Current Magazine

Judge Ends Live TV Coverage of Mubarak Trial, Postpones Until September

Posted on the 15 August 2011 by Periscope @periscopepost
Judge ends live TV coverage of Mubarak trial, postpones until September

The televised trial of Hosni Mubarak. Photo credit: Maggie Osama,

Amid chaotic scenes inside and outside the courtroom, the judge in the trial of Egypt’s former president Hosni Mubarak announced Monday that the trial would be adjourned until September. BBC News reported that Judge Ahmed Rifaat also banned further live television coverage of the trial, and decided to combine the two sets of charges against Mubarak  - of corruption and the murder of protesters – into a single trial.

As on the trial’s first day on August 3, Mubarak’s second appearance in court Monday was marked by angry scuffles on the street between Mubarak’s supporters and opponents, as this video from The Guardian shows. Proceedings inside the building were scarcely less acrimonious, and The Guardian reported earlier that Judge Rifaat was losing his patience with the chaos in the courtroom, something which may have prompted his decision to adjourn the trial. Egyptian reaction to the decision to end the live television coverage has been mixed, to say the least.

  • To TV or not to TV? The original decision to broadcast the trial live on Egyptian TV was seen as a major concession to pro-democracy campaigners. As Evan Hill wrote for Al Jazeera last week, “Mubarak’s trial will be unprecedented – a televised catharsis for millions of Egyptians who took to the streets in January and February united primarily in their hatred of the regime he oversaw for 30 years.” Egyptians who saw the broadcast of the trial as a symbol of a new, more open and democratic Egypt are furious that it is moving behind closed doors. Reuters spoke to  a member of the public who had been watching the trial and who called the decision “preposterous.” Sherif Mohamed claimed that “The case is necessary for public opinion. Not airing it live means there is a deal with Mubarak.” However, Al Jazeera’s live blog coverage of the trial charted reaction to the decision on Twitter, and concluded, “Initial anger has subsided into debate over necessity. Some say that Rifaat’s order is correct, because it will prevent witnesses from hearing others’ testimony, and that journalists, lawyers and victims’ families still allowed inside the courtroom will still be able to act as watchdogs.”
Judge ends live TV coverage of Mubarak trial, postpones until September

Hosni Mubarak, before the revolution. Photo credit: World Economic Forum

  • President in a cage. A major aspect of the debate around the trial is the presentation of Mubarak himself. The sight of the apparently frail 83-year-old strapped to a hospital trolley and giving testimony from inside a cage has divided opinion, even among those Egyptians who want to see him brought to justice. “Mubarak trial: humiliation continues” was how The Voice of Russia put it, although Egyptian novelist Alaa al-Aswany wrote in The Daily Beast that the sight of the former leader reduced to such ignominy had symbolic importance. “I think this is a very important moment, to see Mubarak in the cage,” he said. “It’s a great moment in Egyptian history and the history of the whole region. It’s a turning point. From now on, the president will never be the father of the people or the symbol of the country. He’s going to be a public servant who works for the people, and when he makes mistakes, or commits crimes, he is going to be brought to justice.” However, Hannah Allam, writing in The Miami Herald, explained that even anti-Mubarak Egyptians had mixed feelings about their ex-president lying in a cage on TV. “He’s a criminal and he must receive punishment,” said one protester who went on to admit, “OK, I felt pity for him. I’m not going to lie. What can I say? Egyptians are too kind-hearted.”
  • The meaning of the trial. Whatever Egyptians’ personal feelings about the humiliation of Mubarak, it remains to be seen whether the trial – live on TV or not – will satisfy the demands of the democracy movement in the country. As Richard Spencer explained in The Telegraph, to do so the trial would have to serve both as symbolic retribution for Mubarak’s alleged crimes, and as an example of how much progress, if any, Egypt has made as a bastion of human rights and openness. Referring to the acrimony that has accompanied the trial so far, Spencer wrote that “Some will say that the raucousness of events are a welcome relief from the silence of repression. But the loneliness of judges as they weigh such competing demands is a fitting image of the fragility of revolutionary ideals.”

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Five Things I Loved About My Wedding – Kayleigh

    Five Things Loved About Wedding Kayleigh

    This is the fourth in a series of blog posts with a focus on those little things that make a wedding special. It is called Five Things I Loved About My Wedding. Read more

    The 24 May 2017 by   Wedincentralpark
  • Democracy and the Politics of Intolerance

    Democracy Politics Intolerance

    A democracy allows government to reflect the will of the people. Or does it? Here I would like to understand a bit better the dynamics through which radical... Read more

    The 24 May 2017 by   Dlittle30
  • Cable Girls – 1920s Era Women with a Modern Twist

    Cable Girls 1920s Women with Modern Twist

    Las Chicas del Cable – four women in 1920s Madrid – Cloche hats, colorful flapper frocks and bobbed hair. What’s not to enjoy about the new Netflix produced... Read more

    The 24 May 2017 by   Glamourdaze
  • BADASS Art Journal Page - All of Me....

    BADASS Journal Page Me....

    Embracing all parts of me and surrounded by miracles - Art Journal PageI found a couple of passports photos of myself recently and I was criticizing them becaus... Read more

    The 24 May 2017 by   Realityarts
  • Dutch Apple Loaf

    Dutch Apple Loaf

    This Dutch Apple Loaf is my kind of cake, soft and moist,  and filled with juicy chunks of apple and pecan nuts.  For a lovely hint of sweetness I have... Read more

    The 24 May 2017 by   Shadesofcinnamon
  • A Jumbo Passion Project

    The climber, facing away from the wall, gingerly peers over his toes to watch his sky-blue T-shirt flutter to the ground. He takes a deep breath, then turns in... Read more

    The 24 May 2017 by   Thervproject
  • Top 3 Dim Sum Restaurants in Chinatown

    Restaurants Chinatown

    Chicago’s Chinatown is home to some of the best restaurants in the city. Sundays can be especially crowded in this area, usually around brunch, as dim sum, a... Read more

    The 24 May 2017 by   Urbanmatter Chicago