Current Magazine

Was Paralympic Runner, Pistorius in the Right?

By Mmostynthomas @MostynThomasJou

Pistorius is right. Those blades are definitely too long

The furore surrounding the men’s T44 200m final at the London Paralympics, which Oscar Pistorius lost last night, was extraordinary. But while I can understand how guilty Pistorius felt about the timing of his complaint, I don’t see why he shouldn’t speak out at all.

Pistorius’ claim that fellow competitor Alan Oliveira’s carbon-fibre blades gave him an unfair advantage was particularly ironic in light of the fact his own blades was himself the subject of controversy five years ago, when the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF) ruled against him competing in the Olympics – a decision that was eventually overturned.

In his post-race interview the South African accused Oliveira – who beat him to win gold with 21.45secs – of switching blades overnight.  ”Not taking away from Alan’s performance, he’s a great athlete,” said he, “but these guys are a lot taller and you can’t compete [with the] stride length. You saw how far he came back. We aren’t racing a fair race. I gave it my best.”

According to Pistorius, the length of his Brazilian rival’s blades and that of another competitor – American Blake Leeper, who won bronze in the same race – were up to four inches too long. It was a concern he’d brought up with regulatory body the International Paralympics Committee (IPC) a few weeks ago, he said, but it “had fallen on deaf ears.” (Yes, I know: an insult to deaf people. Let it go. The man was upset.)

Four things appear to count against Oscar Pistorius in that complaint. Let’s analyze them.

1. Pistorius didn’t run as fast as he did in the heats. Oliveira’s gold-winning time was 21.45secs – 0.15secs more than the new world record the global trail-blazer set last Saturday. It could be argued, though, that Pistorius’ starting position – which was near the inside of the track – could have made it more difficult for him to apply those long, medal-winning running strides in that race.

2. Oliveira’s blade length was within the rules. It is standard IPC practice to measure all the athletes’ blades at the beginning of the competition. Pistorius’ complaint was that this regulation was too lenient, for two reasons: a. the athletes could change blades easily unchecked in mid-competition; and b. the maximum length the IPC were prepared to allow meant that some athletes appeared taller than they would if they had legs. Unfortunately, as The Guardian points out today, Pistorius’ blades had to be cleared by the IAAF before he could compete in the Olympics. So Oliveira got away with more.

3. Pistorius seems to be the only person saying that Oliveira changed blades overnight. It’s this that makes him appear the most like a bad loser. But should we be dismissing his claim so easily without comparing the footage of the semi-final with that of the final?

4. But they’re all disabled anyway; shouldn’t we allow for that? Some non-disabled people are going to find it difficult to look past the disability. But the point of the Paralympics is that all the sports have been adapted to accommodate the athletes’ disabilities, enabling them to train and compete at an international elite level. So they should already be participating as equals, without further consideration for their access requirements.

Indeed the T44 category for the 200m pitted below-the-knee amputees against each other, in recognition of their very different running techniques to that of above-the-knee amputees like Richard Whitehead, for instance.

Having said that, the Paralympics has come much further than the Olympics in 64 years. From basically an archery competition for paraplegics in 1948, it has become the second-largest sporting event in the world. So their regulations are bound to be slightly more lax in parts than their non-disabled equivalent – especially when you factor in all those disabilities they have to cater for.

In addition, we need to be looking more closely at the replay of the T44 200m men’s final.

In it, it’s clear that Pistorius is taking as long strides as possible, which equates to any non-disabled professional athlete making the most of the length of his natural legs. But while he’s busy overtaking his South African rival, Oliveira isn’t. He’s coming suddenly out of nowhere, which would indicate that he was a long way back to begin with.

Sure, Usain Bolt was the tallest athlete in the Olympic men’s 100m final, and he started badly too. The difference between Bolt and Oliveira is that the former’s legs were the only ones he had – and they were permanently attached to him.

Then there’s the post-race interview. You can’t fail to notice that Oliveira is towering above his translator and his interviewer while he’s asserting that he’s been wearing the same blades for a month. So tall does he look, in fact, that the cameraman can barely get the heads of the other two in shot.

Oscar Pistorius has been winning the T44 200m in the Paralympics for nearly a decade, and his blades have never been particularly long. He also successfully argued for the right to compete as an equal in the Olympics. Don’t you think that places him in a strong enough position to judge what’s wrong with the rules?

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Shilo Sanders- Son Of Deion Sanders Thanks Courts For Allowing Him To Live With...

    Shilo Sanders- Deion Sanders Thanks Courts Allowing Live With Pilar

    ChristianNews Shilo Sanders, the son of NFL Hall of Famer,  Deion Sanders took to twitter to “thank” the courts for allowing him to live with his mother, Pilar... Read more

    The 04 August 2017 by   Firstladyb
  • “I Feel Great”

    Feel Great”

    Jakub went to his doctor's office believing that he had a back injury, but returned with a chocking diagnosis instead. He had type 2 diabetes - in spite of... Read more

    The 04 August 2017 by   Dietdoctor
  • July Allotment Recap (2/2)

    July Allotment Recap (2/2)

    Sunday afternoon saw us return bravely to 24a even though there were more thundery showers foretold by the weatherman. I will admit that I guffawed at the... Read more

    The 04 August 2017 by   Chrryblossomtat2
  • Culinary Delicacies in Croatia- What to Eat and Drink in Croatia

    Culinary Delicacies Croatia- What Drink Croatia

    In my earlier post, we spoke about how Croatia is a stunning European destination, let us now see what are the culinary delicacies in Croatia or what you can... Read more

    The 04 August 2017 by   Kash Pals
  • #Golf Training Aids Spotlight: The Delta Putt

    #Golf Training Aids Spotlight: Delta Putt

    Do you consider yourself to be a strong putter or do you feel you could improve your make percentage on the green? Most amateurs could use help with the flat... Read more

    The 04 August 2017 by   Golfforbeginners
  • Three Incredible Hikes in Southern Iceland3 Min Read

    Three Incredible Hikes Southern Iceland3 Read

    Nature takes center stage in Iceland, where there's a stunning view around every bend: massive glaciers, expansive lava fields, powerful waterfalls, black sand... Read more

    The 04 August 2017 by   Healthytravelblog
  • What I Wore: Daytime Pajamas

    What Wore: Daytime Pajamas

    Pajama top: ELOQUII (14) | Pajama pants: ELOQUII (14) | Shoes: ASOS (similar) | Earrings: J. Crew ( same in different colors, similar concept in same color) |... Read more

    The 04 August 2017 by   Wardrobeoxygen

Paperblog Hot Topics