Environment Magazine

Classics: Demography Versus Genetics

Posted on the 15 March 2011 by Bradshaw @conservbytes

Here’s another short, but sweet Conservation Classic highlighted in our upcoming book chapter (see previous entries on this book). Today’s entry comes from long-time quantitative ecology guru, Russ Lande, who is now based at the Silwood Park Campus (Imperial College London).

Classics: demography versus genetics


In an influential review, Lande (1988) argued that

“…demography may usually be of more immediate importance than population genetics in determining the minimum viable size of wild populations”.

It was a well-reasoned case, and was widely interpreted to mean that demographic and ecological threats would provide the ‘killer blow’ to threatened species before genetic factors such as inbreeding and fitness effects of loss of genetic diversity had time to exert a major influence on small population dynamics.

Lande’s paper ignited a fire under the belly of conservation geneticists, and led to a concerted effort to come up with stronger evidence for the role of genetics in elevating extinction risk. This in turn resulted in innovative field experiments (Saccheri et al., 1998), meta-analyses on genetically effective population size (Frankham 1995), studies on the enhanced effect of inbreeding on wild populations (Crnokrak & Roff, 1999), and a pairwise comparison of 170 threatened taxa showing that the majority had indeed suffered from a reduction genetic diversity compared to their non-threatened congeners (Spielman et al., 2004).

The net conclusion is that demographic and genetic changes can work in concert in small populations to threaten their viability and survival (Mills & Smouse, 1994).

CJA Bradshaw, NS Sodhi, WF Laurance, BW Brook

ResearchBlogging.orgLande, R. (1988). Genetics and demography in biological conservation Science, 241 (4872), 1455-1460 DOI: 10.1126/science.3420403

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • The Winter of Blazing Discontent Continues in the Arctic

    GR: Climate change in action. We are losing the polar ice cap and that is changing Earth’s climate right now. Nothing good will come of it. “Weird. Strange.... Read more

    By  Garry Rogers
  • National Roll out of New Approach to Great Crested Newt Licensing

    National Roll Approach Great Crested Newt Licensing

    Natural England is to implement an innovative new approach to the conservation of great crested newts across the country, following support from government. Read more

    By  Philpickin
  • Not All Wetlands Are Created Equal

    Wetlands Created Equal

    Last year I wrote what has become a highly viewed post here at ConservationBytes.com about the plight of the world’s freshwater biodiversity. In a word, it’s... Read more

    By  Bradshaw
  • 2500 Miles Jan Update

    2500 Miles Update

    Well that is month one coming to an end (OK there are a few hours left, but I'm not planning on walking very much more, bar to my bed, and maybe the kitchen... Read more

    By  Ashley Crombet-Beolens
  • Milton Keynes Three Lake Walk

    Milton Keynes Three Lake Walk

    As a small child I remember sitting inside school at wet playtime, watching as the rain drops splashed down heavily in the puddles outside, dreamily staring as... Read more

    By  Ashley Crombet-Beolens
  • Platform Addition for the Justice Democrats

    Platform Addition Justice Democrats

    Justice Democrats Platform Omission Monarch butterfly at Coldwater Farm. I agree with the 20 items included in the Justice Democrats platform. My concerns for... Read more

    By  Garry Rogers
  • Sheppy Birding

    Sheppy Birding

    Whenever I visit my old man we try to get out for a spot of birding at least once, our day this time round was a day out in search of owls and raptors at one... Read more

    By  Ashley Crombet-Beolens