Politics Magazine

Tweeting Back at Andy Brehm

Posted on the 27 May 2011 by Erictheblue

"I have an op-ed in today's Star Tribune in defense of the Electoral College," tweets one Andy Brehm.  Here it is--the op-ed, not the tweet.  Brehm is the former press secretary for Sen. Norm Coleman, Chameleon-MN, so the Electoral College is evidently not the only thing he's confused about.  Let us examine some of the points he makes.

  • "The Electoral College requires candidates to seek the support of a broad cross-section of the national electorate."  Well, it is a national election, so it would be somewhat startling if candidates did not feel the need to seek a broad cross-section of support.  It seems obvious, however, that direct popular election of the president would make the need greater, not less.  The Electoral College allows candidates to ignore the populations of entire states--most states, as a matter of fact, get no attention during the general election campaign.
  • "If attaining the most votes nationally were all that mattered, nominees would turn a deaf ear to the rural electorate."  Ask the farmers in Alabama, Kansas, and California whether they have in the past few election cycles revelled in the attention lavished upon them by candidates for president.  The complaint about "turn[ing] a deaf ear on the rural electorate" is just a kind of linguistic ruse for dressing up the fact that the Electoral College gives more weight to ballots cast in states with small populations--generally, the more rural ones.  If Brehm is in favor of that, he should say so.  I trust that most Americans believe ballots should have the same weight, no matter where they are cast.
  • Then there is the argument that if presidents were elected in the same fashion as senators and representatives and governors and state legislators and mayors and school board members (most votes wins), then "New York, Texas and California would be king."  Yes, that would be awful.  These three states have more than a quarter of the country's population, but they are ignored by presidential candidates, who spend all their time in eastern Ohio, western Pennsylvania, central Florida, and the southern suburbs of Washington D.C.  If Brehm thinks that's better, he should explain why.
  • "Even the most orthodox of majoritarians should take solace in the fact that the current Electoral College misfires, so to speak, very rarely."  An odd thing to say.  Brehm makes of "majoritarian" a silly pejorative.  Is it a "misfire" or not when the candidate with the most votes, so to speak, loses?  If it is, the remedy, so to speak, is at hand: direct popular election of the president.
  • Brehm doesn't seem to be aware of probably the worst thing about the Electoral College: it has the practical effect of disenfranchising perhaps a third of the voting population.  If you are a Republican living in New York or Illinois or California, or a Democrat living in Alabama or Texas or Wyoming or Idaho, you have no voice at all.  On Election Day, you can stay home or for exercise walk to the polling place and vote--the outcome is not affected by your choice.  Maybe Brehm doesn't understand this but the candidates sure do.  That is why they spend all their time scrambling and pandering for the only votes that matter.

I think the number of Americans who comprehend what a terrible system we have is on the rise.  People interested in an overdue reform should check this out.

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Shilo Sanders- Son Of Deion Sanders Thanks Courts For Allowing Him To Live With...

    Shilo Sanders- Deion Sanders Thanks Courts Allowing Live With Pilar

    ChristianNews Shilo Sanders, the son of NFL Hall of Famer,  Deion Sanders took to twitter to “thank” the courts for allowing him to live with his mother, Pilar... Read more

    The 04 August 2017 by   Firstladyb
  • “I Feel Great”

    Feel Great”

    Jakub went to his doctor's office believing that he had a back injury, but returned with a chocking diagnosis instead. He had type 2 diabetes - in spite of... Read more

    The 04 August 2017 by   Dietdoctor
  • July Allotment Recap (2/2)

    July Allotment Recap (2/2)

    Sunday afternoon saw us return bravely to 24a even though there were more thundery showers foretold by the weatherman. I will admit that I guffawed at the... Read more

    The 04 August 2017 by   Chrryblossomtat2
  • Culinary Delicacies in Croatia- What to Eat and Drink in Croatia

    Culinary Delicacies Croatia- What Drink Croatia

    In my earlier post, we spoke about how Croatia is a stunning European destination, let us now see what are the culinary delicacies in Croatia or what you can... Read more

    The 04 August 2017 by   Kash Pals
  • #Golf Training Aids Spotlight: The Delta Putt

    #Golf Training Aids Spotlight: Delta Putt

    Do you consider yourself to be a strong putter or do you feel you could improve your make percentage on the green? Most amateurs could use help with the flat... Read more

    The 04 August 2017 by   Golfforbeginners
  • Three Incredible Hikes in Southern Iceland3 Min Read

    Three Incredible Hikes Southern Iceland3 Read

    Nature takes center stage in Iceland, where there's a stunning view around every bend: massive glaciers, expansive lava fields, powerful waterfalls, black sand... Read more

    The 04 August 2017 by   Healthytravelblog
  • What I Wore: Daytime Pajamas

    What Wore: Daytime Pajamas

    Pajama top: ELOQUII (14) | Pajama pants: ELOQUII (14) | Shoes: ASOS (similar) | Earrings: J. Crew ( same in different colors, similar concept in same color) |... Read more

    The 04 August 2017 by   Wardrobeoxygen