Is it “Inhumane” to Take Cigarettes Away from Schizophrenics?
In an article for Brain Blogger a couple of years ago, I looked into the astonishing fact that, as a typical study of impatient smoking among schizophrenics in Britain revealed, about 80-90% of the patients diagnosed with schizophrenia were cigarette smokers. Given that the running rate in the general population hovers around 20-25% on average, this is really quite amazing. It seems clear that nicotine is doing something for a schizophrenic that makes cigarettes into a form of self-medication that almost all schizophrenics apparently discover at one time or another.
A review of relevant studies through 1999, undertaken by Lyon and published in Psychiatric Services, shows unequivocally that schizophrenic smokers are self-medicating to improve processing of auditory stimuli and to reduce many of the cognitive symptoms of the disease. “Neurobiological factors provide the strongest explanation for the link between smoking and schizophrenia,” Lyons writes, “because a direct neurochemical interaction can be demonstrated.” According to Lyon, “Several studies have reported that smokers require higher levels of antipsychotics than nonsmokers. Smoking can lower the blood levels of some antipsychotics by as much as 50%…. For example, Ziedonis and associates found that the average antipsychotic dosage for smokers in their sample was 590 mg in chlorpromazine equivalents compared with 375 mg for nonsmokers.”
In particular, smoking seems to help quell auditory and visual hallucinations. The process known as “sensory gating” refers to lower response levels to repeated auditory stimuli. A schizophrenic’s response to a second stimulus is greater than a normal person’s, and this is also impacted by cigarettes. Sensory gating may be involved in the auditory hallucinations common to schizophrenics. Receptors for nicotine are involved in sensory gating, and several studies have shown that sensory gating among schizophrenics is markedly improved after smoking.
There is an additional reason why smoking is an issue of importance for health professionals. Dr. Bill Yates at Brain Posts has examined a small study by Michael Allen and colleagues in the American Journal of Psychiatry in which 40 schizophrenic patients were admitted to a psychiatric emergency service, where they were given standard antipsychotic therapy. In addition, the researchers randomly assigned either a 21mg nicotine patch or a placebo patch to the subjects upon admission. As Dr. Yates summarized the results:
--Nicotine patches reduced agitation by 33% in the first four hours and 23% at 24 hours. And the reduction was greater than with either the antipsychotic alone, or in conjunction with the placebo patch.
--Subjects with lower nicotine dependence scores tended to show the most response compared to placebo.
--The effect of nicotine replacement on agitation reduction approached the level seen with standard antipsychotic therapy.
As Yates notes, this finding is “pretty dramatic.” It seems to show that acute nicotine withdrawal only makes the situation worse in a clinical setting. The study authors also argue that stronger patches combined with nicotine gum might quell agitation more quickly and effectively. “Encouraging patients with psychotic disorders and mood disorders to quit smoking is an important general health strategy,” Dr. Yates writes. “However, this study suggests that attempting this during an acute psychotic break is probably counter productive and may be inhumane.”
These articles might interest you :
Readers here at the blog will know that I've recommended that adult athletes have a doctor....and that they visit the doctor annually. This sort of medical... Read moreBy Lcreswell
ATHLETICS, HEALTH, MEDICINE, SPORTS
In a scientific article published online earlier this week by Circulation, Eloi Marijon and colleagues at the Paris Cardiovascular Center reported on... Read moreBy Lcreswell
ATHLETICS, HEALTH, MEDICINE, SPORTS
Last time I introduced Andrea Joel and her stellar work at CBS where she is Set Decorator for The Young and the Restless. I posed the question: Where does she... Read moreBy Dplylemd
BOOKS, CULTURE, HEALTH, MEDICINE
Finding a career in medicine can be a competitive process, often highly dependant on training and experience. A medical internship is not only a great addition... Read moreBy Frontiergap
HEALTH, MEDICINE, TRAVEL
Conversations with Healer and Medical Qigong practitioner Darren Orr always prove to be an enlightening and informative experience. I conducted the ... Read moreBy Dianefergurson
ARTS & CRAFTS, BODY, MIND, SPIRIT, LIFESTYLE, SELF EXPRESSION, SPIRITUALITY
The Seattle Times has a wonderful story about medical marijuana users and gun rights. Cynthia Willis calls up and down the firing range to be sure everyone ... Read moreBy Mikeb302000
Adventure Medical Kits has a great reputation for producing a wide variety of excellent first aid kits for just about any outdoor activity. Read moreBy Kungfujedi
MOST POPULAR FROM HEALTH
- Top 10 Health Benefits of Bitter Melon (Bitter Gourd)-Bitter Melon Capsules By Planet Ayurveda by Dr Vikram Chauhan
- A Flacid Bladder Question for Trudy by Trudytriumph
- Pork Shoulder Chops with Roasted Cauliflower Parmesan and Herb Butter by Dietdoctor
- Heroin in Vietnam: The True Story of the Robins Study by Dirkh