Debate Magazine

Evolution of Religion Project: Is “Adaptation” Code for “Design”?

Posted on the 18 April 2011 by Cris

 

Several  months ago I became aware of the “Evolution of Religion” project, which maintains a website here. I did not find it particularly interesting because it was immediately apparent that the project was designed to prove a particular point. We need look no further than the project’s subtitle to ascertain the a priori commitment that guides its research: “The Adaptive Logic of Religious Beliefs and Behavior.”

Splendid. Here we have what is supposed to be a scientific project specifically designed to prove that “religion” evolved because it is adaptive. This sounds like a perfect recipe for confirmation bias to me. It also feels like an agenda.

To understand what may be going on here, let’s look at the “Aims” of the project:

To many scholars, religious beliefs and behaviors appear so bizarre and so costly that they fall outside rational explanation, leading instead to explanations based on psychosis, cognitive accidents, or cultural parasites.

The aim of our project is to conduct a scientific examination of exactly the opposite hypothesis—that religious beliefs and behavior confer adaptive advantages to individual believers, and were therefore favored by natural selection over human evolutionary history. In other words, religion may have evolved.

This is quite revealing. In one corner, we have evolutionary scholars who argue that what we today call “religion” is not the result of targeted selection and is maladaptive. They are mostly atheists. In the other corner, we have evolutionary scholars who argue that we today call “religion” is the result of targeted selection and is adaptive. My educated guess is that some or several are believers.

While I do not have a problem with scholars being atheists or believers, I do have a problem with research that is designed to prove a metaphysical point. This becomes even more of a problem when personal biases or conflicts of interest are not fully disclosed.

As for the latter, it is good to see that the Evolution of Religion project acknowledges that it is “generously supported by the John Templeton Foundation.” For those unfamiliar with the John Templeton Foundation, its history, agenda, and support for particular kinds of research, I encourage you to read about it here.


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Dying Games – Steve Robinson

    Dying Games Steve Robinson

    Crime Fiction5*s The genealogical expert Jefferson Tayte is back! I love this series which has taken me back to historical eras I know little about while tellin... Read more

    14 hours, 12 minutes ago by   Cleopatralovesbooks
    BOOKS, CULTURE
  • Crushed a Flower with a Footstep

    (Photograph by Abhay Tiwari) Please, talk to me about who you were before the walls were painted blue; Tell me the bruises, the aches, and time just added... Read more

    15 hours, 20 minutes ago by   Shantam Sahai
    DIARIES, SELF EXPRESSION
  • Make My Day . . .

    Make

    Read more

    15 hours, 35 minutes ago by   Vickilane
    CREATIVITY, PHOTOGRAPHY
  • Lifestyle: Productive Procrastination

    Lifestyle: Productive Procrastination

    I’ve moaned about it enough, so you’ll all know by know that despite having graduated last summer I’m still studying. I’ve chosen a career path which pretty muc... Read more

    16 hours, 35 minutes ago by   Ninegrandstudent
    FASHION, FOOD & DRINK, LIFESTYLE
  • Why I’m Not At the MidAmerica Region Annual Assembly

    I love Chicago. I have family there that I'm normally always looking for a way to be with. And I have friends that I don't see nearly enough. So when I first... Read more

    17 hours, 50 minutes ago by   Eastofmidnight
    POLITICS, SOCIETY
  • Lemon Stuffed French Toast

    Lemon Stuffed French Toast

    Whenever I have stale bread I want to make one of two things . . . either I want to make a bread pudding, or I want to make French Toast. Today the French... Read more

    18 hours, 35 minutes ago by   Mariealicerayner
    FOOD & DRINK, RECIPES
  • Safety First And Workout Related Injuries Last

    Safety First Workout Related Injuries Last

    (Image Credit) Like most things in life, exercise can be a dangerous game. It’s very easy to injure yourself while you’re exercising; if you fail to take the... Read more

    22 hours, 32 minutes ago by   Peppertan
    FAMILY, HOME

Magazines