Debate Magazine

Derek Carlile Gets a Mistrial

Posted on the 14 November 2012 by Mikeb302000
Derek Carlile Gets a Mistrial Local news reports
Derek Carlile's daughter Jenna was killed after he left a gun unsecured in the family's van while Carlile and his wife were out of the vehicle. His 3-year-old son got ahold of the weapon that went off, shooting Jenna in the stomach.  She later died at a hospital.
The jury told the judge that after several votes, it was deadlocked.  The judge questioned jurors, and declared a mistrial Tuesday afternoon.
Prosecutors said the little boy, who was used to playing with toy guns, saw Carlile's loaded .38-caliber service revolver, that the gun could have been put in a lockable storage box and that its safety lock was not engaged.
Carlile's attorney said the officer meant to put the off-duty weapon on his ankle, but simply got distracted and never meant to leave his children in danger.
That's as good as a not-guilty. Gun negligence is not taken seriously enough unless someone is killed. In those cases, especially if it's the gun owner's kid, the pity factor gets them a pass. How could a jury be deadlocked in a open-and-shut case like this otherwise.  They felt sorry for the guy.
A man who does something like this should never have another chance to misuse his gun rights. I don't see much good in putting him in jail, but the loss of gun rights should be a given.
What's your opinion?  Please leave a comment.

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Lawful Florida Gun Owner Gets Found Out

    Lawful Florida Owner Gets Found

    Local news reports A Flagler Beach woman is accused of firing a shot outside of a State Road A1A bar, upset because she was ready to leave but her friend wasn’t... Read more

    By  Mikeb302000
  • Massachusetts Gets One Thing Right…

    Massachusetts Gets Thing Right…

    They aren’t all that stoopid – even though they elected known “Cherokee” liar Elizabeth Warren to senate. Massachusetts voters narrowly defeat Question 2,... Read more

    By  Eowyn
  • Abortionist Gets Closed Door Hearing

    Abortionist Gets Closed Door Hearing

    NM Medical Board Closes Sella Disciplinary Hearing over Botched 35 Week AbortionOperation Rescue: The New Mexico Medical Board has decided to close the... Read more

    By  Eowyn
  • NRA Gets Rave Reviews

    Gets Rave Reviews

    Bear in mind, both newspapers slant conservative; both endorsed Mitt Romney in 2012. From a public relations perspective, I would have thought WayneO would... Read more

    By  Mikeb302000
  • NRA Hero, Schaeffer Cox Gets 26 Years

    Remember the pride of the NRA, Schaeffer Cox? Well, seems Cox will be taking a well-deserved hiatus from talkin' tough 'bout guns and the occasional... Read more

    By  Mikeb302000
  • POS Gets Inaugurated as POTUS

    Gets Inaugurated POTUS

    Today is a day of mourning for America.Today, the POS will be inaugurated, at an estimated cost of $300 million, to reign for four more years — or... Read more

    By  Eowyn
  • Concert Review: He's Only Just Begun

    Concert Review: He's Only Just Begun

    Berlioz, George Benjamin and Ravel with the BSO at Carnegie Hall. by Paul J. Pelkonen Hector Berlioz (center) and his muse Harriet Smithson as depicted on the... Read more

    By  Superconductor