Culture Magazine

Review: Incident at Vichy (Redtwist Theatre)

By Chicagotheaterbeat @chitheaterbeat

Review: Incident at Vichy (Redtwist Theatre)  

Incident at Vichy 

Written by Arthur Miller
Redtwist Theatre, 1044 W. Bryn Mawr (map)
thru Dec 27  |  tix: $30-$35  | more info
Check for half-price tickets  



Minimalist holocaust production lacks payoff


Review: Incident at Vichy (Redtwist Theatre)


Redtwist Theatre presents


Incident at Vichy

Review by Keith Glab

Dripping with dramatic irony, Incident at Vichy involves a group of detainees in France under the 1942 German occupation. For the first 40 minutes of the play, the group debates why they’ve been taken. Finally, someone mentions the word "furnaces" and the characters come to accept what the audience has known all along: these men are being investigated to see whether they should get shipped to concentration camps for being Jewish.

Review: Incident at Vichy (Redtwist Theatre)
Redtwist’s long, intimate space has the audience on two sides of the action. Three benches comprise the only set, the bare walls are completely black, a series of low-hanging lights remain unchanged throughout, and hardly any sound cues are heard. With such a minimalist production, director Ian Frank relies upon a celebrated playwright, incendiary subject, and extensive cast to carry the show.

It isn’t enough. Incident doesn’t represent Arthur Miller‘s best work, with many of the characters lacking substance and the action taking a very long time to develop. While the holocaust remains a harrowingly compelling subject, the play is 50 years old and countless accounts of fiction and nonfiction since have better captured its psychology and its horrors. The cast of 20 do a solid job for the most part, but several of them either don’t have enough stage time to develop their characters or face away from half the audience for most of that stage time.

The biggest issue with the production lies in its overly steady pacing. Several moments warrant a more fervent pace while a sustained silence could help emphasize others. With so many characters onstage and so much evasion of what’s happening, these moments of emphasis prove particularly necessary. With what is obviously meant to be a powerful play, allowing some of the more poignant moments to land would allow that power to be realized.

Review: Incident at Vichy (Redtwist Theatre)
Review: Incident at Vichy (Redtwist Theatre)
Review: Incident at Vichy (Redtwist Theatre)

Jeremy Pfaff‘s performance as The Major highlights the show, exhibiting a broad range of characteristics in his brief time onstage. Tim Parker gives Leduc subtle depth in what you could call the lead role. Jeremy Trager establishes a very distinctive character as Prince Von Berg, though his motivations aren’t always clear. That’s problematic since the play’s final moments hinge on a decision his character makes. What should serve as an incredible payoff instead fizzles out.

Sometimes, all you need for successful theater is a group of talented actors telling a good story. Other times, this results in a bunch of talking heads discussing ideals with the audience feeling less than involved in the action. Redtwist prides itself on taking risks, but Incident at Vichy falls flat in a very conservatively constructed production.


Rating: ★★



Incident at Vichy continues through December 27th at Redtwist Theatre, 1044 W. Bryn Mawr (map), with performances Thursdays-Saturdays at 7:30pm, Sundays 3pm.  Tickets are $30-$35, and are available by phone (773-728-7529) or online through (check for half-price tickets at More information at  (Running time: 90 minutes, no intermission)

Review: Incident at Vichy (Redtwist Theatre)

Photos by Ian Frank, Jan Ellen Graves




Michael Bartz (Detective), Jerry Bloom (Police Captain), Matt Browning (Lebeau), Justin Burns (Boy), Zach DeNardi (Waiter), Tyler Esselman (Police Guard), Jeff Gamlin (Ferrand), David Giannini (Bayard), William Goff (Prisoner), Peter Brian Kelly (Prisoner), Tom Lally (Old Jew), Matthew Lunt (Prisoner), Jim Morley (Monceau), Daniel Mozurkewich (Gypsy), Devon Nimerfroh (Professor), Tim Parker (Leduc), Jeremy Pfaff (Major), Michael Sherwin (Marchand), Nathan Speckman (Prisoner), Jeremy Trager (Von Berg)

behind the scenes

Ian Frank (director, set design), Matthew Nerber (asst. director), Garth Moritz (stage manager), Kelly Field (stage manager, after Dec 21), Melissa Nelson (asst. stage manager), Daniel Friedman (lighting design), Ray Rehberg (sound design), kClare McKellaston (costume design), Josh Hurley (props design), Jan Ellen Graves (co-producer, graphic designer, marketing, photos), Kevin McDonald (dramaturg), Jeff Gamlin (set construction), Catherine Miller (casting director), Charles Bonilla (box office manager), E. Malcolm Martinez (box office associate), Johnny Garcia (box office associate, associate producer), Michael Colucci (co-producer)

Review: Incident at Vichy (Redtwist Theatre)
Review: Incident at Vichy (Redtwist Theatre)
Review: Incident at Vichy (Redtwist Theatre)


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Pull Apart Cinnamon Roll Bread

    Pull Apart Cinnamon Roll Bread

    Who doesn't love cinnamon rolls? Not many people I would assert. I saw this recipe for a Pull Apart Cinnamon Roll Bread on Pinch of Yum a while back and had... Read more

    11 hours, 32 minutes ago by   Mariealicerayner
  • $500 Weekend Blowout

    Well a month ago our $1,000 post was very successful, a number of sales took place and it brought about members engaging with one another to get some deals... Read more

    13 hours, 12 minutes ago by   Worldwide
  • Proliferation of Hate and Intolerance

    Proliferation Hate Intolerance

    Paul Brass provides a wealth of ethnographic and historical evidence on the causes of Hindu-Muslim violence in India in The Production of Hindu-Muslim Violence... Read more

    14 hours, 35 minutes ago by   Dlittle30
  • Unpacked Book Trailer

    Unpacked Book Trailer

    Introducing…The Unpacked Book Trailer!!Back in December, my friend and filmmaker Andrew MacCormack and I got to together for a chat at my cottage in Stanley... Read more

    14 hours, 43 minutes ago by   Moduffycobb
  • Currently....


    Happy Friday folks bitches! Time and Place: 4:24 p.m. At my computer in my home office looking at my dog and counting down 36 minutes until happy hour. Read more

    The 26 May 2017 by   Brisdon
  • ETSY MIX of the Week

    ETSY Week

    1 | Hoop earrings are making a comeback. These solid ones with the v shaped cutout are very pretty (umya, $56.89) 2 | A gorgeous birch wood plate to serve and... Read more

    The 26 May 2017 by   Myparadissi
  • Berghaus Dragon’s Back Race 2017 – Day Five – The Finish Line

    Berghaus Dragon’s Back Race 2017 Five Finish Line

    MARCUS SCOTNEY AND CAROL MORGAN WIN THE BERGHAUS DRAGON'S BACK RACE 2017 Marcus Scotney put aside injury concerns to lead from the front on the final day and wi... Read more

    The 26 May 2017 by   Abichal

Paperblog Hot Topics