LGBTQ Magazine

"The Whole Thing Is Simply Beyond Comprehension": Post-Paris Discussions and Lessons from History Not Learned and Unlearned

Posted on the 18 November 2015 by William Lindsey @wdlindsy
US Jul ’38: What’s your attitude towards allowing German, Austrian & other political refugees to come into the US?— Historical Opinion (@HistOpinion) November 16, 2015

I woke yesterday with Etty Hillesum in my mind. When I googled to refresh my memory about the details of her all-too-brief life, I discovered that she died this month in 1943. Etty Hillesum was murdered at Auschwitz in an overwhelmingly Catholic-Christian country in a holocaust planned and carried out by a nation whose citizens were almost all Christian, an act of mass murder in which millions of Jews (and Gypsies, Slavs, gay people, and people with mental and physical disabilities) were murdered along with her. 
In June 1943, a few months before her murder, as she watched a train transport 3,000 Jews east to Auschwitz, many of them infants with tuberculosis, Hillesum wrote, 
The sky is full of birds, the purple lupins stand up so regally and peacefully, two little old women have sat down on the box for a chat, the sun is shining on my face – and right before our eyes, mass murder. The whole thing is simply beyond comprehension (Letters from Westerbork, trans. Arnold J. Pomerans [NY: Pantheon, 1986], p. 56).

In the year in which she was murdered along with millions of other Jews in a holocaust planned and carried out by Christian people, Etty Hillesum also wrote, 
The whole of Europe is gradually being turned into one great prison camp. The whole of Europe will undergo this same bitter experience. To simply record the bare facts of families torn apart, of possessions plundered and liberties forfeited, would soon become monotonous. Nor is it possible to pen picturesque accounts of barbed wire and vegetable swill to show outsiders what it’s like. Besides, I wonder how many outsiders will be left if history continues along the paths it has taken (ibid., p. 23).

1943 is not so very long ago. I was born only 7 years after that, so 1943 is almost my own lifetime. How quickly we forget the lessons of history. How quickly we choose to forget. How easily we choose to pretend — that we are good, holy, and innocent, and someone else is evil, unholy, and guilty.
Sarah Posner at Religion Dispatches yesterday, reporting on the results of the Public Religion Research Institute's 2015 Religious Landscape Survey:
"One of the things the survey is showing is an increased xenophobic streak in the American public," Robert Jones, PRRI’s CEO, told me in an interview. In addition to the increased hostility to Islam, Jones said, the survey found increased negativity toward the contributions of immigrants to society, and increased intolerance for encountering immigrants who do not speak English. "The attitudes are moving in the same direction," Jones said. 
Jones emphasized that the survey was conducted before the terrorist attacks in Paris on Friday, but suggested the uptick in anti-Muslim sentiment was probably attributable to January’s terrorist attacks on the Charlie Hebdo offices and a kosher supermarket in Paris, as well as to the increased visibility of ISIS atrocities.  . . .  
White evangelicals and white mainline Protestants are the most likely religious groups to agree with the statement that Islam is "at odds with American values and way of life" (73 percent and 63 percent, respectively). But the uptick in the percentage of people agreeing with the statement took place across demographic categories, Jones said, as the overall percentage of people agreeing rose nine percentage points in two years, from 47 to 56 percent.

Ishaan Tharoor in Washington Post yesterday, commenting on the tweet by Historical Opinion at the head of this posting:
The results of the poll illustrated above by the useful Twitter account @HistOpinion were published in the ages of Fortune magazine in July 1938. Fewer than 5 percent of Americans surveyed at the time believed that the United States should raise its immigration quotas or encourage political refugees fleeing fascist states in Europe — the vast majority of whom were Jewish — to voyage across the Atlantic. Two-thirds of the respondents agreed with the proposition that "we should try to keep them out."

