Entertainment Magazine

Review #3855: Arrow 1.7: “Muse of Fire”

Posted on the 29 November 2012 by Entil2001 @criticalmyth

Contributor: John Keegan

Written by Geoff Johns, Marc Guggenheim, and Andrew Kreisberg
Directed by David Grossman

Considering that the writers for “Arrow” are taking their time with Laurel’s eventual development into Black Canary, it makes sense that they would want to introduce someone that could help Oliver gain some perspective on his vigilante lifestyle. Dig is already serving that purpose to some extent, but sometimes it takes someone coming at it from a different extreme to prompt self-reflection.

Review #3855: Arrow 1.7: “Muse of Fire”

I’m only familiar with the version of Huntress that was the daughter of Bruce Wayne and Selena Kyle, so I have no idea if Helena Bertinelli was an earlier incarnation of the character. Regardless, Helena/Huntress is damaged on a level similar to Oliver’s, and is also on a quest to correct the sins of the father. The difference being that Helena’s father is alive, and that complicates matters dramatically.

Deadshot confronted Oliver on the reality of his choices in an earlier episode, but given that Deadshot was an adversary, there was little chance of the message getting through. Dig can also play the conscience, but he can only go so far, and he’s not pushing Oliver to tone down the level of bloodletting, so much as recalibrating the scope of his crusade. Helena, however, is far more overt in her lust for vengeance, almost to the point of being consumed by hate.

Helena is a difficult character to render within the world of “Arrow”, because her specific issues run the risk of making her look uninteresting and flat compared to Oliver’s more polished act. We don’t get to see Helena outside of her sullen and defensive moments. I can easily see some viewers saying that the actress is terrible in the part, but I would disagree. I think Helena is meant to be off-putting, to demonstrate what kind of trauma Oliver is hiding (that he would be drawn to someone like Helena) and to emphasize that she may be too far gone to change her ways.

Huntress is therefore a reflection of what Oliver could become, if he doesn’t come to terms with his own choices and recognize the flaws in his self-justification. Oliver has told himself that giving his victims the opportunity to change their ways and amend their sins is sufficient; if they choose not to do so, they get what they deserve. But is that any better than the choices that Bertinelli gives to those he shakes down, or the machinations that Captain Jack must have employed with Oliver’s father? In the end, it’s window-dressing, a pretty fantasy.

To that end, I can easily see this turning into a story arc where Oliver finds Helena to be a kindred spirit in the short-term, but as they get closer and time passes, his misgivings grow as the depth of her hatred becomes clear. If Huntress is a reflection of what Green Arrow could become, then it would make symbolic sense for him to have to fight and defeat Huntress down the line, before he can become something better.

It is now definitive that Captain Jack is Tommy’s father, and somewhere along the line, I missed the fact that Tommy’s last name is Merlyn. It doesn’t take much digging to realize that Merlyn is the name of Green Arrow’s nemesis, which fits the general impression that the writers have given for Tommy’s future role. The fact that he is now cut off by his father, while still trying to live the life he had while Oliver wasn’t in his way, could become the basis for a future turn to villainy. (And it also provides another possible reason for Laurel to take up the Black Canary mantle!)

If there is one flaw to the episode, it’s that the dialogue didn’t quite seem to fit what has come before. Some of the Dig/Oliver conversations were a bit more awkward than usual, and generally speaking, Oliver’s attempts at light banter felt out of place. It’s hard to tell if this was a problem with the script or the direction, but considering Geoff Johns’ track record on “Smallville”, it could be that his initial attempt at writing for “Arrow” wasn’t quite in tune with the material coming out of the writers’ room.

Writing: 2/2
Acting: 2/2
Direction: 2/2
Style: 1/4

Final Score: 7/10


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • “This Diet Has Been Nothing Short of Life Changing for Me and My Family”

    Tyler has been able to truly turn his life around with a low-carb diet. Here's how he massively increased his energy levels and lost 100 lbs (45 kg) in only... Read more

    The 25 June 2017 by   Dietdoctor
    DIET & WEIGHT, HEALTH, HEALTHY LIVING, MEDICINE
  • New Keto Meal Plan

    Our popular low-carb meal-plan tool gives you everything you need to succeed on low carb. Meal plans, recipes and shopping lists - no planning required! Adjust... Read more

    The 25 June 2017 by   Dietdoctor
    DIET & WEIGHT, HEALTH, HEALTHY LIVING, MEDICINE
  • Vegan Rocket Pesto Pasta!

    Vegan Rocket Pesto Pasta!

    I harvested a lot of wild rocket in our garden hey, what to do with it? I knew that I made a previous non-vegan rocket pesto that was so delicious. Read more

    The 25 June 2017 by   Sophies Foodie
    FOOD & DRINK, RECIPES, VEGETARIAN & VEGAN
  • Party Saturday

    According to the calendar, summer started this past week. According to Tajikistan, summer started last month. And so by now, a month into summer, it is hot. Read more

    The 25 June 2017 by   Sherwoods
    FAMILY, PARENTING
  • Sunday Bliss Is..

    Sunday Bliss Is..

    ..baking these adorable red berry and almond blondies in this understated sunlit kitchen. Join the Read more

    The 25 June 2017 by   Myparadissi
    HOME, INTERIOR DESIGN
  • 5 Reasons NOT To Start With A Non-Profit Business

    Reasons Start With Non-Profit Business

    A common misconception I often hear in the startup world is that non-profits are easy and safe, since they don’t have to pay taxes, and they don’t have to make ... Read more

    The 25 June 2017 by   Martin Zwilling
    BUSINESS, CAREER
  • A Day at the Marvellous West Woodhay Gardeners' Fair

    Marvellous West Woodhay Gardeners' Fair

    I received an invitation the other day to go to the West Woodhay Gardeners' Fair; a quick check on the map and I thought it would make a nice day trip. I happil... Read more

    The 25 June 2017 by   Ozhene
    GARDENING, HOME