Health Magazine

Making a Buck by Passing the Buck

Posted on the 25 November 2012 by Fadi Bejjani @DrFadiBejjani
Referral is another name for this game. A doctor is never penalized or charged for over-referring. Not only it is considered good practice but also good cover your but and good business. Starting with the latter a bona fide game of Ping Pong starts between specialists whether sending the same patient back and forth or I send you one you send me one. Some hospitals who stand to gain a lot of dineros from procedures may even double the bet: you send us one we will give you two!
A classic scenario usually goes like this: primary care doc sends back patient to an orthopedist. The latter reluctantly cannot jump to the knife right away (case management and all) so he orders some physical therapy. A couple of months later, patient comes back still in pain so the orthopod refers him to a pain specialist. The latter schedules a series of spine injections. Patient returns a few months later to the orthopod. Of course he is deemed still not improved but his MRI is inconclusive so he is sent back to the pain doc for a discogram, the results of which usually give the orthopod the license to cut he was waiting for, complements of the grateful pain doc. About 3 months later, the patient with more hardware in his back than the Eiffel Tower, is in even more pain so he gets sent back to the pain doc who rachets the pain meds to a point. Patient is still miserable so a trial of spinal neurostimulator is now warranted, which basically aims at distracting the pain versus eliminating it. Patient is deemed to have passed the trial successfully, whether it is true or not, so now he is referred back to the spine surgeon for permanent implantation of said stimulator (another open procedure under general anesthesia). As this Ping Pong game continues, the doctors and the device manufacturers prosper (or at least the latter) and more GDP is gobbled up by the US healthcare system. Of course the very expensive stimulator usually stops working within a year and occasionally the Ping Pong game includes another match: implantation of a morphine pump. More often the patient now has put in enough time in pain, misery and out-of-work time to qualify for disability income from Social voila, le tour est joué! as the French would say.
Besides the above duet or trio ensembles, larger ones are common ground in multidisciplinary practices, i.e. quintet or sextet. A patient walks into his generalist complaining of joint pain. After the usual history and physical, he gets referred to the colleague next door who happens to be a rheumatologist. Same scenario, different blood work and now a referral to the orthopedic surgeon partner. Noblesse oblige, the latter has to obtain various imaging tests so the patient is off to the radiologist of the group. God forbid the surgeon smells anything operable, the patient then has to see a cardiologist to clear him for surgery. More tests are done in the practice's laboratories. Often, for "convenience" of course, there is a pharmacy on site and the medications are provided there as they are prescribed by the members of the medical quintet. In this case referrals are indirectly lucrative to the various members of that quintet whom are all partners of the medical corporation. There is clearly NO incentive to cure the patient swiftly and definitively. It would be bad for business and not tolerated by the administrators. The longer the patient is in this loop the better...unless of course his insurance runs out, then his healh is deemed to have improved drastically over night and he is discharged.
Although lawyers for example can refer to each other to their hearts content, doctors are legally barred from doing so by the STARK Laws so. Nonethess the above scenarios seem to be convenient loopholes to get around these laws. Another example of the proverbial toothpaste tube: you press on one end and the paste exits the other end.
If a doctor, mindful of the DO NO HARM clause in the Hippocratic Oath, and maybe also responsible enough to be concerned with the rising healthcare costs, has the temerity to adopt "The buck stops here" approach  instead of the "passing the buck" approach by refusing to play the referral game, all hell breaks loose: he will get no referrals from his colleagues because he does not "play ball" and if he manages to survive from word-of-mouth patient referrals because they see in him the real deal, the colleagues' ire and jealousy will increase even more and they will not hesitate to complain about him to the Medical Boards. The latter are usually manned by old timers who grew up in a different era when the medical referral game was the only game in town and the medical specialties were so stringently defined that you practically needed a visa to venture from one to another.
The advent of minimally invasive techniques and technologies did blur those specialty boundaries, especially between conventionally surgical and non-surgical specialties, but the carriers stubbornly call them experimental so as not to pay for them and the Medical Boards maintain a very skewed interpretation of the certificates they award which read unambiguously "License to Practice Medicine and Surgery".
To end on a historical note, Dr Watanabe who invented knee arthroscopy in the mid 1970s was a Japanese rheumatologist. Need I say more!

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Making the Switch's here. Something epic. Yep. Life changing. For real. Melissa and I are starting a new video series to help you (the consumer) sift through all the... Read more

    By  Asullivan
  • Tara Buck Helps AfterBuzzTV Review True Blood 5.02 – ‘Authority Always Wins’

    Tara Buck Helps AfterBuzzTV Review True Blood 5.02 ‘Authority Always Wins’

    AFTERBUZZ TV — True Blood edition, is a weekly “after show” for fans of HBO’s True Blood.In this show, host Jenna Busch breaks down the episode and there to hel... Read more

    By  Thevault
    TV & VIDEO
  • The Wine Making Process

    Wine Making Process

    Before this past weekend, I visited vineyards twice: once as a child and once on an awesome assignment for Needless to say I never really got to... Read more

    By  Alustforallseasons
  • Making Decisions.

    Over the past few days I've made some decisions about where I want my life 'to go.' Last night as I sat watching a programme about old people in poverty in the... Read more

    By  Threesixfive
  • Passing Cloud

    Passing Cloud

    “Passing Cloud” is a transportation project presented by Portuguese architect Tiago Barros Made by rounded ballons covered by a nylon texture, Passing Cloud... Read more

    By  Vecie78
  • Kevin M Buck - Musick for the New Aeon

    Kevin Buck Musick Aeon

    Let’s get serious. We are not going to dance or throw back double shots of Maker’s Mark. Well, maybe we will. But, first, on his new album, Musick for the New... Read more

    By  Ripplemusic
  • The Bitter End Of Howard “Buck” McKeon (R-CA)

    Click on this one:The Bitter End Of Howard “Buck” McKeon (R-CA).I’m passing this on to you. I’m tired of all the corrupt politicians that run our lives and... Read more

    By  Btchakir