Environment Magazine

The Few, the Loud and the Factually Challenged

Posted on the 18 June 2011 by Bradshaw @conservbytes
The few, the loud and the factually challenged

© The Guardian

Here’s a little paraphrased response I received from a colleague who works for a particular agency concerned about the ridiculous politicking and misinformation associated with marine parks proposed for South Australia.

I’ve posted several times before why marine parks are a win for all involved, from the biodiversity it is meant to protect, to the fishers who benefit from the free, public-good resource that they assist in maintaining (see here, here and here). The evidence is clear world-wide: marine parks benefit pretty much everything and everyone.

However, just like the climate change denalists who use every psychological tactic in the book to try to convince people that climate change is a belief when in fact, it is soundly evidence phenomenon, there are those Luddites who think that any change in the marine setting fundamentally threatens their way of life.

Here’s what my colleague had to say about some recent ill-informed comments on this blog:

I wondered when they would find your blog. In my experience, do not engage. A game of intimidation has started.

No matter what you say, no matter how many scientists say it, no matter how strong the evidence, they will not listen. They will just keep on going at you and anyone else who wants to try and defend the evidence in favour of marine conservation.

They will accuse scientists, professors – whomever – who have extensive work experience in reserve design or marine conservation, as being dodgy, even corrupt, but a veterinarian, who has no experience in such matters, is taken as the one truthful scientist? [addendum: I don't know how many times I've come across the god complex in veterinarians - apparently a few years sticking a finger up cat & dog bottoms makes you omniscient].

You can’t respond to that shit. You will just spend a lot of time feeding their anger.

You might have noticed that the number of people actually saying anything negative about marine parks is irrelevantly small. On the anti-marine park Facebook page set up to ‘white-ant’ the marine protected area process in South Australia, the number of true active members is four (yes, that’s right, four).

However, they are a very active four, and become extremely aggressive when you question their commentary. As you know, the climate scientists have been copping it, death threats included, and that sort of intimidatory behaviour probably isn’t far off (unless it has already started) for those working in the field of marine conservation, reserve design and the like.

A certain pro-MPA group [name withheld] had to open a police file in South Australia because of the aggression targeted at their staff. The people on these forums engage in classic art of war – they target individuals to try and undermine the overall strength of a collective. By targeting your blog, this is what they are wanting to do.

We have unfortunately had to block a number of the individuals from commenting on our Facebook page because of the viciousness of the attacks. This decision was taken because the overwhelming majority think these people are mad but it does put the majority off – it frightens them so they disengage and go somewhere else that fits their frame of mind. Classic bully-boy tactics that unfortunately work on the majority.

My advice, do not give them anymore oxygen than is required. If it gets nasty, aggressive or plainly mad, block them.

You are warned.

CJA Bradshaw

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Well, That’s Life

    Well, That’s Life

    There’s good news and bad news. The good news? I found a place to live! Come March 1, I’ll be settled into a cute albeit teeny apartment in Cambridge with a... Read more

    By  Astylizedhysteria
  • I, Flemming


    You will have to excuse the pompous title, I could not resist. Inspired by a comment from Frank Ettenberg I shall post a couple of portraits of yours truly... Read more

    By  Flemmingbo
  • Can’t Keep a Good Cat Down. Or Inside.

    Can’t Keep Good Down. Inside.

    Time for a proper Day of the Cat entry…Ever since I moved into my parents home in the suburbs, the cats have been especially keen about getting outside. Read more

    By  Astylizedhysteria
  • Random/Various and I Am a STAR

    Random/Various STAR

    This weekend all the family were here and Joba came over and Knutty came over to tea. Everyone was much too busy to takeproper photos so this one is a mess. It... Read more

    By  Elizabethwix
  • I've Gone to the "Dark Side" (and a Few Other Lame Reasons Why I Haven't Posted...

    I've Gone "Dark Side" (and Other Lame Reasons Haven't Posted While)!

    Wow, it feels like it's been forever since my last post! If anybody's been wondering where I've been (anybody?), I can sum it up in one word: school. Read more

    By  Danielleb
  • I Want...

    A video with talking cats from the Humane Society to promote adopting kittens. YouTube link (via Neatorama)The Read more

    By  Gerard
  • Wish You Were Here ... Heck Wish I Was There -- Pink Floyd Reunion

    Wish Were Here Heck There Pink Floyd Reunion

    The surviving members of Pink Floyd — Roger Waters, David Gilmour, and Nick Mason — have sworn they will never reunite to tour again after breaking up in the... Read more

    By  Getgoretro