Books Magazine

Review: A Medal for Murder by Frances Brody

By Girllostinabook
Review:  A Medal for Murder by Frances Brody Description (from publisher):
'A pawn-shop robbery:
It's no rest for the wicked as Kate Shackleton picks up her second professional sleuthing case. But exposing the culprit of a pawn-shop robbery turns sinister when her investigate takes her to Harrogate--and murder is only one step behind...

A fatal stabbing:
A night at the theater should have been just what the doctor ordered, until Kate stumbles across a body in the doorway. The knife sticking out of its chest definitely suggests a killer in the theatre's midst...

A ransom demand:
Kate likes nothing better than a mystery--and nothing better than solving them. So when a ransom note demands $1,000 for the safe return of the play's leading lady, the refined streets of Harrogate play host to Kate's skills in piecing together clues--and luring criminals out of their lairs...'
My thoughts:
When I read the first book in this series, Dying in the Wool, I thought I had found a historical mystery on the same par of excellence as the Maisie Dobbs series. I really enjoyed the first book in this series and enjoyed getting to know war widow Kate Shackleton. So of course I didn't hesitate to pick up this next installment in the series. While I enjoyed this book, I feel that the first book was a lot better. There was a lot going on at once in this one and it got confusing at times. I hate that I felt this way about this book, because it does have good bones, but it almost felt like the author was trying to impress the reader too much and it missed the mark.
Kate Shackleton's character reminds me a lot of Maisie Dobbs. These two characters share the same time period and knack for using their intelligence to solve crimes. However, just because the characters are similar it doesn't mean that they are the exact same type of stories. Kate has a past and it shows through her characteristics and creates a mysterious aura that surrounds her. This book features heavily on the theater and I really enjoyed that the chapters started with some type of theatrical explanation. That in itself set the atmosphere for the chapters and I appreciate all the thought that it took to come up with that. To be honest, I felt that there was too much going on at once and that it really took something away from this story. It was confusing in a sense to try to keep up with all the story lines.
I know that these books are already released in the UK and they are taking forever to be published here in the United States. I have heard wonderful things about this series, so maybe this book was a fluke and the next ones in the series recreate the brilliance of the debut? The only way to find out is to of course read the next ones released and I plan to do exactly that before I make a serious decision to continue or drop this series. I was a little disappointed with this one as I was expecting more.
Overall Rating: 2.5
Title:  A Medal for Murder
Author:  Frances Brody
Series:  Kate Shackleton Mystery #2
Publisher:  Minotaur Books
Publication Date:  February 12, 2013
Pages:  432
Genre:  Historical Mystery
Get It:  Amazon; Barnes & Noble
Disclaimer: This book was given to me by the publisher, through Netgalley, in exchange for my honest review. I reviewed this book without compensation of any kind. All thoughts and opinions are solely mine.

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Review: Murder on the House by Juliet Blackwell

    Review: Murder House Juliet Blackwell

    Description (from cover):'Bed-and-breakfast--with a side of ghosts.Word has spread that contractor Mel Turner can communicate with the spirits of the dead, and... Read more

    By  Girllostinabook
    BOOKS, CULTURE
  • From Quinoa To a Murder Mystery: All in a Day's Work!

    From Quinoa Murder Mystery: Day's Work!

    QuinoaDo you know that 2013 is the International Year of Quinoa (Keen-wah)? Do you know that Quinoa although may look somewhat like couscous is actually a... Read more

    By  Bookfabulous
    BOOKS, CULTURE
  • Frances Coles

    Frances Coles

    Today marks the anniversary of the murder of Frances Coles on the 13th of February 1891, which is generally held to be the last in the cycle of grisly crimes... Read more

    By  Mmeguillotine
    BOOKS, CULTURE, HISTORY
  • Eden’s Outcasts – A Review

    Eden’s Outcasts Review

    Title: Eden’s OutcastsAuthor: John MattesonGenre: Biography/ HistoryPublisher: W.W. Norton & CompanyLength: 497 pagesI knew I wanted to read this book the... Read more

    By  Akklemm
    BOOKS, CULTURE
  • The Wild Girls – A Review

    Wild Girls Review

    Title: The Wild GirlsAuthor: Pat MurphyPublisher: Speak (an imprint of Penguin Group)Genre: Young AdultLength: 288 pagesDear Publishing Companies,Allow me to... Read more

    By  Akklemm
    BOOKS, CULTURE
  • A Sport and a Pastime - Review

    Sport Pastime Review

    I wanted to love this book. I didn’t. It didn’t satisfy. I need to be gripped by a story and dragged headlong through it. I want to regret closing the book so... Read more

    By  Justwrite
    BOOKS, CULTURE
  • A Review of March 2013

    Let me open by saying that I have two causes for excitement.  First, I had my first sales in March – one on Smashwords and one on Amazon.com- for two different... Read more

    By  Imagineer
    BOOKS, CULTURE

Magazines