Judges and Bloggers of One MindPosted on the 27 May 2011 by Seabee
A very interesting report appeared in The National yesterday including comments from several judges about the sentences they often hand down for people found guilty of indecency.
"Public decency laws need to be reformed so that punishments can more accurately reflect the severity of the offence, several judges have said."
I've questioned in various posts on the subject whether the courts had any discretion in the sentences they hand down, or whether they are mandatory. The judges quoted in the report have answered that.
"While sentencing guidelines for more serious crimes allow judges discretion in weighing the facts of a particular case, guidelines for minor crimes concerning public decency often force them into overly harsh sentences."
"An expatriate who has committed an offence such as raising his hand in a bad gesture should be punished, but not by destroying his chances of returning to this country to make a living," one lower court judge said. More serious crimes such as theft were not punished by deportation, he pointed out."
The courts have taken some stick, especially in the overseas press, over their draconian sentencing but it seems they have little room for discretion.
In fact judges, or at least some of them, seem to be of the same opinion as us.
It's a fascinating insight into the legal system here in The National.
You Might Also Like :
These articles might interest you :
Gerald Bard TjoflatIf I ran a video of a bank executive stealing money from a vault, it probably would go viral--and the public, understandably, would be... Read moreBy Rogershuler
I love tennis books! I love reading them but I also love giving them to all of my favorite tennis pals as gifts. And this week, I've got a fabulous one for... Read moreBy Kselz
Growing up in the province of Milan, the presence of various panettoni in the house was reliably the earliest indicator that the Christmas season had returned.... Read moreBy Paolo
FOOD & DRINK
It really does feel like the final sprint now! Five more posts and then we're home, so I best get on with today's offering...La Bella Mano (1875) Dante Gabriel... Read moreBy Kirsty Stonell Walker
Isaiah 7:10-16"The Life of Christ: The Virgin Birth" S. Lewis JohnsonI liked how Pastor S. Lewis Johnson emphasized the virgin conception rather than the... Read moreBy Elizabethprata
Paris was less crowded than when we visited in July, and there were far fewer tourists in town. So this time I had much better luck with street style photos. Read moreBy Unefemme
It is hard to believe that 2016 is quickly drawing to an end, and soon we'll turn the page to a new year. That means lots of new opportunities of course, and a... Read moreBy Kungfujedi
MOST RECOMMENDED IN LEGAL
- Ashley Madison records show Alabama tax attorney Thomas Mancuso has been looking for a woman who wants "to be licked" or "taken from behind" by Rogershuler
- U.S. Sen. Luther Strange's appointment of Kevin Turner as chief of staff emits the foul odor of blackmail and a "secret" that must be kept under wraps by Rogershuler
- Trump AG Jeff Sessions likely will be dragged into Michael Flynn scandal after serving as chairman over Flynn on two national-security committees by Rogershuler
- Judge R. David Proctor's corrupt opinion in "The House Case" suggests Jeff Sessions & Co. have engaged in obstruction of justice and perhaps other crimes by Rogershuler