Culture Magazine

Known and Unknown

By Cris

Jerry Coyne has been on a tear lately; even if I don’t agree with everything he says I admire his willingness to tackle the big issues and talk straight. He recently posted on free will and made a case for strict determinism, along with these assertions:

Therefore, even if determinism reigns (and, if it does, there’s no free will under my definition), that doesn’t mean that we can predict our future behaviors from what we know now. Certainly the predictability of decisions made under experimental conditions undermines our traditional notions of free will.

The hard problem here is the gaping chasm between accepting physical determinism in theory and predicting behavior in practice. Freeman Dyson recently addressed this in his review of Daniel Kahneman’s Thinking, Fast and Slow:

The scope of Kahneman’s psychology is necessarily limited by his method. His method is to study mental processes that can be observed and measured under rigorously controlled experimental conditions. Following this method, he revolutionized psychology. He discovered mental processes that can be described precisely and demonstrated reliably.

Since strong emotions and obsessions cannot be experimentally controlled, Kahneman’s method did not allow him to study them. The part of the human personality that Kahneman’s method can handle is the nonviolent part, concerned with everyday decisions, artificial parlor games, and gambling for small stakes. The violent and passionate manifestations of human nature, concerned with matters of life and death and love and hate and pain and sex, cannot be experimentally controlled and are beyond Kahneman’s reach.

Known and UnknownWe are a long way from knowing everything and our current models fall short. This doesn’t mean they will always fall short or we should resort to metaphysics where knowledge fails us, but it does mean that we should beware hubris because we know that science is never complete.

There is a sense in which science is always just at the beginning. The state of scientific knowledge will be dramatically different two hundred years from now and today’s understandings will look quaint or even primitive.

I was recently reminded of these beginnings, and future unfoldings, while reading this Nature report on quantum entanglement (or what Einstein called “spooky action at a distance”) and this reasonable take on Daryl Bem’s psi research. The world is weird and wonderful.

Share

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Want Fast Food? Get Some Fruits

    If you really consider the definition of fast food, food that can be prepared quickly, and can be a quick meal, fruit absolutely falls under that category. Read more

    The 14 July 2015 by   Glasgow Skinner/ My Life On And Off The Guest List
    LIFESTYLE
  • Why What We Wear To Work Actually Matters

    How much time do you spend getting ready for work? I remember watching my mother get ready for work in the mornings as a little girl. Read more

    The 13 July 2015 by   Juliez
    SOCIETY, WOMEN'S ISSUES
  • With FlipKart - #AbHarWishHogiPoori

    Have a look at the video - shows the boundless joy wishes bring. There are times when our creative side itches to do something extra-ordinary. Read more

    The 14 July 2015 by   Sarusinghal
    SELF EXPRESSION
  • What I Love About Minho?

    What I love about Minho, tells you the story about the wonders of this ever-green region in the North of Portugal. It is the home of green wine, bacalhau (salt... Read more

    The 14 July 2015 by   Nelsoncarvalheiro
    FOOD & DRINK, TRAVEL
  • That's Shalott

    It all started when I watched It Follows this week...I am a sucker for a 'curse' film, where the likeable protagonist accidentally gets the attention of a grump... Read more

    The 14 July 2015 by   Kirsty Stonell Walker
    CULTURE
  • Competition: Taste Cocktails, Margarita Kit.

    Taste Cocktails are giving away one of their new Summer cocktail kits which contains everything you need to make the perfect Margarita at home. The... Read more

    The 13 July 2015 by   Evette Garside
    FAMILY
  • Monte Cahn Named As One Of Top 400 CEO’s to Follow On Twitter

    StrategicObjectives.com, published The Ultimate List of Social CEO’s on Twitter @SO_pr and my partner in RightoftheDot.com made the very impressive list of 400. Read more

    The 13 July 2015 by   Worldwide
    BUSINESS, TECH

Add a comment