Incentives--From Where We Came to Where We AreBy Kelly058
Incentives should be used to meet economic development goals. Goals which as originally discussed must look beyond just direct impacts of jobs and revenues to include diversification of our tax base, sustainability, more higher paying jobs, and compatibility with the city's character.
In setting up the incentives program it was important to place benchmarks like jobs , revenues, and capital investment to be achieved before tax dollars and fees would be reimbursed. We have dealt with the direct impacts and seem to have stopped and there have been consequences.
For downtown an existing business creating 5 jobs, and $125,000 capital investment and 10 jobs and $250,000 capital investment, are the benchmark for qualifying for incentives. As for job creation we are not differentiating between a $25,000 a year job and a $125,000 a year job. If we take into consideration the costs associated with those jobs the return to the city could also be negatively affected. In regards to capital investment we are looking at revenues to the city of only from $1,000 to $2,150 a year based on the current real estate tax rate. How much of a return are we actually getting? As for revenues projections we base them only on the business' projections but not on the potential impact on other businesses.
Case in point, a new restaurant downtown would probably have a negative impact other downtown restaurants' revenue. Just providing incentives for one sector, i.e., restaurants for example, can be counterproductive.
The benchmarks for Celebrate VA and Eagle Village are 25 jobs and $500,000 capital investment which seems low knowing what type of businesses are planned for those areas. It should also be noted that we have since tweaked our incentive programs to bring them in line with our neighbors. Based on the first come first serve approach one has to question the validity of the incentives program. It should also be remembered than one of our goals was to get away from our reliance on retail/service.
We are failing on two counts. We have forgotten some significant reasons we had for implementing incentives in the first place--diversity, sustainability, more higher paying jobs, and compatibility with the city's character (I'll deal with the Kalahari comments as they come). Secondly, they were put in place so that the city could pro-actively work towards achieving diversity, sustainability, more higher paying jobs, and fitting the city character. It time to reevaluate where we are with incentives and also take a moment to provide the community with the vision of what is to be achieved with them.
Is there a role for incentives in Fredericksburg?
These articles might interest you :
Historical Fiction4*s Lizzie Borden took an axe And gave her mother forty whacks. When she saw what she had done, She gave her father forty-one. Read more9 hours, 43 minutes ago by Cleopatralovesbooks
Hi Huneybees,Hubby and I love going out for rides and recently we had the Toyota Rav4 Premium 2.0 to join us. I've always been a fan of the RAV4 series for its... Read more9 hours, 46 minutes ago by Huney_84
LIFESTYLE, SHOPPING, TV & VIDEO
Soprano Natalie Dessay returns to Carnegie Hall. by Paul J. Pelkonen Natalie Dessay. Photo © Sony Classical. Natalie Dessay is no stranger to adversity. Read more10 hours, 18 minutes ago by Superconductor
CULTURE, THEATRE & OPERA
There are normally only two of us eating in this house and so I normally try to cut recipes in half for us, or create dishes which are simple and make just... Read more11 hours, 46 minutes ago by Mariealicerayner
FOOD & DRINK, RECIPES
Well, there are a lot of winning factors that AMPM Cafe Bar has to gain your presence frequently. Though its rooftop fourth floor and fifth floor are silent... Read more12 hours, 48 minutes ago by Jaideep Khanduja
DIARIES, SELF EXPRESSION
This week Tiger has actually done a few things around the house and he's so proud of himself. FFS. It's not anything amazing, just things that he should be doin... Read more13 hours, 17 minutes ago by Glossqueen
HAIR & BEAUTY, SELF EXPRESSION
Susan. Alison. Jeanne. I've been trying to find a way to ask this question and not sound like an angry black woman. I have figured out in the process that I... Read more13 hours, 27 minutes ago by Eastofmidnight
MOST POPULAR FROM DEBATE
- Friday fun day: again, let us point and laugh at their president by Doggone
- Daily Mail on top form by Markwadsworth
- Strweth Sheila, 'Straya has fake charities too! by Markwadsworth
MOST RECOMMENDED IN DEBATE
- Thursday Schadenfreude: Bill, Sean, and soon Rush go bye bye by Doggone
- “Why are people encouraging me to borrow thousands of dollars to attend an institution in which people like me have a 1-out-of-5 chance of graduating”? by Stevemiranda
- Free Planet - Diversity locations - Diversity languages by Freeplanet
- Another Russian-rigged election, another Kremlin puppet fascist by Doggone