Business Magazine

The New Gtld Discussion Moves to Reddit “nTLD Extensions Are Already Failing”

Posted on the 14 March 2017 by Worldwide @thedomains

The new gtld discussion moves to Reddit “nTLD extensions are already failing”

It looks like the new gtld discussion has moved to Reddit, in the sysadmin subreddit.

User netzvolk started things off:

For those of you that are not aware, the nTLD’s as opposed to the old good .com and others don’t have any limitations on price increases. This means you can register .networks today for $10 and the registry can decide to charge you $1000 next year.

Not only is this extremely risky for anyone that considers developing a new TLD but in some cases they are much worse than standard and traditional extensions because the registries decided to reserve all good names for their own use as premiums. And if you happen to own a premium one, they charge you more, so if .technology costs $30 a year for the public, if you have a premium one, it could be $500 a year just for you. How unfair is that?

The second you have to add 2 words to a new TLD it’s a far worse option than regular domains, examples:

yournewcompany.com (shorter and more credible)

yournewcompany.business

soundnow.com (shorter and more credible)

soundnow.audio

Forget single or dictionary words, because they are all premiums. No wonder they are failing…nobody is going to keep an ugly longer + untrusted extension. Don’t even try to use email on them, most system admins I know, block all of them in their spam filters. ccTLD (country code) seems a far better option for most people today.

So next time your bill comes for domains in your company. Think again. Some may fail in the future and soon.

There are 165 comments so far which is a lot for a topic dealing with domain names.

Now there are some comments that expressed a fondness for .solutions and one member said they got a .rocks for their band.

The disinformation started with lines like enjoy the $10,000 renewal fee. Some believing that if the band gets big they will increase the renewal on what is obviously not a premium name.

Could they do that ? Yes, will they ? I doubt it, that would be a bad pr hit that would in my opinion sink a new gtld. But who knows it is the wild west thanks to ICANN not implementing price caps.

Another member had a take that I am sure Rick Schwartz would approved of.

I’ve always been hesitant to use nTLDs for any public-facing services. Reason being no-one’s used to them yet – you hand someone a business card with a www.namecensored.noiwontfixyouripad as the URL, and half the time they’ll get confused and put a .com after it and wonder what kind of idiot IT guy hands out cards with an email/website that doesn’t work. It’s the same idea behind recommending to clients they don’t register where.do-the-dashesgo.com from 10 years ago – too confusing.

But I don’t mind using them for infrastructure. It’s difficult to get a memorable and short domain on .com that isn’t already taken (short because I’m likely to type it 1000 times a day). I’ll gladly spend (company money on) the $10/year to use public DNS and SSL (via LetsEncrypt), instead of having to argue with every decrepit piece of kit to trust a private CA and ignore the DHCP-issued DNS server.

You can check out the whole thread on Reddit


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Is High Cholesterol Dangerous on A Low-Carb Diet?

    Is high cholesterol dangerous on a low-carb diet? For some people, the "bad" LDL cholesterol goes up, while other aspects improve (like the "good" HDL... Read more

    By  Dietdoctor
    DIET & WEIGHT, HEALTH, HEALTHY LIVING, MEDICINE
  • [NYC] Go! Go! Curry!: Dinner in a Hurry!

    [NYC] Curry!: Dinner Hurry!

    This post is going to be quick and dirty, just like a meal at Go! Go! CURRY! in NYC. After hippoCHAN finished class, it was already pretty late and we were... Read more

    By  Foodobyte
    DINING OUT, FOOD & DRINK, RECIPES
  • Choose the Right Generator for the Right Purpose [Infographic]

    Choose Right Generator Purpose [Infographic]

    Choosing the right generator for the task is very important but sometimes we find it difficult to pick the right one as there are many options available. Read more

    By  Kravelv
    HOME, HOME IMPROVEMENT
  • My Garden Right Now

    Garden Right

    I'm writing this post specifically in order to participate in Michelle Chapman's meme called #mygardenrightnow. If you want to know the full story behind this,... Read more

    By  Mwillis
    GARDENING, HOME
  • Most Sociable and Friendly Cities in the World

    Most Sociable Friendly Cities World

    The most sociable cities of the world were revealed by booking website “Hostelworld” following a study which covered 39 cities in 28 countries. Read more

    By  Poundtravel
    TRAVEL
  • Getting Summer Ready with Herbs & More

    Getting Summer Ready with Herbs More

    Hey beautifuls, hope you all are doing great. Mumbai is burning, and perhaps I am seeing the hottest February since the time I have come to the city. Read more

    By  Jhilmil D Saha
    HAIR & BEAUTY
  • The Atomic Bomb

    Atomic Bomb

    Richard Rhodes' history of the development of the atomic bomb, The Making of the Atomic Bomb, is now thirty years old. The book is crucial reading for anyone wh... Read more

    By  Dlittle30
    SOCIETY

Magazines