Contributor: John Keegan
This was probably one of the most anticipated episodes of the season, and for good reason. While most of the regulars have been featured to one degree or another, on both sides of the dual-universe equation, Astrid and her counterpart have been mostly relegated to the background. It’s about time that Jasika Nicole had the chance to shine, and sure enough, it was the breakout performance we were all hoping to see.
Beyond bringing Alt-Astrid into the mix to break down some of the barriers that were lingering amongst the “Super Fringe Division”, we received more backstory for both Astrids than I think we’ve ever gotten. Alt-Astrid’s difficulty over the death of her father was heart-breaking, to say the least. The stark contrast between the two Astrids really made it feel like we were dealing with two entirely different characters, and even though a lot of time was spent with both versions, I was left wishing this could have stretched over a few episodes.
It helps that this episode also had a compelling case. For much of the episode, I was under the impression that the TSA agent was being actively aided and directed by the Observers, which would have tied into the notion that they are, ultimately, the real antagonists of the season. That still might be the case, but in the end, the agent was just a madman with September’s Observer tech. But we seem to be getting closer to the moment when the Observers intervene more directly, now that they are aware of Peter’s existence.
Beyond the interaction of the two Astrids, there was also some brilliant work between Walter and Alt-Astrid. The fact that he was able to appreciate her unique perspective allowed her to give him a different way of looking at past betrayal by Fauxlivia and his issues with Peter. He even remembered her name, to our Astrid’s chagrin!
But the real surprise was the substantial contributions from Fauxlivia herself. We knew from earlier episodes this season that she replaced Olivia in the Fringe Prime universe, largely in the same way that she did in the original timeline. But it hasn’t been fully explained, nor have all the ramifications been explored. It makes sense that this would be a major item of contention in the ongoing truce between the universes, and it had to be addressed.
I have to say, while I enjoyed Fauxlivia more than a little in the third season, I hadn’t realized how much I missed her. She’s always been more playful and casual, compared to Olivia’s more reserved and dour personality, and this timeline has only pushed both characters further in both directions. Fauxlivia’s personality is certainly infectious!
Looking at the broader situation, particularly Peter and his work with Walter on the Machine, I think it’s a great writing choice to have Walter struggle with his deal to help Peter. Walter’s issues are far from simple. While part of the problem may be that this is not his Peter, I don’t see how convincing Walter to consider Peter a true surrogate son is the best option. After all, would Walter want to let Peter go, once he was emotionally invested?
Writing: 2/2
Acting: 2/2
Direction: 2/2
Style: 3/4
Final Rating: 9/10
