Fashion Magazine

"Thus Far Shall We Go and No Farther"

By Dieworkwear @dieworkwear

Setting aside for a moment the not-so-subtle sexist undertones of the image above, I found this 1949 newspaper clip about women and Brooks Brothers amusing. The clip can be found framed and hung at Brooks Brothers’ London flagship. Underneath the lead image, a caption reads: “Because the shirttails were long, Bobbie tried to use the shirt as a nightgown then promptly fell asleep.” Yes, I’m sure that’s what she did, dear author, half naked right in front of this photographer.

Undoubtedly, this was a smartly presented piece of marketing using sex appeal, which is amusing for a company that - particularly at that time - was known for its conservatively cut tweeds, foulard ties, and staid argyle socks. Now, whether it’s actually true, as the article suggests, that women were coming into Brooks Brothers to raid the men’s department is unclear. It is clear, however, that Brooks tried to market this idea. The long-legged Bobby Trelease you see above, who came from New York City’s Barbizon Model Agency, worked as a model and Broadway stage dancer at the time. For this particular job, she was given a Brooks OCBD and asked to do with it whatever she pleased. Apparently she found a dozen uses, and the more practical examples were photographed and shown in newspapers’ pages. Those included: a nightgown, a housecoat, and a regular shirt for the office. Who knows how many women actually bought OCBDs for these purposes.

There was something, however, published seven years later in the New York Times, claiming that women have indeed been known to raid the men’s department. The earliest example given was in the 1920s, when women came for men’s baggy polo coats until something was scaled down just for them. Then, in the 1930s, they came for the Shetland sweaters, again until something was scaled down just for them. The most amusing example, however, is perhaps the pink OCBD. Three weeks after they introduced the women’s version, Brooks Brothers’ president at the time, Mr. John C. Wood, issued the following statement:

“About a year ago, Brooks took cognizance of the fact that more and more of its pink shirts for men were finding their way onto women. Brooks was disturbed because the shirts hadn’t been designed with the female configuration in mind and didn’t look as well as they should. We then thought of designing a blouse for women and consulted our friends at Vogue – they advised we do a shirt instead and suggested a pink one, promising to help us rescale the measurements.”

When asked whether or not feminizing the pink OCBD would threaten their sales to men, Wood answered:

“To be perfectly frank, whenever we contemplate changing anything around here, a perceptible shudder goes through the store. In the end, after months of soul-searching, we resolved to risk a restyled shirt for women, but never to restyle anything else for women. We are definitely not in the women’s clothing business. Thus far shall we go and no farther.”

Of course, it did go farther. In 1951, Brooks Brothers’ rescaled their raglan-sleeved raincoats for women, and the following year, they recut their Bermuda shorts. As usual, women get the last word. 

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Influential Conservation Papers of 2015

    Influential Conservation Papers 2015

    As I did last year and the year before, here’s another arbitrary, retrospective list of the top 20 influential conservation papers of 2015 as assessed via... Read more

    By  Bradshaw
  • In Defense of Finn/Poe

    Defense Finn/Poe

    [Star Wars spoilers ahead] Having now seen Star Wars: The Force Awakens four times in eight days, I’m thoroughly obsessed with the movie and have become... Read more

    By  Brute Reason
  • Roatan Review: Barefoot Cay & Barefoot Divers

    Roatan Review: Barefoot Divers

    There's only one place I recommend to travelers looking for the absolute ultimate in luxury during their stay on Roatan, and that's Barefoot Cay Resort. A... Read more

    By  Cubiclethrowdown
  • Don't Be "The Isolator" Christian

    Don't "The Isolator" Christian

    Contrary to popular current sentiment, from those who condescend about "religion" and "the church" and its "hypocrites," and claim to be able to "do God" on... Read more

    By  Elizabethprata
  • San Vicente Marine Sanctuary: A Developing Success in Marine Conservation

    Vicente Marine Sanctuary: Developing Success Conservation

    Have you ever observed something in progress? While evidence of man-made progress is generally observable, Mother Nature takes a rather slow, gradual, and... Read more

    By  Adrenaline Romance
  • Social Saturdays Volume 12

    Social Saturdays Volume

    Have no fear, because in between seeing Star Wars and setting up Grinch traps, our staff this holiday week has not forsaken the vast frozen tundra of the world... Read more

    By  Christopher De Voss
  • Game Change

    Game Change

    What a strange, memorable election 2008 was: Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton's brutal primary fight, John McCain and Sarah Palin's dysfunctional campaign,... Read more

    12 hours, 24 minutes ago by   Christopher Saunders