Culture Magazine

Reading List: Mozart the Dramatist

By Singingscholar @singingscholar
“Opera of all arts offers the opportunity of the most direct expression of emotions by the least naturalistic method.”
“Mozart is charming—indeed, ravishing—up to the very limit of our tolerance of pleasure…. Appreciation of Mozart is a matter of being moved.”

Brigid Brophy’s Mozart the Dramatist is, from a literary standpoint, a treat. Her fluent, sparklingly inventive prose is compulsively readable, and her frequently wicked wit is a delight. The book, thematically arranged, is not a comprehensive survey of Mozart’s “development” as dramatist. Rather, it is an impassioned and fascinating Plädoyer for his cultural significance, and an analysis of his five most famous dramas (Die Entführung aus dem Serail, Le Nozze di Figaro, Don Giovanni, Così fan tutte, and Die Zauberflöte) in light of their eighteenth-century context and in relation to Mozart’s own life. First published in 1964, I read the 1988 revision which includes a preface on Idomeneo and La Clemenza di Tito. Mozart the Dramatist boasts such tantalizing chapter titles as “Women and Opera,” “Opera, Cities, and Enlightenment,” and “Singing and Theology.” Who could resist?
The scintillating confidence of Brophy’s prose does come with far fewer footnotes than I would like. Her analysis of Mozart contains a great deal of eighteenth-century cultural history, argued with great persuasiveness. The comparisons she draws are always intriguing, not least in the chapter on “The Rococo Seducer” which treats Clarissa, Les Liaisons Dangereuses, and Don Giovanni. Brophy draws on painting and philosophy to discuss the enlightenment period towards nature, science, and fantasy. She has a two-chapter consideration of Die Zauberflöte in the context of eighteenth-century interest in mystery cults, not neglecting the opera’s internal contradictions about women. (She sees Mozart as a feminist, and Pamina as an emotionally complex figure with agency. I’m less convinced than I’d like to be, but I’ll be going back to the libretto with Brophy next to me.) She also argues in some detail the why and how of Mozart’s and Jane Austen’s psychological realism.
All of this I found ultimately more fascinating than compelling. It is not only her view of Don Giovanni as an “unconsciously autobiographical” work, “an eternal enigma, an unstaunchable wound in the cultural consciousness of civilization,” which is heavily reliant on Freud. There is little contextualizing or criticism of Freud himself; his categories of analysis are taken as axiomatic. Furthermore—what I found just as problematic, and more irksome—the Enlightenment is continually and insistently placed in stark, monolithic contrast to the Middle Ages. I very nearly wailed aloud at points. Because apparently the eighteenth century invented the concept of the individual, and free thought. And no one questioned the medieval belief system (singular!) which was imposed from above. Really? Just ask Thomas Aquinas about that one! Or Bede, or Boniface, or the peasant who told Jacques Fournier that the devil appeared to him in the form of a tree. This oversimplification does, I think, mar Brophy’s analysis. But it’s still thought-provoking… and it’s still a fun read.

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Reading List: Literary Fantasias

    I read Mawrdew Czgowchwz on a beach, and chuckled through it happily. It's a linguistically exuberant, insouciantly implausible fable in which the outsider is... Read more

    By  Singingscholar
  • Reading List: Christa Ludwig's Memoirs

    Reading List: Christa Ludwig's Memoirs

    "So what you need is a complete harmony of your technique of movement on stage, and the expression of your interpretation, with the music, and with the pure... Read more

    By  Singingscholar
  • Concert Review: Mozart Goes Last, But Comes First

    Concert Review: Mozart Goes Last, Comes First

    Mostly Mozart, with Joshua Bell at Avery Fisher Hall. Violinist Joshua Bell, and four-stringed friend. Photo courtesy Lincoln Center. Read more

    By  Superconductor
  • Mozart, Beyond: "Jupiter" and Vesperae Solennes De Confessore

    Mozart, Beyond: "Jupiter" Vesperae Solennes Confessore

    Iván Fischer, in a recent interview, offered the following paradoxical definition of Mozart's work: that it lies beyond categorization. This might seem closer t... Read more

    By  Singingscholar
  • Concert Review: Grief, Joy, but No Mozart

    Concert Review: Grief, Joy, Mozart

    New world elegance: pianist Nelson Freire. The composer whose name adorns the festival was absent from Mostly Mozart on Friday night, as the Festival Orchestra... Read more

    By  Superconductor
  • When Mozart Meets Fantasy Football

    When Mozart Meets Fantasy Football

    Yeah. You read that correctly. Former Chicago Bears QB Kyle Orton, after meeting a large dragon. Uniform and image © National Football League/ Chicago Bears. Read more

    By  Superconductor
  • Mozart and Vogue

    A blonde Leporello reading a catalogue... which happened to be a Vogue magazine :)). Only Erwin could do that. It happened in Waldbuhne, a few nights ago. Read more

    By  Irinastanescu