Do 'world Religions' Make Cuckoldry Easier?By Tomrees8
Actually, what the data reveal is a more complex and rather more interesting picture.
First, to summarize what was done. Beverly Strassman (University of Michigan) and colleagues have been studying the Dogon of Mali in West Africa, who practice a range of different religions. Most of them hold on to their traditional beliefs, some are Muslim, and increasing numbers have been converted to Christianity.
They've built up a large genetic database, allowing them to test 1,706 father–son pairs in 29 patrilineages to see if they match.
What they found was that the Dogon had the lowest odds of non-paternity, followed by the Muslims (although this difference was not statistically significant), while the Catholics had the highest rates of cuckoldry.
Strassman looked into several possible explanations (polygamy, poverty etc) but the one that stood out was a particular cultural practice that marks out traditional Dogon culture: menstrual huts.
Dogon women have high fertility. Typically they are either pregnant or lactating, so menstruation is a rare event that is usually rapidly followed by pregnancy. Traditional Dogon culture demands that menstruating women relocate to special huts, close to where the men of a single patrilineage live. It's an effective way to control the reproductive options for these women.
Dogon Muslims have abandoned these huts, but Muslim women must notify their husbands and are not allowed to pray. So they clearly signal their fertility.
Christians don't have any such safeguards, which likely explains their higher rates of cuckoldry.
That's not to say that Christians tolerate cuckoldry. Far from it. In fact these religions strictly forbid it and warn of supernatural punishment (certainly that's the case for Christianity and Islam).
All of this got me thinking. After all, one popular argument is that world religions helped to bring about complex societies. They did this by facilitate interactions between strangers by increasing trust - by threatening cheaters with supernatural punishment.
Maybe what we're seeing here is the flipside of that. Christianity, a religion designed for the complex urban societies of the late Roman period, has fewer rules and regulations designed at forcing honest behavior. It relies, instead, on assumptions of trust backed up by threats of supernatural punishment.
As a result, world religions - and the relative personal freedom they allow - actually make cheating easier, compared with the controlling traditionalist religions. Just a thought.
Strassmann, B., Kurapati, N., Hug, B., Burke, E., Gillespie, B., Karafet, T., & Hammer, M. (2012). Religion as a means to assure paternity Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1110442109
This article by Tom Rees was first published on Epiphenom. It is licensed under Creative Commons.
These articles might interest you :
Are there atheists in foxholes? It's another fascinating topic that has seen quite a lot of development over recent years. The study that kicked it all off was... Read moreThe 19 July 2012 by Tomrees8
DEBATE, RELIGION, SCIENCE, SOCIETY, SPIRITUALITY
Small effects sometimes matter - but psychology can do betterOne of the things that bugs me about 'embodied' cognition research is that the effects, while... Read moreThe 17 August 2012 by Andrew D Wilson
LANGUAGES, PHILOSOPHY, PSYCHOLOGY, SCIENCE
If you’ve watched the news in the past day or so, or followed any health-related twitter feeds, no doubt you’ve seen the reports that the radiofrequency... Read moreThe 01 June 2011 by Thecancergeek
HEALTH, MEDICINE, SCIENCE
Walking upright is one of the defining features of humans, separating us from the rest of the living apes. So it’s hardly surprising that the origins of... Read moreThe 15 October 2013 by Reprieve
Copstick (in blue) at Mama Biashara projectYesterday, my blog continued the saga of comedy critic Kate Copstick’s recent visit to Kenya, where she has been... Read moreThe 18 October 2013 by Thejohnfleming
WebMD has a quiz on “Cancer Myths and Facts.” It’s short, comprised of only 8 questions, and should take you only a couple of minutes to take. Click here to tak... Read moreThe 15 August 2013 by Eowyn
DEBATE, POLITICS, SOCIETY, SPIRITUALITY
Over the past two decades, the Polish economy has undergone dramatic change as it shifted towards a liberal market. That, in turn, has lead to profound changes... Read moreThe 13 April 2013 by Tomrees8
DEBATE, RELIGION, SPIRITUALITY
MOST POPULAR FROM DEBATE
- No Party: Only Hope for Change by Technocowgirl
- Liberal journalist Seymour Hersh says Obama made up the intelligence for war on Syria by Eowyn
- Washington Times full-page ad on Obama’s forged Select Service Registration by Eowyn
- Screeching for Jewish Blood at San Francisco State University by Mikelumish
Hurricane Irene Lady Gaga Economy Hurricane Sandy Halloween Lance Armstrong Samsung The Company Men Russia European Union Apps Thanksgiving Apple Occupy Wall Street Winter Sports North Korea True Blood Nuclear Energy The Olympics Climate Change Academy Awards Rick Perry Egypt The Box Office Turkey Christmas John Galliano Harry Potter China Barack Obama