Debate Magazine

Paul Krugman: Economist Or Activist?

Posted on the 30 May 2012 by Philosopher's Beard
I hadn't realised quite how single-minded an activist Krugman had become, so coming across one of his columns recently was an unpleasant surprise. In Easy Useless Economics he argues that the economy's problems, and especially unemployment, are all about demand shortfall and that anyone talking about structural problems is lazy, deluded, and/or a hater of the unemployed.
As Krugman puts it,
So what’s with the obsessive push to declare our problems “structural”? And, yes, I mean obsessive. Economists have been debating this issue for several years, and the structuralistas won’t take no for an answer, no matter how much contrary evidence is presented. 
The answer, I’d suggest, lies in the way claims that our problems are deep and structural offer an excuse for not acting, for doing nothing to alleviate the plight of the unemployed.

Really? Can't one have more than one explanation in something as complicated as an economy? Isn't real social science concerned with working out how multiple causal mechanisms interact, not which one is correct? Do people who suggest other - heretical - explanations deserve demonising and insulting? Is that how progress is made in science?
Krugman is in danger of becoming a deformed creature of polemic. No more the Krugman we used to love, the hero of the intellect who won a Nobel Prize, but some kind of screeching Keynesian harpy.Paul Krugman: economist or activist?

You Might Also Like :

Add a comment Report spam/abuse Print this article Share on Facebook See the original article
Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Behavioral Science

    (1958-59 class of Fellows at Center for Advanced Study in the Behavioral Sciences; link) Sometimes the rubric "behavioral science" is used to capture some of th... Read more

    The 26 December 2012 by   Dlittle30
    CURRENT, DEBATE, PHILOSOPHY, POLITICS, SOCIETY
  • The Narcissism of Privilege: The Left Needs to Be More Not Less Aware of It

    “…let’s put aside our differences and start fighting back” says Tom Midlane in a recent New Statesman piece on privilege checking. Or as he so eruditely puts it... Read more

    The 17 December 2012 by   Weekwoman
    CURRENT, DEBATE, PHILOSOPHY, POLITICS, SOCIETY, WOMEN'S ISSUES
  • Bertrand Russell On Religion

    The following two paragraphs are from a speech given in 1927 by Bertrand Russell (pictured above) entitled "Why I Am Not A Christian". Read more

    The 17 February 2013 by   Jobsanger
    CURRENT, DEBATE, PHILOSOPHY, POLITICS, SOCIETY
  • Hierarchy of Needs

    My school does a program with a school for girls from difficult family situations in Pinsk, Belarus. Students travel to Pinskover their winter break and hang ou... Read more

    The 08 January 2013 by   Starofdavida
    DEBATE, PHILOSOPHY, RELIGION, SOCIETY, WOMEN'S ISSUES
  • Marketing to Women: Power to the PANKs

    On the eve of Mother’s Day, I thought it would be important to salute those amazing women who are influential in the lives of their nieces and nephews but have... Read more

    The 12 May 2013 by   Jamiedunham
    BUSINESS, MARKETING & ADVERTISING

Add a comment