Entertainment Magazine

Review #2442: Classic Doctor Who: “Doctor Who and the Silurians”

Posted on the 08 April 2011 by Entil2001 @criticalmyth

Written by Malcolm Hulke
Directed by Timothy Combe

Considering that the previous serial (“Spearhead From Space”) was essentially an introductory piece, this is really the first solid Third Doctor tale. Weighing in at seven episodes, it’s quite a long story, but given that the status quo of the series had undergone a radical change, this length gives the characters time and space to breathe and work through their roles in the team. The Third Doctor, Liz Shaw, and the Brigadier all get better defined, both within the context of UNIT and within the “contemporary” world of 1970.

Review #2442: Classic Doctor Who: “Doctor Who and the Silurians”

In terms of the plot, it’s nothing special for the savvy modern-day science fiction fan, but at the time, it was a neat and unexpected twist on the familiar alien invasion story. The Silurians are, as presented, the original dominant humanoid species on Earth, and they want to take it back from the mammals that have taken over. This leads to a series of confrontations that quickly escalate, despite the Doctor’s efforts to broker peace. After a few deadly biological attacks and such, the problem is “solved” when the Brigadier destroys the Silurian enclave, much to the Doctor’s chagrin.

This all sets up a relationship between the Doctor and the Brigadier that is quite interesting. The Doctor is a dogged pacifist, while the Brigadier is more of a pragmatic military mind. Liz, in essence, is caught between the two extremes, though this presents the Doctor/Brigadier in a more contentious manner than exists. But it retains the notion of the Doctor as moral authority while avoiding the trope of having his Companions yield to his wisdom. (Though I honestly still don’t find much distinctive about Liz.) Still, at the end of the day, the Doctor’s moral certainty leaves him vulnerable to astonishing arrogance. And this time, one cannot say he wins the day, so much as comes to terms with the realities of his exile.

The story is also interesting because it is very much a product of its time. What we take for granted in terms of the treatment of political figures, military tensions, and so forth were “cutting edge” at the time. British society in particular was just emerging from its tradition of not criticizing political figures openly. Not only that, but this was in the midst of the Vietnam Conflict, a proxy battleground of the Cold War, and the Silurians as metaphor for the “red menace” is hard to mistake.

If I have one major complaint for this serial, it’s the musical score. Actually, calling it a musical score is far too charitable. Instead, imagine the most annoying array of noisy instruments, from xylophones to kazoos, and toss them together: that’s the score in a nutshell. I realize that I’ve been spoiled by the delightful bombast of Murray Gold, but even by average measure, this is atrocious.

But in the end, this is one of the most storied Classic Who serials for a reason: it presents a compelling ethical dilemma with strongly written perspective characters on all sides of the debate. It’s a rare example of a longer serial that doesn’t drag in terms of the story. Replace the musical score with something more suitable, and it would be a great character piece with few drawbacks. It gave me a great sense of the Third Doctor, and I look forward to the next available adventure (“Inferno”)!

Writing: 2/2
Acting: 2/2
Direction: 2/2
Style: 2/4

Final Rating: 8/10


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • The Threat of AI

    Kai-Fu Lee has an important op-ed in the NYTimes, "The Real Threat of Artificial Intelligence". He begins by pointing out that all too many discussions of the... Read more

    The 25 June 2017 by   Bbenzon
    CULTURE, PHILOSOPHY, SOCIETY
  • Does Fitness Equal Health?

    Does fitness equal health? Or is there a point where you increase fitness at the expense of health, or vice versa? Finally, can you use ketosis as a way to... Read more

    The 25 June 2017 by   Dietdoctor
    DIET & WEIGHT, HEALTH, HEALTHY LIVING, MEDICINE
  • Enjoy Summer with a Low-Carb Picnic

    Enjoy Summer with Low-Carb Picnic

    Prepare for a great day out with the help of these great recipes. Fresh, filling and healthy food, perfect for a trip to a nice park or maybe the beach. If... Read more

    The 25 June 2017 by   Dietdoctor
    DIET & WEIGHT, HEALTH, HEALTHY LIVING, MEDICINE
  • Beaches

    Beaches

    ! Sand, sea, warm skin, days of freedom and fun. Your Saturday Blogger has a few favourite places on earth and most of them feature a beach somewhere in the... Read more

    The 25 June 2017 by   Ashleylister
    BOOKS, CREATIVITY, CULTURE, SELF EXPRESSION
  • Review - Hardy & Co. Dewy Skin Anti-Ageing Champagne Mist

    I have been using mist as the first step (after cleansing) of my skincare routine for a few years... Click for Read more

    The 25 June 2017 by   Chantana
    HAIR & BEAUTY, LIFESTYLE
  • Be Jealous Clothing: Gingham Trend

    Jealous Clothing: Gingham Trend

    Jumpsuit-Be Jealous*Sliders-F FThis summer has some really nice trends, my favourite is the gingham trend, I'm absolutely loving this gingham jumpsuit from Be... Read more

    The 25 June 2017 by   Sammycx
    FASHION, LIFESTYLE
  • A Day in the Life of a Low-Carb Doctor

    Life Low-Carb Doctor

    As a hospitalist physician, I have the privilege of caring for general medical patients who are admitted to the hospital. I am certainly an oddity among... Read more

    The 25 June 2017 by   Dietdoctor
    DIET & WEIGHT, HEALTH, HEALTHY LIVING, MEDICINE