Debate Magazine

Derek Carlile Gets a Mistrial

Posted on the 14 November 2012 by Mikeb302000
Derek Carlile Gets a Mistrial Local news reports
Derek Carlile's daughter Jenna was killed after he left a gun unsecured in the family's van while Carlile and his wife were out of the vehicle. His 3-year-old son got ahold of the weapon that went off, shooting Jenna in the stomach.  She later died at a hospital.
The jury told the judge that after several votes, it was deadlocked.  The judge questioned jurors, and declared a mistrial Tuesday afternoon.
Prosecutors said the little boy, who was used to playing with toy guns, saw Carlile's loaded .38-caliber service revolver, that the gun could have been put in a lockable storage box and that its safety lock was not engaged.
Carlile's attorney said the officer meant to put the off-duty weapon on his ankle, but simply got distracted and never meant to leave his children in danger.
That's as good as a not-guilty. Gun negligence is not taken seriously enough unless someone is killed. In those cases, especially if it's the gun owner's kid, the pity factor gets them a pass. How could a jury be deadlocked in a open-and-shut case like this otherwise.  They felt sorry for the guy.
A man who does something like this should never have another chance to misuse his gun rights. I don't see much good in putting him in jail, but the loss of gun rights should be a given.
What's your opinion?  Please leave a comment.

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Best Resorts in Cancun for a Family of 5

    Best Resorts Cancun Family

    Long-time readers of A Week at the Beach know that I love Mexico’s Riviera Maya for a family beach vacation. With plenty of flights from around the United... Read more

    The 20 September 2015 by   Sarah Fazendin
  • Restaurant Review | The Bar and Eatery, Koregaon Park, Pune

    Restaurant Review Eatery, Koregaon Park, Pune

    Its 3.30 pm. I have just finished a meeting and I am famished. A simple snack will not do. Oh no! I am in need of a full meal right from starters to desserts-... Read more

    The 20 September 2015 by   Maneeshhr
  • 5 Reasons We’re Excited for TURF 2015

    Reasons We’re Excited TURF 2015

    The start of TURF is just hours away. It’s our first time covering the festival and we’re pretty excited.It’s going to be a packed 3 days at Historic Fort... Read more

    The 18 September 2015 by   Phjoshua
  • Cocktails For Cougars and Cowgirls

    Cocktails Cougars Cowgirls

    Here’s a great gift idea for girlfriends!  Cocktails for Cougars and Cowgirls: Simple and Delicious Recipes for Every Woman presents the prettiest and tastiest... Read more

    The 18 September 2015 by   Mimiavocado
  • The Ganeshas of Thandalam

    Ganeshas Thandalam

    While we were on the recce visits of the temples along the banks of the river Cooum, we visited a village called Thandalam, which is one of the eighteen... Read more

    The 17 September 2015 by   Priyabaskar
  • Explaining Sanders's "Socialism" to Kansans

    Explaining Sanders's "Socialism" Kansans

    [Cross-posted to Political Context]I appreciate the kind attention which The Wichita Eagle recently paid to us local Democrats, progressive liberals, Christian... Read more

    The 17 September 2015 by   Russellarbenfox
  • Apple Inc. Getting Ready To Use New .apple gTLD Domain Extension?

    Apple Inc. Getting Ready .apple gTLD Domain Extension?

    Apple Inc. has registered 29 new .com domain names and looking at the list, the domains look a little "odd" but consider the fact that Apple Inc. has applied fo... Read more

    The 18 September 2015 by   Worldwide

Add a comment