Society Magazine

How Theatre Can Help Us Understand Donald Trump And Brexit

Posted on the 15 May 2017 by Loup Dargent @loup_dargent

"Through the parallels of the play to our own lives, we are led into thinking politically without the usual prejudices. Now we begin to understand why people believe lies and vote for irrational politicians. In this situation it is easy to avoid responsibility with feeble excuses - because everyone's doing it and it's necessary to survive. It is possible to convince yourself to vote for a necessary evil, just as the impoverished villagers decided to kill the shop keeper..."

How Theatre Can Help Us Understand Donald Trump And Brexit

Image via ShutterstockBy Hans-Ludwig Buchholz, University of Aberdeen

When it comes to the chaotic policies of But they cannot fully explain why millions believe in "The Swiss dramatist and author As the audience, we can step back from our own prejudices, and fear for or laugh at the figures on stage. In comedy especially, we can watch something we don't need to take too seriously - only to realise afterwards that we behave in our own lives exactly as the characters on stage do. Our own frustrations and foibles are revealed to us as the play unfolds. By experiencing the drama, we have unwittingly considered, mocked and judged ourselves. Dürrenmatt Dürrenmatt's most famous comedy
Donald Trump or the seeming irrationality of Brexit, traditional political explanations can fail to produce satisfactory answers. Political science may help to solve some of these riddles, but far from all. For example, scholars may be able to argue that those disappointed or marginalised by the US political establishment voted for Trump's promises. Or they could claim that people voted for the UK to leave the EU because it was seen as the project of a rich elite.

Theatre Help Understand Donald Trump Brexit
alternative facts", or why the arguments for these are made so passionately. Perhaps unexpectedly, theatre can be an instrument for thinking about politics and making sense of Trump, Brexit and other political upheavals.
Friedrich Dürrenmatt is considered an international writer of classic plays, but is popular only in German-speaking countries. However, Dürrenmatt can teach us how to make sense of irrational policies through the use of literature, and especially comedy. He shows us how everyone can use art to think politically.
The type of theatre we're talking about here isn't Shakespeare's historic plays or modern TV dramas in the style of House of Cards or The West Wing - they can make visible what happens behind closed doors. What we really need to do is take a step back to understand what is going on in the whole of society - and in ourselves. And it is theatrical comedy that opens up this way of thinking.
Dürrenmatt's position is that our complicated, chaotic world, where a clear morality no longer exists, has to be translated by literature into an understandable narrative. Theatre can represent certain aspects of the world and place them in a concrete story. once said: " I love to trick the audience into thinking about their own case, which is always political".
So, how can this theory be applied? Play for today
The Visit (1956) tells the story of Claire Zachanassian, a wealthy old woman who visits the now-impoverished village of her youth. She offers the villagers the sum of one billion Swiss francs under the condition that someone kills the owner of the village shop.
As a young woman, Zachanassian had loved this man, but he had jilted her when she was poor and pregnant. Now she wants to exact her revenge and see justice done. At first the villagers reject the immoral offer. But soon they start to talk about how the money could alleviate their poverty and suffering. Then, figuring they deserve it, the locals begin to buy expensive things on credit in anticipation of their wealth, making the shop owner increasingly nervous. In the end - spoiler alert - they accept the offer and kill him.
Of course, the comedy discusses big questions of justice, but as we watch, it mainly makes us laugh and judge. The characters on stage are portrayed in ridiculous ways: their obedient bow to the rich old woman is idiotic; their greed is farcical; their willingness to put aside loyalty is weak; their poor excuses for taking the money are laughable.

Appalling lies are swallowed in order to make the chosen evil acceptable. The people hit by Trump's travel bans, or Britain's European neighbours, are the necessary sacrifices for what surely must be the only option left,

How Theatre Can Help Us Understand Donald Trump And Brexit

Amazon, CC BY-SA
After the play ends, we may ask ourselves how we would have reacted to Zachanassian's offer. We can use it to think about the choices in our lives, like accepting high interest rates that are too good to be true from dubious banks; or voting for politicians who are only acting for those rich or British enough; or for parties advocating low taxation.
And suddenly all our usual excuses and justifications are toppled. In the course of the play we dismiss the villagers as laughable, ridiculous and shameful. But as Dürrenmatt claimed, we have been tricked into thinking about our own lives all along.
Through the parallels of the play to our own lives, we are led into thinking politically without the usual prejudices. Now we begin to understand why people believe lies and vote for irrational politicians. In this situation it is easy to avoid responsibility with feeble excuses - because everyone's doing it and it's necessary to survive. It is possible to convince yourself to vote for a necessary evil, just as the impoverished villagers decided to kill the shop keeper.
Dissolving limitations
Literature in politics can only hint at how we should think. Otherwise we repeat the problems of political science, which is stuck with a rigid way of thinking designed to produce absolute truths. Thinking about difficult moral questions with the help of literature is more playful, and dissolves all limitations. some might reason.
Taking literature too seriously - making messages absolute and ideological - would destroy this possibility. Instead, literature has to be vague, emotional, and open - used as an opportunity to explore our sense of morality and justice. Literature may not be able to fully explain Brexit, but it can help make sense of it.
Brexiteers are Claire Zachanassian figures in that they promise to save Britain and the NHS - if Europeans living in the UK and British people living abroad are made to suffer the necessary sacrifice. Like the villagers in the play we are then asked the difficult question, and the answer we give should help us see ourselves more clearly - if we are honest.

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Sundaze 57

    Sundaze

    After a BUSY week at Chez Chai, it comes as no surprise that this miniature Sundaze installment is scheduled! Nope, we’re not in real-time right now and by the... Read more

    6 hours, 54 minutes ago by   Winyeemichelle
    FASHION, LIFESTYLE
  • Fabb Review & Unboxing of My Envy Box of July’17

    Fabb Review Unboxing Envy July’17

    Hey Everyone, Hope you are doing well. Today I am going to talk about My Envy Box of July month. I received this day before yesterday and I am so excited to... Read more

    7 hours, 44 minutes ago by   Dreamtechie
    FASHION, LIFESTYLE
  • God’s Own Country

    God’s Country

    On a complete whim, we decided on a mini tour of Yorkshire. As England’s largest traditional county by far, it was a very teeny weeny tour encompassing just... Read more

    7 hours, 54 minutes ago by   Jackscott
    DIARIES, EXPAT, SELF EXPRESSION
  • Thoughts of the Week

    1. We've been in home improvement mode lately and I love it. Tiger put in a wood heater and he put up curtains in our bedroom and the nursery. It makes the hous... Read more

    10 hours, 51 minutes ago by   Glossqueen
    HAIR & BEAUTY, SELF EXPRESSION
  • Peach & Blueberry Crumble

    Peach Blueberry Crumble

    This is a delicious dessert to make when the blueberry bushes are just dripping with fruit. We are not quite there yet in our garden, but it won't be long now,... Read more

    13 hours, 54 minutes ago by   Mariealicerayner
    FOOD & DRINK, RECIPES
  • Concert Review: The New Teen Titans

    Concert Review: Teen Titans

    The National Youth Orchestra of the United States of America marks five years at Carnegie Hall. by Paul J. Pelkonen Members of the National Youth Orchestra of... Read more

    14 hours, 51 minutes ago by   Superconductor
    CULTURE, THEATRE & OPERA
  • My Dilemma

    Dilemma

    I’ve not been around much lately, not that the few readers I have left would notice, but it’s been a crazy month.   I bought a new house  and I’m also in the... Read more

    15 hours, 37 minutes ago by   Laurken
    SELF EXPRESSION

Magazine