Home Magazine

Ionization Vs. Photoelectric Smoke Alarms

By Homesmsp

Do you know what type of smoke alarms you have in your house?   There are two basic types of residential smoke alarms - ionization and photoelectric.  The vast majority of smoke alarms in use today are the ionization type, but they're being questioned more and more as a valid detection method; today they're no longer allowed as the only type of residential smoke alarms in IowaVermont,  and Massachusetts.

Why all the bad press about ionization smoke alarms?

One of the major problems with ionization smoke alarms is that they give off too many false alarms - mostly from cooking and showers.  When a smoke alarm goes off every time someone cooks bacon, people remove the battery or take down the smoke alarm. Manufacturers require them to be installed away from kitchens and bathrooms, but there is no hard and fast rule for clearance requirements across different manufacturers.  Some cities, such as Minneapolis, have implemented even stricter requirements for ionization smoke alarms; they require smoke alarms that are within 20' of a cooking appliance to either be of the photoelectric type, or to have a hush button.

Recent statistics show that in 24% of home fire deaths, smoke alarms were present but did not sound; in half of those cases, there was a missing or disconnected battery.  This is a common problem that I find all the time while doing Truth-In-Sale of Housing evaluations, and the reason people always give is that the smoke alarm goes off every time they cook or shower.

The other problem with ionization smoke alarms is that they take a long time to respond to a smoldering fire - they're tens of minutes slower than photoelectric alarms (page 17).   Estimates show that at least one third of home fatal fires involve a significant smoldering period (page 14).   This is the major reason that there is such a push to replace ionization smoke alarms with photoelectric smoke alarms.  The diagram and text below comes from a handout published by the CPSC, showing how a photoelectric smoke alarm will give occupants much more time to escape in the event of a smoldering fire.

Smoldering Fire

In the event of a smoldering fire, a photoelectric smoke alarm clearly outperforms the ionization type.  So why do we even have ionization alarms?  The main reason is cost.  Photoelectric smoke alarms typically cost about twice as much as the ionization type.  The other reason is that ionization smoke alarms will outperform photoelectric alarms in the event of a fast moving fire.  The faster reaction time can be measured in tens of seconds, but in the event of a fast moving fire, these are precious seconds.  The diagram below, again from the CPSC, helps to illustrate this.

Fast Moving Fire

Most Smoke Alarms are the Ionization Type

I've been hearing more and more about this push, but after recently listening to an impassioned speech on the benefits of photoelectric smoke alarms over ionization alarms, I started taking an informal inventory of the smoke alarms that are installed in Minnesota homes.  Over the past few weeks, I've inspected every smoke alarm in every house I've inspected to get an idea of what's the most common type used in Minnesota.  Out of the dozens of smoke alarms I've looked at, I found one dual-sensor smoke alarm, which employed both ionization and photoelectric technologies.  The rest of the smoke alarms were the ionization type only.  I didn't come across a single photoelectric unit.

To know the difference between ionization and photoelectric alarms, you need to take the smoke alarm down and look at the back.  Ionization alarms all contain a trace amount of a radioactive material, Americium 241.  They'll all have a warning about this on the back side.  Click on any of the thumbnails below to see a blowup of the text on the back side of a smoke alarm - I marked up the labeling that indicates these are ionization alarms in every photo.

First Alert SA86RAC Back 2 Marked Up First Alert SA67D Back 3 Marked Up Firex i4618 Back Marked Up Firex 120-1056C Back Marked up Family Guard FG888D Back Marked Up BRK Electronics 1839WN Back 2 Marked Up Kidde 0914 Back Marked Up

Minnesota Requirements

Minnesota currently has no specific requirements when it comes to ionization vs photoelectric smoke detectors.  Smoke alarms are generally required in bedrooms and in common areas on every level of the home in Minnesota, and they need to be hardwired and interconnected when possible.  You can read the full requirements for smoke alarms in Minnesota here.

My Recommendation

I recommend installing both photoelectric and ionization smoke alarms, or smoke alarms that use both technologies called dual alarms.  Some people argue that these alarms shouldn't be used because there could be more nuisance tripping due to the ionization sensor, which would cause the occupants to disable the smoke alarm.  While this is obviously a possibility, proper placement of smoke alarms and better education about how they operate is the best way to make a home safer.

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • 5 Next-generation Headphones You Might Want to Buy

    A headphone is no longer limited as a tool to listen the music. From playing games to watching movies - listening podcasts to attending phone calls - or just... Read more

    The 10 April 2015 by   Gaurav Tiwari
  • A Temple for Everlasting Beauty!

    The Deivanayakeswarar Temple at ElumiyankotturThere are temples to fulfill every kind of prayer - good health, marriage, childbirth, education, dosha nivarthi... Read more

    The 11 April 2015 by   Priyabaskar
  • Top 10 Short Anime with Badass Main Character and Most Powerful

    Do you like anime? Well, I think who don’t. First let me tell you that there is a big difference between anime and cartoons. Cartoons are the animation that... Read more

    The 10 April 2015 by   Rohit Sharma
  • Becoming Julia

    This week I am delighted to report I had a dream come true. I became Julia Margaret Cameron. For a day. Well, sort of. On Friday I did a wet collodion process... Read more

    The 11 April 2015 by   Kirsty Stonell Walker
  • 8 Things You Can Do To Empower Young People This National Youth HIV/AIDS...

    Credit: Tumblr Today is the 3rd National Youth HIV and AIDS Awareness Day — a meaningful day for us as an adolescent health educator and feminist youth worker. Read more

    The 10 April 2015 by   Juliez
  • Shouty Kid Book 2 + a Competition

    The funniest kid in fiction is back! Follow his life's ups and downs told through laugh-out-loud letters, emails, texts and more! Last year Ryan was very... Read more

    The 10 April 2015 by   Evette Garside
  • The Cleaning Woman Takes to the Streets

    Remember that piece I was writing about my traumatic day at work? Well, I wrote it. And I saved it. On another computer. You'll see it Monday. Until then, pleas... Read more

    The 10 April 2015 by   Pearl

Add a comment