Debate Magazine

Gandhi’s Dualism and Homer’s Soul

Posted on the 23 June 2011 by Cris

No stranger to the existential angst arising from the meta-and-physical dichotomy of sacred/profane, the inimitable Christopher Hitchens evaluates similar sorts of tensions in the life of India’s hagiographic hero. Whilst reviewing Joseph Lelyveld’s new book, Great Soul: Mahatma Gandhi and His Struggle with India, Hitchens pours cold pragmatic water on the man and his myths.

Despite its new-agey western construction as the font of ahimsa, we are again reminded that Hindu tradition sanctifies caste and the perversion of untouchability. It is of course impolite to mention such matters at the yoga studio, where the flow must go on.

Hitchens astutely observes that these kinds of contradictions are to be expected when all that supposedly exists is cleaved with a Cartesian binary:

[This] was always latent in Gandhism: a highly dubious employment of the mind-body distinction. For him, the material and physical world was gross and polluting and selfish, while all that pertained to the “soul” was axiomatically ideal and altruistic….This false antithesis is the basis for all religious fundamentalism, even as its deliberate indifference permits and even encourages sharp deterioration in the world of “real” conditions.

The separation of mind from matter and body from soul is not merely a Western fallacy or Vedic fantasy. It is a widespread idea, found among most peoples across time and space. Whence cometh the soul?

This is a weighty question and The Simpsons have answers.

Gandhi’s Dualism and Homer’s Soul

Using Homer’s Soul as their humorous foil, psychologists Paul Bloom and David Pizarro examine mind-body dualism and metaphysics:

[S]olving the mind-body problem remains a major preoccupation of both psychologists and philosophers; no science of the mind can be complete without it.

What does The Simpsons have to say about this issue? Most likely, absolutely nothing. The Simpsons is a fine television show, but it’s not where to look for innovative ideas in cognitive neuroscience or the philosophy of mind. We think, however, that it can help give us insight into a related, and extremely important, issue.

We might learn through this show something about common-sense metaphysics, about how people naturally think about consciousness, the brain and the soul.

As it turns out, The Simpsons illuminate these issues in all sorts of revealing ways. Homer’s Soul is the perfect teaching tool for a generation raised on the (dualist) philosophy of D’oh.


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • This Day, O Soul....

    This Day, Soul....

    This day, O Soul, I give you a wondrous mirror; Long in the dark, in tarnish and cloud it lay— But the cloud has pass’d, and the tarnish gone; Behold, O Soul! Read more

    By  Cathyberry
  • Dark Night of the Soul: the Art of Felix Meseck

    Dark Night Soul: Felix Meseck

    Felix Meseck was born in Danzig in 1883, and died in Holzminden in 1955. Meseck studied at the Fine Art Academies in Berlin and Königsberg, studying painting... Read more

    By  Adventuresintheprinttrade
  • Song Speculation True Blood Season 4 Episode 11 “Soul of Fire”

    Song Speculation True Blood Season Episode “Soul Fire”

    Since we now know the title for the Season 4, Episode 11 is “Soul of Fire”, as is our practice, we like to speculate about what song will be chosen by True... Read more

    By  Thevault
  • Soul Saturdays: 4 Life Perspectives

    Last week at the Skirt! Magazine Writer's Conference, a very cool, inspirational woman named Michelle Goss. Her message was about the four life perspectives tha... Read more

    By  Shawndrarussell
  • Soul Saturday: Parenthood (the Tv Show)

    I am not a parent, but this show is about everything, not just parenting. I usually cry at the end of every episode, but not in a sad, this-is-depressing way bu... Read more

    By  Shawndrarussell
  • The Soul of John Black - Good Thang

    Soul John Black Good Thang

    Big generalization.I don't like R B, but I love Soul.The difference? Well . . . it's soul. Soul has it. R B doesn't. In my small, over-generalizing mind, sou... Read more

    By  Ripplemusic
  • Soul Saturdays: "Verbal Photograph"

    I discovered Filmutopia's Sunday Morning Movie Blog today thanks to the wonderful world of Twitter, and I am already hooked. In teaching my Creative Writing... Read more

    By  Shawndrarussell