Books Magazine

Booker Prize Shortlist: Alan Hollinghurst Omission Causes Trouble

By Periscope @periscopepost
Booker Prize shortlist: Alan Hollinghurst omission causes trouble

Some of the longlisted books. Photocredit:

The Man Booker Prize shortlist was announced yesterday. The list includes four British authors, (Julian Barnes, Carol Birch, Stephen Kelman and A D Miller) and two first time novelists. The judging committee was chaired by Dame Stella Rimington, the erstwhile director of MI5, and included politician Chris Mullin, Daily Telegraph Head of Books Gaby Wood, novelist Susan Hill and journalist Matthew D’Ancona. The winner trousers £50,000 and is guaranteed rocket-fuelled sales boosts (see Howard Jacobson’s Finkler Question and Hilary Mantel’s Wolf Hall.)

The judges have caused controversy by claiming that they were prizing readability over any other quality. Stella Rimington said “”We want people to buy these books and read them, not buy them and admire them,” on The Guardian, whilst The New Yorker‘s Book Bench quoted Chris Mullin: “Other people said to me when they heard I was in the judging panel, ‘I hope you pick something readable this year.’ That was such a big factor, it had to zip along.”

Longlisted authors Sebastian Barry (previously shortlisted twice) and Alan Hollinghurst (a  winner seven years ago for The Line of Beauty) did not make the final cut. Current favourite is Julian Barnes for his novella The Sense of an Ending, which is at 13/8 on Ladbrokes. First timer A D Miller’s Snowdrops is set in a plutocratic, amoral Moscow, and his fellow debuter Stephen Kelman’s Pigeon English tells the story of a young Ghanaian immigrant. There are also four books from independent publishers: Canongate, Serpent’s Tail, Atlantic and Granta. The shortlist is below.

  • Ho for Hollinghurst! Harry Mount, on his Daily Telegraph blog, was completely at a loss at Alan Hollinghurst’s omission. Was it because he’s won before? Surely not – J G Farrell carted off the prize twice, as did Peter Carey. Opportunities to put him on the list are rare – and leaving him off now is like “omitting Evelyn Waugh in the 1930s or Kingsley Amis in the 1960s” (though of course the Booker wasn’t around then.) The other books will have to be “exceptionally accomplished to knock Hollinghurst out of the reckoning.”
  • BUBAR? (Bookered up beyond all recognition.) Boyd Tonkin in The Independentwas equally scornful. The French have a prize, the Priz Décembre, which is designed to correct literary awards earlier in the year. We Brits are in urgent need of such a gong. A prize dedicated to pure brilliance in fiction, without the whiff of celebrity judges, would not constantly seek novelties and want to “cut a dash and make a splash”. This year is a decidedly “mixed bag.” Many will be wondering what the point is. The Booker Prize needs to get its act together.
  • Should we care? Why should Alan Hollinghurst be on the list? asked Elizabeth Minkel on The New Yorker’s Book Bench blog. He won it seven years ago, after all. Nicholas Blincoe, on Twitter, said that reading Hollinghurst was like “sitting the Civil Service exam.” The story’s really about the British literary establishment, said Minkel, with the “ancient” Julian Barnes pitted against a selection of novelists with an average age of 44. The judges wanted books that would be read. This is kind of “depressing”. But why should we care about literary prizes anyway? Take a look at The Guardian‘s Not the Booker Prize – it’s much more fun.
The ShortlistJulian Barnes The Sense of an Ending (Jonathan Cape – Random House)

Carol Birch Jamrach’s Menagerie (Canongate Books)

Patrick deWitt The Sisters Brothers (Granta)

Esi Edugyan Half Blood Blues (Serpent’s Tail)

Stephen Kelman Pigeon English (Bloomsbury)

A.D. Miller Snowdrops (Atlantic)

More on books

  • Steve Jobs book
  • Five best plot twists
  • Major coup for Amazon
  • Wizard! It’s Pottermore!

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Man Booker Prize Longlist Announced

    The longlist for the Man Booker Prize for fiction was unveiled yesterday in London. The chair of judges said, "We are delighted by the quality and breadth of... Read more

    By  Bookpassage
  • Top Five Booker Scandals

    Five Booker Scandals

    Joanna Lumley: Booker controversy. Photocredit: Liberal Democrats. Booker Prize was... Read more

    By  Periscope
  • An Interview with Alan Rinzler and Myself

    Author Meghan Ward has a fantastic blog about writing calledWriterland. Recently she did an interview with myself and my friend (and legendary editor) Alan... Read more

    By  Andyross
  • Alan Gura on the Term "Reasonable"

    Robert Farago interviewing and asking great questions. I suggested in a comment over on TTAG that Robert should have followed up these questions with one about... Read more

    By  Mikeb302000
  • Alan Colmes on Newt's Nonsense

    via Alan Colmes LiberalandNewt Gingrich says it’s not the Constitution that gives us the right to own a gun, it’s God. Alan's response: Isn’t it God who gives... Read more

    By  Mikeb302000
  • Prize-fighting Rules and Unsuitable Epitaphs

    Prize-fighting Rules Unsuitable Epitaphs

    In discussing the extraordinary gravestone of George Taylor, pugilist and master of the cross-buttock throw, I mentioned his dispute with fellow prize-fighter... Read more

    By  Carolineld
  • Is the Mercury Prize Cursed?

    Mercury Prize Cursed?

    PJ Harvey is the first artist to win the Mercury Prize twice. Read more

    By  Periscope