Cultural Transmission of Religious Violence: is It Inherited Or DiffusedBy Tomrees8
Some of these groups (around half), advocated the violent overthrow of government and existing churches to establish a theocracy. The other half, although often sharing the same ultimate goal, were non-violent.
Luke Matthews, an anthropologist at Harvard University, was interested in what governed whether a particular group was violent or pacifist.
In particular, he wanted to know if the most important factor was whether the parent group advocated violence, or whether the personal relationships between the groups that mattered more.
So he analysed the different groups, using a statistical technique borrowed from evolutionary biology, to see if inheritance was important. He also looked at whether the leaders of the congregations knew each other personally, and whether that had any influence over shared attitudes.
What he found was that, for violent beliefs, the most important factor was whether the groups shared a common inheritance. Violent groups, it seems, beget violent splinter groups.
That wasn't the case for other theological beliefs - for example, whether they observed Sabbath on a Saturday, or practised polygamy, or believed in purgatory. All of these were better explained by personal connections between group leaders.
So it seems that while religious ethical beliefs diffused from one group to another, attitudes towards violent revolution were inherited.
Quite why that would be is not clear - although ti me this suggests that attitudes towards violence must define what each group is about is some fundamental way. Whereas other beliefs are up for negotiation, belief in violence or pacifism is not.
Luke J. Matthewsa, Jeffrey Edmonds, Wesley J. Wildman, & Charles L. Nunn (2012). Cultural inheritance or cultural diffusion of religious violence? A quantitative case study of the Radical Reformation Religion, Brain & Behavior, 1-13 DOI: 10.1080/2153599X.2012.707388
This article by Tom Rees was first published on Epiphenom. It is licensed under Creative Commons.
These articles might interest you :
Last week at the Huffington Post site, Arianna Huffington announced that the Oprah Winfrey Network would air several programs on 27 October about being gay in... Read moreThe 28 October 2013 by William Lindsey
LGBTQ, RELIGION, SOCIETY
The National Museum of Scotland, like many museums in the British Isles, is free to visitors. Such museums are repositories of national pride and provide a sens... Read moreThe 19 July 2013 by Steveawiggins
POLITICS, RELIGION, SOCIETY
Globalization has ensured that international borders are heavily relaxed so large and profitable domestic firms from one nation can pursue business interests... Read moreThe 28 May 2013 by The Conscience Blog
DEBATE, POLITICS, SOCIETY
My friend Wendell Griffen maintains that the George Zimmerman trial demonstrates that American lawyers are still not trained to be culturally competent--to... Read moreThe 03 August 2013 by William Lindsey
LGBTQ, RELIGION, SOCIETY
Michael L. It doesn't even matter if these are Islamist rebels supported by the Obama regime - they are - or if they are Assad loyalists. Read moreThe 01 December 2013 by Mikelumish
John Stonestreet over at LifeSiteNews is making some sense: The writer Upton Sinclair, commenting on his loss in the 1934 California gubernatorial election,... Read moreThe 23 April 2013 by Brutallyhonest
I’ve been reading Odd Girls and Twilight Lovers, Lillian Faderman’s sweeping social history of lesbians in 20th century America (this is the sort of thing I do... Read moreThe 24 March 2013 by Brute Reason
SOCIETY, WOMEN'S ISSUES
MOST POPULAR FROM DEBATE
- Antisemitic Event At SFSU Tomorrow by Mikelumish
- Proposed Maryland law seeks to identify gun owners with a criminal record by Eowyn
- Movement to break away and form new states gains traction by Eowyn
- Obama executive order declares national emergency; Ukraine crisis an “extraordinary threat” to U.S. national security by Eowyn
ON THE DEBATE FORUM
- Dr. Zia Uddin Khan Writes A ... Reviewed by Unitedthree
- D.C. Re-Registration Requirement to Take Effect ... Reviewed by Carlos
- Stoner president endorses pot Reviewed by Gwen
- Why hurricanes turn anti-clockwise in the ... Reviewed by Diet