Elias Isquith at Salon in a chilling but absolutely correct forecast:
If the response to the Paris atrocity is a guide, then a return to the post-9/11 Bush years is closer than we think.
Max Blumenthal at Alternet on how the hysterical fear-mongering (and, let's be honest, cynical political opportunism) driving the response to the Paris events plays right into the hands of ISIS:
Billions of dollars have been spent and hundreds of thousands of lives lost in the global war on terror. At every step of the way, Western governments played directly into the hands of Islamic extremists, falling for their ploys and fueling their ambitions.
Colin Taylor  at Occupy Democrats commenting on the recent testimony of Nicholas Hénin, who spent ten months in ISIS captivity, in The Guardian:
Like the American far-right ultrareligious conservatives who believe a conflict between Iran and Israel that will bring about the End Of Days written in the Book of Revelations, ISIS is doing everything they can to goad the West into invading Iraq and Syria, to overextend and get bogged down in a series of quagmires like the United States did following the 9/11 attacks, to finish out the great struggle between Christian and Muslim that began even before the Crusades. 
George W. Bush's response to the 9/11 terror attacks gave Osama bin Laden everything that he wanted. We overextended and wasted trillions of dollars on useless foreign wars, destabilized entire regions, killed hundreds of thousands, and turned the world against us in a drunken rampage across the Middle East and Central Asia. We abandoned our own values and turned to torture and murder to get what we want. We must not fall into that same trap and make those same mistakes again, especially not to a group of "street kids drunk on ideology and power." We cannot give in to fear and terror; peace and unity are our strongest weapons in the face of unspeakable hatred.  

Justin Salhani at Think Progress
All of the attackers from Friday's massacre in Paris so far have been identified as European Union nationals, according to a top EU official. The announcement further casts doubt on the validity of a Syrian passport found near the bodies of a slain attacker.The majority of attackers were identified as French or Belgian nationals. An Egyptian passport was also found, but the Egyptian Ambassador to France said it belonged to a critically wounded victim and not a perpetrator.  

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • A New Way to Shop for the Most Unique Sunglasses

    Shop Most Unique Sunglasses

    These unique sunglasses represent smart style for women's fashion and are only available for a limited time. This startup has made a line of luxury sustainable... Read more

    8 hours, 19 minutes ago by   Meghashop
  • Who Are the Members of Diet Doctor?

    Members Diet Doctor?

    Who are you? We asked our members and received 1,100 replies: Most members are women, and more specifically middle-aged women. This is a group of people that... Read more

    8 hours, 36 minutes ago by   Dietdoctor
  • Self-Transcendence 3100 Mile Race 2017 – Daily Updates – Day 8 – Alan Young

    Self-Transcendence 3100 Mile Race 2017 Daily Updates Alan Young

    A cool calm (wind wise) start to the day. Usual start up work completed but we lose our Manager of the Drinks Food table. Tomorrow it will be Yuri Trostenyuk an... Read more

    9 hours, 18 minutes ago by   Abichal
  • Beautiful Destination Wedding with Pastel Colors | Gemma & Sean

    Beautiful Destination Wedding with Pastel Colors Gemma Sean

    Chic Stylish Weddings Chic Stylish Weddings - The destination wedding we are sharing today is so beautiful; from the pastel colored flowers used for the... Read more

    10 hours, 24 minutes ago by   Eleni Balkouli
  • The Humor Writing Business

    Making people laugh is no laughing matter. Someone should have told me this before I...oh, wait, a lot of people did but, as usual, I never take advice that run... Read more

    12 hours, 30 minutes ago by   C. Suresh
  • Baptism of My Babies. All of Them.

    Baptism Babies. Them.

    Today was so emotionally intense for me. Three of our seven children were baptized at the church Matt and I met in and got married in. Each one has been... Read more

    12 hours, 43 minutes ago by   Rachel Rachelhagg
  • Asparagus and Courgette Rice

    Asparagus Courgette Rice

    I wanted to cook us something quick and light today . . . fresh, and healthy. I remembered seeing this recipe in the June issue of Food to Love and I had... Read more

    12 hours, 45 minutes ago by   Mariealicerayner