Debate Magazine

Derek Carlile Gets a Mistrial

Posted on the 14 November 2012 by Mikeb302000
Derek Carlile Gets a Mistrial Local news reports
Derek Carlile's daughter Jenna was killed after he left a gun unsecured in the family's van while Carlile and his wife were out of the vehicle. His 3-year-old son got ahold of the weapon that went off, shooting Jenna in the stomach.  She later died at a hospital.
The jury told the judge that after several votes, it was deadlocked.  The judge questioned jurors, and declared a mistrial Tuesday afternoon.
Prosecutors said the little boy, who was used to playing with toy guns, saw Carlile's loaded .38-caliber service revolver, that the gun could have been put in a lockable storage box and that its safety lock was not engaged.
Carlile's attorney said the officer meant to put the off-duty weapon on his ankle, but simply got distracted and never meant to leave his children in danger.
That's as good as a not-guilty. Gun negligence is not taken seriously enough unless someone is killed. In those cases, especially if it's the gun owner's kid, the pity factor gets them a pass. How could a jury be deadlocked in a open-and-shut case like this otherwise.  They felt sorry for the guy.
A man who does something like this should never have another chance to misuse his gun rights. I don't see much good in putting him in jail, but the loss of gun rights should be a given.
What's your opinion?  Please leave a comment.

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • How Much Sleep Do We Need?

    The National Sleep Foundation has produced new guidelines on how much sleep we need throughout our life.  Along with a multi-disciplinary expert panel, the... Read more

    The 06 February 2015 by   Sharon Dalzell
    HOME
  • Take Your Sweetheart to The World’s Best Red Wines

    A glass of red wine is arguably a staple in a Valentine’s Day dinner. Sharing a bottle of red is not only romantic, but it also enhances and complements the... Read more

    The 06 February 2015 by   Healthytravelblog
    HEALTH, TRAVEL
  • 5 Fiction Books That Are Must Read in 2015

    Reading is one of the best ways of escaping reality and creating your own imaginary universe, at least for a couple of hours. Out of the numerous literary and... Read more

    The 06 February 2015 by   Gaurav Tiwari
    SCIENCE
  • Welcome to the Weekend…(the Power of a Kind Word)

    I was busy preparing my upcoming post, a mix of travel and humor (two of my favorite things), when I decided to slow it down and write a “Welcome to the Weekend... Read more

    The 06 February 2015 by   Stylemindchic
    HOME, LIFESTYLE
  • Comedy’s Captain Beefheart Twonkey Ruminates on Robot Arms and Replicants

    Paul Vickers talked to me from Edinburgh via Skype yesterdayPaul Vickers performs on stage as Mr Twonkey.“I went to art college and that’s when it all went... Read more

    The 06 February 2015 by   Thejohnfleming
    CULTURE, ENTERTAINMENT
  • Recipe | Oreo Cookie Crumb Bar

    I can't quite contain my excitement for this post, I wasn't even suppose to make it till next week but I just couldn't resist! Read more

    The 06 February 2015 by   Ourbabyblog
    FAMILY, SELF EXPRESSION
  • Game 52: Penguins at Flames

    The Western Canada road swing continues tonight in Calgary. Scouting the Flames (from the Penguins' website) - http://video.penguins.nhl.com/videoc... Read more

    The 06 February 2015 by   Kipper
    SPORTS

Add a comment

Magazine