Debate Magazine

How the AP Deals With Women

Posted on the 17 February 2011 by Juliez

"Women In xxx" isn't enough

I don’t like being patronized. I know this probably isn’t shocking, but I seriously HATE it. It also annoys me to no end when people patronize womankind.

This year, I’m taking AP European History. Ignoring the fact that the teacher is honestly the worst I’ve ever had (although it is rather fun piping in with my obnoxious feminist comments), I find the course itself patronizing towards women. Maybe I’m overreacting and being too picky, but nevertheless it annoys me that there are specific “Women in xxx” units (for example – “Women in the Scientific Revolution”).

On a handout my teacher gave us outlining women’s role throughout the periods we’ve studied, it says at the top, “A generation ago, women’s history, if it appeared at all in the textbooks, was generally relegated to a few sidebars. Now, women’s history should be an integral part of your AP European History course.”

The sentiment is noble: I completely support it and am glad that the AP is making such a concerted effort to include women’s history in the curriculum. However, I find it patronizing and a little bit sexist that they completely separate women’s history from the “mainstream” history.

I’ve taken notes in the Goldhar format ever since my school had Rabbi Goldhar, the creator of the format, come in and teach it to us. It’s really helpful, since instead of taking notes in paragraph or even list format, you put the main idea into a bubble on the left side of the page, and write information pertaining to the main idea in spokes coming out from the bubble. Looking through my Goldhar notes for AP Euro, everything is in neat little bubbles. Under the Scientific Revolution, I have 16 bubbles, one of which is the “Women in Science” bubble. Under the Enlightenment there are 19 bubbles, one of which is the “Role of Women” bubble. Under the French Revolution, I have 29 bubbles and – you guessed it – “Women vs. Men in Philosophy,” “Women March Versailles,” and “Women in the Revolution” bubbles.
I find it kind of sad that not only was the amount of information taught about women in those respective periods pathetically small, but that said information was taught in a singular unit, grouped together simply because the people involved were women.

Let’s use the Scientific Revolution as an example. I have bubbles dedicated to Francis Bacon, Rene Descartes, Copernicus, Tycho Brahe, Johannes Kepler, Galileo Galilei, Isaac Newton, Thomas Hobbes, and John Locke. “Women in Science” has a lot of spokes, including ones dedicated to Margaret Cavendish, Maria Cunitz, Maria Winkelman, and Emilie Chatelet. Why couldn’t the discoveries of Winkelman been mentioned under the same heading as those of Copernicus, since both of them tried to figure out an accurate calendar? Why don’t Newton and Chatelet get accorded honors at the same time, since Chatelet translated Newton’s work into French? I’m not saying to make a bigger deal out of their scientific research than they deserve, but just don’t separate the women’s work from the men’s work simply based on gender.

So that’s my two cents on how to include women’s history in the curriculum. It’s definitely a step in the right direction to include them in a separate unit, and I commend the AP for making such a concerted effort to keep women in the syllabus. Nonetheless, it’s much closer to the goal of complete equality between the sexes to include women in the mainstream program of study.


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Support Women Artists Sunday: Kate Walsh

    Support Women Artists Sunday: Kate Walsh

    Kate Walsh She’s been called music’s best kept, not-so-secret ‘secret.’; ‘The missing link between Joni Mitchell’ (hails UK’s The Guardian) and a host of... Read more

    By  Juliez
    DEBATE, ENTERTAINMENT, MUSIC, SOCIETY
  • Guns Are Bad News for Michian Women

    In Isabella County there was a rather strange domestic murder. The way the guy walked into the police station and the matter-of-fact way the sheriff spoke of th... Read more

    By  Mikeb302000
    DEBATE, SOCIETY
  • How to Deal with Poverty in Schools

    Deal with Poverty Schools

    While teaching in a big urban high school, I had a conversation with students one day about the “voluntary simplicity” movement, which consists of people who... Read more

    By  Stevemiranda
    DEBATE, FAMILY, SCHOOLING, SOCIETY
  • Guns Are Bad News for Women - With a Twist

    Mercury news reports on a different version of the famous old scene. A man is in surgery and a woman is in custody after she shot him and then surrendered at a... Read more

    By  Mikeb302000
    CURRENT, DEBATE, SOCIETY
  • Saturday Vids: Ideal Women

    Elena Rossini is a film director, cinematographer and editor from Italy. She’s also a really awesome woman who is working on multiple feminist projects,... Read more

    By  Juliez
    DEBATE, SOCIETY
  • How AP European History Deals with Women

    European History Deals with Women

    This was cross-posted on the FBomb. I don’t like being patronized. I know this is probably not a shocking fact, but I would like to make it extremely clear... Read more

    By  Starofdavida
    DEBATE, RELIGION, SOCIETY
  • Violence Against Women and Harassment Against Women in Egypt

    Dear readersI mentioned in my last post that my nanny was assaulted on Friday for being Sudanese or dark skinned. However, I told this story to my class, and... Read more

    By  Warigia
    CURRENT, DEBATE, SOCIETY

Magazines