Culture Magazine

DVD Review: A Valkyrie with Broken Wings

By Superconductor @ppelkonen
The Copenhagen Ring: Die Walküre
Check out the first part in this review: The Horror of Das Rheingold.

DVD Review: A Valkyrie with Broken Wings

Siegmund (Stig Anderson, left) and Sieglinde (Gitta-Maria Sjöberg) outside Hunding's hut.
Act I of Die Walküre from The Copenhagen Ring
Photo by Martin Mydtkalov Rosne © 2006 The Royal Danish Opera/Decca Classics

The second installment in the Royal Danish Opera's fascinating take on Wagner's Ring places the struggles of the Gods squarely in a banal world of family drama, like a TV network movie-of-the-week shot on a low budget. It opens with a striking bourgeois image. Hunding's hut is an art deco apartment, with Sieglinde as a cowed, bullied hausfrau desperate to get out. When Siegmund (Stig Anderson) enters, and she immediately seizes upon him as the means of escape. Hunding (Stephen Milling) is a loutish, violent alcoholic. The escape from his apartment is quite literal: Siegmund throws a chair through a plate-glass window and they find the sword stuck in a tree in the front yard.

DVD Review: A Valkyrie with Broken Wings

Brunnhilde (Iréne Theodrin) with the
"game pieces" for Siegmund and Sieglinde.

Act II of Die Walküre from the Copenhagen Ring.
Photo by Martin Mydtkalov Rosne © 2006
The Royal Danish Opera/Decca Classics

Mr. Anderson was a late replacement in this cycle, but he gives a committed performance. He sounds comfortable in this low-lying tenor part, and while he reaches for the high notes, the overall effect is pleasing. He is paired with Gitta-Maria Sjöberg, an emotional Sieglinde who is more involved in events than this character usually is. She pulls the sword from the tree, and is awake (and horrified) for the Annunciation of Death. Mr. Milling is a memorable, nasty Hunding, whose voice does not match his hulking Ted Cassidy-like physique.
Wotan (James Johnson) starts on the flying "bridge" that ended Das Rheingold. He is playing a vast game of Stratego with plaster pieces representing the other characters. When he realizes he must slay his son, he smashes his son's piece at "Das ende!", eliminating Siegmund from the game of power. Here, the one-eyed God is also blurred by drink: whiskey swigged from a hip flask. Mr. Johnson remains a better actor than a singer, but he is both convincing and moving in his anguish.
Decked out in black with literal wings on her back, Iréne Theorin is a dramatically interesting Brunnhilde. She has a heroic soprano voice that is slightly on the small side. But she endures through this difficult role, and her middleweight voice suits the director's intimate concept. It helps that Michael Schønwalt conducts with a light touch in the pit when it is needed. Her voice hardens under pressure, which makes her big moment with Sieglinde in Act III seem forced.

DVD Review: A Valkyrie with Broken Wings

Wotan (James Johnson) puts Brunnhilde (Iréne Theorin) to sleep in the Magic Fire.
Act III of Die Walküre from the Copenhagen Ring.
Photo by Martin Mydtkalov Rosne © 2006 The Royal Danish Opera/Decca Classics


Kasper Bech Holten's production has its share of innovative ideas. Wotan is completely combat-unready. All he can do is scheme and bully his daughters. He is totally impotent, and doesn't even kill Hunding. The brute laughs, kicks Siegmund's corpse and strolls off the stage. The Valkyrie girls, in blood-stained dresses and black feathery angel wings, loot the mummified bodies of dead soldiers on an urban rooftop with a greenhouse-type structure that doubles as Brunnhilde's Valkyrie rock. At the height of Wotan's Farewell, the god literally rips the wing from his daughter's back before putting Brunnhilde to sleep, a moving moment that echoes the mutilation of Alberich in Das Rheingold.
Mr. Schønwandt falls into the Böhm-Boulez school of Wagner interpreters. His quick tempos and clear delineation of the instrumentation suit this production, with its contemporary sets and movie-of-the-week atmosphere. Part of that feel is due to the stage direction, but the fast-moving cameras and close focus make this feel more like a soap than an opera.

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • DVD Review: The King of the Golden Hall

    Review: King Golden Hall

    Discovering Beethoven: Symphonies 7, 8 and 9 with Christian Thielemann and the Vienna Philharmonic Christian Thielemann, leading the Vienna Philharmonic in the... Read more

    By  Superconductor
    CULTURE, THEATRE & OPERA
  • DVD Review: A Valkyrie with Broken Wings

    Review: Valkyrie with Broken Wings

    The Copenhagen Ring: Die Walküre Check out the first installment in this review: The Horror of Das Rheingold. Wotan (James Johnson) puts Brunnhilde (Iréne... Read more

    By  Superconductor
    CULTURE, THEATRE & OPERA
  • DVD Review: Out of the Shadows

    Review: Shadows

    Die Frau ohne Schatten from Nagoya, Japan Screen-grab of Luana DeVol as the Empress in Die Frau ohne Schatten, Image © 1992 Bavarian State Opera/ArtHaus... Read more

    By  Superconductor
    CULTURE, THEATRE & OPERA
  • Opera Review: A New Machine, Part II

    Opera Review: Machine, Part

    A Second Look at the Met's Die Walküre The assembled Valkyries in Act III of Die Walküre at the Met. At the top of the set: Deborah Voigt as Brunnhilde with... Read more

    By  Superconductor
    CULTURE, THEATRE & OPERA
  • Concert Review: A Diva's Return...to Earth

    Concert Review: Diva's Return...to Earth

    "Anything you can do..." Paulo Szot and Debbie Voigt at Carnegie Hall. Photo by Erin Baiano © 2011. Deborah Voigt Sings Broadway at Carnegie Hall "It's good to... Read more

    By  Superconductor
    CULTURE, THEATRE & OPERA
  • Concert Review: A Valkyrie, Lost in the Woods

    Concert Review: Valkyrie, Lost Woods

    Erwartung at the New York Philharmonic with Deborah Voigt Original stage set design for Erwartung. Crayon, pastel and watercolor by Arnold Schoenberg. From the... Read more

    By  Superconductor
    CULTURE, THEATRE & OPERA
  • DVD Review: A Sneak Peek at the Apocalypse.

    Review: Sneak Peek Apocalypse.

    Franz Welser-Möst. Note the blue cufflinks. Photo by Roger Mastrioanni © 2011 The Cleveland Orchestra. Saturday night's free event at the Rubinstein Atrium... Read more

    By  Superconductor
    CULTURE, THEATRE & OPERA