vary in some systematic way? Is it, as some people have claimed, that complex societies lead to the development of moralising gods?
Hervey Peoples and Frank Marlowe, at the University of Cambridge, have set out to test this statistically - no mean feat.
They used a something called the "Standard Cross-Cultural Sample", which was created in 1980 and which provides an unbiased sample of the worlds societies - representing every region, language family, and cultural area. They're predominantly pre-industrial.
They categorised each society according to whether they believed in an active High God (a single, all-powerful creator active in human affairs and supportive of human morality), a High God that is inactive or remote, or no belief in any High God.
Belief in an active High God was significantly greater in societies that were larger, more stratified (i.e. less equality) and societies engaged in intensive agriculture. Now, all of these things go together - you need intensive agriculture to support a large society, and large agricultural societies have the surpluses and politics that facilitate stratification.
All of this fits nicely with the hypothesis that moralising gods are an invention of large, structured societies. But what about pastoralists?
The thing about pastoralists is that they are vulnerable to the environment - herds could scatter or be devastated by drought. Lifestyles based on foraging and low-intensity agriculture are vulnerable to the same things, although it it easier for such groups to relocate.
Even more important, I think, is that pastoralists have a source of transportable wealth - their cattle. That means that they are vulnerable to attack from other pastoralists (and, indeed, can gain from attacking other groups). And that in turn means that their groups must be cohesive and well-organised to survive.
In other words, they have a very great incentive to punish free-riders and cheats. If a forager goes off the rails, no-one really suffers except him. For a pastoralist group, however, sticking together is all important.
At first blush, all of this is in line with other research that links the emergence of complex societies to the invention of moralising gods. However, that's not quite the case.
The previous research showed that 'world religions' are linked to altruism towards anonymous strangers. In practice, that means breaking down inter-group barriers.
This new research seems to show that moralising powerful gods are linked to stronger group cohesion.
Now, those two results are actually in conflict. But they do reinforce the fact that religious beliefs do not act in a straightforward way.
It seems likely that their effects are quite context dependent - a conclusion, of course, that's borne out by a lot of other research!
Peoples HC, & Marlowe FW (2012). Subsistence and the evolution of religion. Human nature (Hawthorne, N.Y.), 23 (3), 253-69 PMID: 22837060
Creative Commons License This article by Tom Rees was first published on Epiphenom. It is licensed under Creative Commons.

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • What Do You Get When You Have A Drunk Cowboy, Old Woman, And A Mule? Why A...

    An old woman prospector shuffled into town leading a tired old mule.The old woman headed straight for the only saloon to clear her parched throat.She walked up... Read more

    The 25 May 2013 by   Eowyn
  • When Did McDonald’s Start Force-feeding Kids?

    ‘Don’t you want kids to be healthy so they can live a long life?’ Girl, 9,  corners McDonald’s CEO at shareholders meetingDailyMail: She may only be little,... Read more

    The 26 May 2013 by   Eowyn
  • When Even Protexia Doesn't Help

    Protexia is the secret weapon of most Israelis. It is sometimes known as Vitamin P. Protexia opens doors and opportunities that are normally sealed shut. But... Read more

    The 23 May 2013 by   Gldmeier
  • When Rain After Pesach is Not a Curse

    Here in Israel it is normally pretty rare to get rain after Pesach. Every few years we might get a little bit of rain after Pesach, but this year we have had... Read more

    The 21 April 2013 by   Gldmeier
  • When Shabbos Falls out on Tuesday...

    The mishna/gemara talks about a situation in which a person finds himself far away from civilization, such as lost in the desert, and does not know which day... Read more

    The 16 June 2013 by   Gldmeier
  • Ladies: Do You Want to Look Like This When You’re 92?

    What price vanity?Yesterday was the 92nd birthday of Jackie Stallone, the mother of actor Sylvester Stallone.This pic was taken 5 months ago in June 2013,... Read more

    The 30 November 2013 by   Eowyn
  • What Do You Get When You Rearrange PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA?

    Answer:AN ARAB BACKED IMPOSTER !Try this anagram for yourself:P R E S I D E N T B A R A C K O B A M AA N A R A B B A C K E D I M P O S T E RYou can’t make this... Read more

    The 18 September 2013 by   Eowyn

Add a comment