History Magazine

Gay Cavemen & Buried Shamans

By Cris

This past week, British newspapers carried sensational headlines about an archaeological find in Prague: “First Homosexual Caveman Found” (The Telegraph) and “Oldest Gay in the Village: 5,000 Year Old is ‘Outed’ By the Way He Was Buried” (Daily Mail). Although the assemblage in question has not been published in a journal, the archaeologists called a press conference and provided this picture:

Gay Cavemen & Buried Shamans

While this may not look very gay to the untrained eye, the archaeologists tell us this is an unusual burial because this apparent male was buried in a posture typically reserved for females, and because the grave goods are not typical of those usually found in either male or female burials. This raises the possibility that s/he was other gendered.

Although it is quite unlikely that modern Western constructions of gender or sexual orientation mirror those of 5,000 year old Neolithic farmers, the lead researcher nonetheless suggests an analogy: “Far more likely is that he was a man with a different sexual orientation, homosexual or transvestite. What we see here does not add up to traditional Corded Ware cultural norms.” While this may be an unusual burial for people of this time and place, determining sexual orientation and gender status from a single sample is fraught with difficulties, nearly all of which have been summed up nicely by Kristina Killgrove over at Bone Girl.

The find raises interesting questions, however, about what kinds of inferences we can make from burials. As my readers know, I question whether deliberate burials, with nothing more, is a marker for soul beliefs. Because nearly all people who bury their dead with grave goods claim that such goods assist the deceased in their afterlife journey, grave goods are a much better indicator of such beliefs.

But not all grave goods are created equal; when unusual objects are included, it may indicate that the deceased was a shaman. In 2008, Leore Grosman and colleagues described (in PNAS, open access) a 12,000 year old burial from the Levantine Natufian culture. The deceased, an elderly female, was buried with an unusual array of objects, including “50 complete tortoise shells and select body-parts of a wild boar, an eagle, a cow, a leopard, and two martens, as well as a complete human foot.” This suggested to the researchers that the old woman, who was physically debilitated for a long period of time before she died, was a shaman:

We argue that this burial is consistent with expectations for a shaman’s grave. Although the term shaman derives specifically from the Tungus people of Siberia, shamanistic figures are well-known from hunter-gatherer and small-scale agricultural societies world-wide. The shaman’s primary role is to mediate between the human and the spirit worlds. Shamans act as messengers, healers, and magicians, and serve both the community and its members.

Although shaman graves are highly variable, and thus, there are no standard criteria to identify a shaman in the archaeological record, a number of generalizations about shamans can be surmised from cross-cultural research: (a) shamans are associated with spiritual, magical, and healing powers; (b) shamans engage the help of spirits in animal form; (c) shamans are keepers of specialized knowledge; (d) shamans are ascribed high status within their communities; and (e) the status of shamans is reflected in their special treatment at death—their burials often contain artifacts reflecting their role in life (i.e., remains of particular animals and contents of healing kits).

Ethnographic records describe a variety of ways to bury a shaman (21), but because shamans are always considered privileged persons, who therefore enjoy a different kind of afterlife from other members of their group, unusual features of their graves mark their special status.

This is a splendid example of middle-range archaeological theory, in which known practices of historic or living peoples are used to assess archaeological discoveries and make inferences. In the case of the may be “gay” and not “caveman” burial from Prague, we have no such theory. We do not know, for instance, whether the Corded Ware culture recognized anything like a third gender, such as the Native American “two spirit” or berdache, and if so, whether such persons were buried in a differential manner.

In the absence of such knowledge and much more information about this burial and others from the same time/place, the most we can say is that this appears to be an unusual burial of uncertain significance. While it is never fun pouring cold scientific water on sensational headlines, it is sometimes necessary.

Reference:

Grosman, L., Munro, N., & Belfer-Cohen, A. (2008). A 12,000-year-old Shaman burial from the southern Levant (Israel). Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 105 (46), 17665-17669 DOI: 10.1073/pnas.0806030105


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • A Heartfelt Letter to My First Child - I Miss Those Times Too

    Heartfelt Letter First Child Miss Those Times

    For those of us who chose to have more than one kid, have you ever thought of how life would be if you had only one? You would have so much more time for... Read more

    14 hours, 35 minutes ago by   A Happy Mum
    FAMILY, SELF EXPRESSION
  • This is How to Put Together a Fabulous Outfit In Minutes

    This Together Fabulous Outfit Minutes

    Putting together a stylish outfit everyday doesn't have to be tricky. In fact I've come up with a simple formula that you can use over and over for all... Read more

    14 hours, 38 minutes ago by   Imogenl
    FASHION, LIFESTYLE
  • Cream Scones (Anneka Manning)

    Cream Scones (Anneka Manning)

    version;It was the end of a typical school day as the kids were streaming out from their classes..."Hi Sweetie!""Mum, we baked scones at school today.""Sounds... Read more

    15 hours, 10 minutes ago by   Zoebakeforhappykids
    FOOD & DRINK, RECIPES
  • Blind Fear

    I write a lot about Love, about Justice, about Intuition- about all the essential things that see without seeing. I think a lot about blind spots, about the... Read more

    The 19 July 2017 by   Rarasaur
    CREATIVITY, SELF EXPRESSION
  • Self-Transcendence 3100 Mile Race 2017 – Daily Updates – Day 31 – Alan Young

    Self-Transcendence 3100 Mile Race 2017 Daily Updates Alan Young

    Latest news, Multiday News, Self-Transcendence 3100 Mile Race Self-Transcendence 3100 Mile Race 2017 - Daily Updates - Day 31 Daily Diary Tuesday 18th July -... Read more

    The 19 July 2017 by   Abichal
    OTHER SPORTS, OUTDOORS
  • Review: Hir (Steppenwolf Theatre)

    Review: (Steppenwolf Theatre)

    In Mac's kitchen-sink drama, the meek shall inherit the earth Review by Catey Sullivan Early on in Taylor Mac's Hir , the playwright offers up a monologue... Read more

    The 19 July 2017 by   Chicagotheaterbeat
    CULTURE, THEATRE & OPERA
  • How to Find a Foundation Repair Company

    Do you own a house? If this is the case, you might eventually encounter some problems with your home’s foundation. These problems can become very serious if the... Read more

    The 19 July 2017 by   Peppertan
    FAMILY, HOME

Magazines