Culture Magazine

Mr. Pamuk, Are You a Naive Novelist Or a Sentimental One?

By Jaac
The title of Orhan Pamuk's 2009 Charles Eliot Norton Lectures, The Naive and the Sentimental Novelist, comes, as he explains in his first lecture, from Friedrich Schiller's essay, "Über naive und sentimentalische Dichtung" (On Naive and Sentimental Poetry, 1795-1796). The word 'sentimental' here is a false friend, as Pamuk explains. In Schiller's essay it is intended 'to describe the state of mind which has strayed from nature's simplicity and power and has become too caught up in its own emotions and thoughts.' Pamuk writes about how Schiller had envied what he saw as Goethe's effortless brilliance -- his naivety -- which he saw in contrast to his own more complex tendency to think too much. Pamuk then goes on to reflect:
While reading "On Naive and Sentimental Poetry" thirty years ago, I too -- just like Schiller raging at Goethe  -- complained of the naive, childlike nature of Turkish novelists of the previous generation. They wrote their novels so easily, and never worried about problems of style and technique. And I applied the word "naive" (which I increasingly used in a negative sense) not only to them but to writers all over the world who regarded the nineteenth-century Balzacian novel as a natural entity and accepted it without question. (p.18)

Surprisingly, then, in his Epilogue to the lectures, Pamuk writes:

When I was in my twenties and first read the essay by Schiller that informs this book, I wanted to become a naive writer. Back then, in the 1970s, the most popular and influential Turkish novelists wrote semi-political, semi-poetic novels that took place in rural settings and small villages. In those days, becoming a naive writer whose stories were set in the city, in Istanbul, seemed a difficult goal to achieve. Since I delivered these lectures at Harvard, I have been repeatedly asked, "Mr. Pamuk, are you a naive novelist or a sentimental one?" I would like to emphasize that, for me, the ideal state is one in which the novelist is naive and sentimental at the same time. (p. 189)

Which Pamuk do we believe, the one who speaks first or the one that writes afterwards? Or perhaps there is only the classic Pamuk predicament: that while he thought he despised these naive, childlike writers, all along he just wanted to become one of them -- that he wanted to become somebody else.

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Austenesque Extravaganza - Talking Mr Darcy

    Austenesque Extravaganza Talking Darcy

    This post is part the Travelling Tuesday in the Austenesque Extravaganza at Meredith's Austenesque Reviews. Commenting here and leaving your e-mail address ,... Read more

    By  Mariagrazia
  • Mr Penfold at Unit44

    Penfold Unit44

    Mr Penfold has just finished the latest wall of the White Wall series up in Newcastle. Unit44 have been hosting a series of artists painting the large walls... Read more

    By  Ukstreetart
  • Mr. Self Destruct on His Creative Process

    Self Destruct Creative Process

    THE SOCIAL NETWORKWith Trent Reznor, Atticus Ross and Ren KlyceOn Sunday, I was fortunate to have an invitation to a screening of The Social Network, followed b... Read more

    By  Happygrc
  • Mr. Peanut's New Car


    Mr. Peanut is the advertising logo and mascot of Planters, an American snack-food company and division of Kraft Foods. Now, Mr. Peanut has a new car, the... Read more

    By  Gerard
  • Goodbye Mr Chips

    Goodbye Chips

    On the search for the missing Chip in ChipsteadFrankfurters are not from Frankfurt. Hamburgers not from Hamburg. Port is not from Port Vale and apparently... Read more

    By  Stuartnoel
  • The Bottom Line According to Mr. G

    via That Mr. G Guy The bottom line is this, as long as America has the Second Amendment Right for it's citizens,we will continue to be a free country. Read more

    By  Mikeb302000
  • Sat 23rd April: Jackmode Vs Pelski w/ The Martin Brothers, Hanne & Lore, Mr Ho,...

    23rd April: Jackmode Pelski Martin Brothers, Hanne Lore, Self...

    Only a couple of weeks away, our very special Counter Culture is approaching fast. £8 earlybird tickets are back online, so pick them up at the RA event... Read more

    By  Pelski