Debate Magazine

Castle Doctrine, Or Murder?

Posted on the 13 July 2011 by Mikeb302000
I leave it to you, our readers, to discuss - was it wrong to shoot someone who no longer posed a threat, and who may not have been armed in the first place?  Does the Castle doctrine apply?  Was Ersland in the wrong to pursue one of the suspects outside the store, instead of allowing him to retreat?
Have at it!
From MSNBC:
Oklahoma pharmacist sentenced to life for killing would-be robber
Fifty-nine-year-old calls his sentence 'an injustice of a monumental proportion'
An Oklahoma pharmacist has been sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole for first-degree murder in the shooting death of a teenager who tried to rob the south Oklahoma City pharmacy where he worked.
Fifty-nine-year-old Jerome Ersland was sentenced Monday after Oklahoma County District Judge Ray Elliott rejected a defense motion to suspend the sentence.
Ersland had no reaction and said nothing as the sentence was handed down. As he left the courtroom, he responded to a reporter's shouted question by calling the sentence "an injustice of a monumental proportion."
A jury convicted Ersland and recommended the life with the possibility of parole sentence for the May 2009 shooting of 16-year-old Antwun Parker. Defense attorney Irven Box said the conviction and sentence will be appealed.
Confronted by two holdup men, Ersland pulled a gun, shot one of them in the head and chased the other away. Then, in a scene recorded by the drugstore's security camera, he went behind the counter, got another gun, and pumped five more bullets into Parker as he lay on the floor unconscious.
At the trial, prosecutors argued that Ersland crossed into the wrong when he shot the unarmed and unconscious Parker five more times.
Ersland contended that he was defending himself and two co-workers from a robber who still posed a threat.
Please don't give up hope'
Thousands of Ersland's supporters have reportedly signed petitions pushing Gov. Mary Fallin to pardon the pharmacist, or ease his sentence.
Video: Was it murder or self-defense? (on this page)
"Please people, don't give up hope. We got 17,000 signatures in a month," Ersland's friend and activist Karen Monahan told KOCO.
Monahan told the station she is selling T-shirts and collecting signatures to help save the life of her good friend.
"The last time I talked to him (Ersland), he was over-excited. He's getting letters (of support) from people he doesn't even know," Monahan reportedly said.

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Wrong Guy Shot - 1st-Degree Murder Anyway

    Does that sound right to you? These dopey criminals went to the wrong house. Can it still be murder in the 1st degree? Where do you think they got their guns... Read more

    By  Mikeb302000
    CURRENT, DEBATE, SOCIETY
  • Another Brutal Gun Murder in Florida

    Another Brutal Murder Florida

    Seth Tyler Jackson, photo from CBS News / 48 hours mystery Six arrested in brutal murder of Fla. boySix people, including a 15-year-old girl and three other... Read more

    By  Mikeb302000
    CURRENT, DEBATE, SOCIETY
  • “Good Mothers Don’t Murder Their Kids”

    “Good Mothers Don’t Murder Their Kids”

    Another tragic case of a mother drowning her children, and herself, come out of New Jersey this week. A young black mother of four drove her minivan, with all... Read more

    By  Gradmommy
    DEBATE, FAMILY, PARENTING
  • Is It (Attempted) Murder?

    (Attempted) Murder?

    A mother was recently convicted of attempted murder for withholding cancer medication from her child, a child who subsequently died when his cancer returned... Read more

    By  Gradmommy
    DEBATE, FAMILY, PARENTING
  • Murder on Staten Island

    The New York Post reports A crazed gunman blew away his business partner inside the victim's Staten Island home, wounded his wife, then held a weapon to their... Read more

    By  Mikeb302000
    CURRENT, DEBATE, SOCIETY
  • Attempted Murder, Murder and Suicide in Illinois

    The Quad-City Times reports all the gory details. But basically it's the same old story: abusive boyfriend, restraining order, he comes back with a gun. Read more

    By  Mikeb302000
    DEBATE, SOCIETY
  • Felony Murder in Miami

    The Miami Herald reports Authorities are trying to determine whether the fatal shooting of an intruder attempting to steal a wave runner outside a Miami... Read more

    By  Mikeb302000
    DEBATE

Magazine