And the numbers are… fuzzy.
Public health officials in the UK have been wringing their hands for some time now over perceived rates of binge drinking among the populace. In a 2010 survey of 27,000 Europeans by the official polling agency of the EU, binge drinking in the UK—defined as five or more drinks in one, er, binge—clocked in at a rate of 34%, compared to an EU average of 29%. Predictably, the highest rate of UK binge drinking was found in people between the ages of 15 and 24. This still lagged well behind the Irish (44%) and the Romanians (39%). Scant comfort, perhaps, given the historical role drinking has played in those two cultures, but still, clearly, the British and the rest of the UK are above-average drinkers.
Or are they? And what about the U.S. How do we rank? For comparative purposes, we can use the “Vital Signs” survey in the United States from 2010, performed by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and published in CDC’s Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, results of which are pictured above. Using almost the same criteria for binge drinking—five drinks at a sitting for men, four drinks for women—the study concludes that the “overall prevalence of binge drinking was 17.1%. Among binge drinkers, the frequency of binge drinking was 4.4 episodes per month, and the intensity was 7.9 drinks on occasion.”
By the CDC’s definition, the heaviest binge drinking in America takes place in the Midwest, parts of New England, D.C., and Alaska. Survey respondents with an income in excess of $75,000 were the most serious bingers (20.2%), but those making under $25,000 binged more often and had more drinks per binge than other groups, the report says. And binge drinking is about twice as prevalent among men. Binge drinking, the survey concludes, is reported by one of every six U.S. adults.
Even so, it appears that the U.S. does not have the same level of binge drinking as the UK. However, astute readers have no doubt noticed that actual binge drinkers in the U.S. were consuming almost 8 drinks per bout, well above the official mark of four or five drinks at one time. The problem is that there is no internationally agreed upon definition of binge drinking. A 2010 fact sheet from the UK’s Institute of Alcohol Studies (IAS) maintains that “drinking surveys normally define binge drinkers as men consuming at least eight, and women at least six standard units of alcohol in a single day, that is, double the maximum recommended ‘safe limit’ for men and women respectively.”
But referring to binge drinking as “high intake of alcohol in a single drinking occasion” is misleading, says IAS. The problem is biological: “Because of individual variations in, for example, body weight and alcohol tolerance, as well as factors such as speed of consumption, there is not a simple, consistent correlation between the number of units consumed, their resulting blood alcohol level and the subjective effects on the drinker.”
Furthermore, the report charges that “researchers have criticized the term ‘binge drinking’ as unclear, politically charged and therefore, unhelpful in that many (young) people do not identify themselves as binge drinkers because, despite exceeding the number of drinks officially used to define bingeing, they drink at a slow enough pace to avoid getting seriously drunk.”
There you have it. As currently defined and measured, binge drinking is a relatively useless metric for assessing a population’s alcohol habits. “The different definitions employed need to be taken into account in understanding surveys of drinking behavior and calculations of how many binge drinkers there are in the population,” as the UK report wisely puts it. Take the above chart with a few grains of salt.
Photo Credit: CDC
These articles might interest you :
We all know that feeding our children – or ourselves – processed foods isn’t a good idea. But I think many of us believe that it’s unhealthy if eaten to excess... Read moreThe 08 June 2015 by Tonicnutrition1
FOOD & DRINK, HEALTH, RECIPES, VEGETARIAN & VEGAN
Dental treatments done in India are by far 65 to 90 per cent cheaper than the developed world. The favourable cost-benefit ratio in treatment has led... Read moreThe 28 March 2015 by Anan Adisa
Spicier than ever.Four drug deaths last month in Britain have been blamed on so-called “Superman” pills being sold as Ecstasy, but actually containing PMMA, a... Read moreThe 05 February 2015 by Dirkh
HEALTH, PSYCHOLOGY, SCIENCE
Do you use Vaseline? Or are you a purist who refuses to use any petrol-type product or anything with mineral oil? I love making my own products anyway, so my... Read moreThe 14 January 2015 by Yellowstar2000
BODY, MIND, SPIRIT, HAIR & BEAUTY, HEALTH
Today in a landmark decision a European Union court decided that “obesity”in and of itself does not constitute a disability, but that if it creates a situation... Read moreThe 19 December 2014 by Danceswithfat
DIET & WEIGHT, FITNESS, HEALTH
Who smokes cannabis, and how much?(First published 12/27/2013)Most statistical surveys of marijuana focus on a single quantitative measurement: How many people... Read moreThe 13 November 2014 by Dirkh
HEALTH, PSYCHOLOGY, SCIENCE
In all the excitement about the research being presented at ASH and ASCO and EHA on the new therapies for CLL, it is important to remember that infection, mostl... Read moreThe 25 June 2014 by Bkoffman
MOST POPULAR FROM HEALTH
- PRAWN AND MANGO SKEWERS ! by Fitnessontoast
- Dopey Challenge Training Update by Fitfulfocus
- ADH 2014: Dr. Sharman on Cell Death in CLL (chronic lymphocytic leukemia) ,a patient meeting, a newsletter and iwCLL by Bkoffman
- Lose Weight Using Weight Loss Pills by Dietdoctor
MOST RECOMMENDED IN HEALTH
- Bacon Mushroom Cheeseburger Lettuce Wraps by Dietdoctor
- George Takei and Why I Can’t Take a Joke by Danceswithfat
- What If I’m Not Happy With My Weight by Danceswithfat
- “The Weight Fell Off” by Dietdoctor