Debate Magazine

Are Human Rights Universal?

Posted on the 19 April 2011 by Humanwriter @roseforman


If there is a separate convention outlining the rights of women and the elimination of the discrimination of women it implies that general human rights instruments fail to protect women. However, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights states that “all humans are entitled to all the rights and freedoms set forth” in the Declaration.[1] Sedley defines human rights as birthrights, in that we are all entitled to them freely and equally, rights are not something which should be earned. “Rights which are not recognised as universal cannot be human rights.”[2]


However, there are many factors which vary the importance or significance of rights to the individual, fundamental rights have changed over time, and will continue to change, when the Universal Declaration of Human Rights was first drafted in the 1940’s the intent was to protect individuals from State tyranny as seen in Communist and Fascist regimes. Nowadays the focus is more on using positive obligations to protect individuals from others, the state acts as the ‘guardian’. Fundamental rights also vary from culture to culture. For example the rights to vote or freedom of expression may be highly prioritised in developed States, but the right to freedom from slavery or forced labour is likely to be more relevant to individuals who are exploited in developing countries.


As Sedley states “the argument for universality foes not ignore these differentials.”[3] A further example of how rights have changed is the inclusion of gender under those protected from discrimination, when the Universal Declaration was drafted it would have been unthinkable to believe that women were oppressed or segregated in society in the same way as race and religion. However, certain cultures still carry the belief system of separating women and men’s equality, such as religious laws like Sharia. However, does this distinction between modern western ideology and cultures more resistant to change mean that non-western beliefs are wrong? This is where the margin of appreciation allows for cultural diversity, however, how can a right be universal if it is limited by the doctrines of the majority. Therefore if a majority of people believe that capital punishment is acceptable then does that negate the universality of the right to life? This example applies to the United States who have signed and ratified the Universal Declaration of Human Rights but many of its states still enforce the death penalty. Sedley defines one of the key characteristics of universality as “the non-negotiability of basic rights.”[4]


Furthermore, all rights are context based, as the right to life is negated by self-defence and can be derogated from in times of war or to quell a riot, also the prohibition of torture is defined as an ‘absolute right’, with no room for derogation, however many countries which have ratified the Universal Declaration still continue to use methods of inhumane or degrading treatment Therefore do human rights only work where they are recognised and enforced and the individuals from countries which do not enforce all rights and denied the universality of those rights?


[1] Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 10 December 1948,  Article 2[2] The Rt Hon Lord Justice Sedley Are Human Rights Universal, and Does it Matter? (University of Birmingham 2005) 2[3] Ibid[4] Ibid 4


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Tulip Stairs

    Tulip Stairs

    The first geometric, self-supporting spiral staircase in Britain is in the Queen's House, Greenwich. It is 'geometric' because each step supports the stair... Read more

    5 hours, 46 minutes ago by   Carolineld
    CULTURE, DESTINATIONS, HISTORY
  • Playing Under the Sea at Palau by Jennifer Avventura

    Playing Under Palau Jennifer Avventura

    Last year, I was given a super-duper under water camera, and I’ve had a ton of fun playing under the sea at Palau, Sardinia, Italy. Read more

    5 hours, 54 minutes ago by   Jenniferavventura
    DESTINATIONS, EXPAT, TRAVEL
  • How to Get a Thai Tax ID Without a Work Permit (Digital Nomads)

    Thai Without Work Permit (Digital Nomads)

    In this article, I am going to show you how to get your very own Thai tax ID to pay taxes in Thailand without having a work permit. I'll also explain in this... Read more

    5 hours, 57 minutes ago by   Harvie
    EXPAT, TRAVEL
  • Full Length Swimsuits Are This Summer Trends

    Full Length Swimsuits This Summer Trends

    This summer, the silhouette does not matter so much! Swimsuits in trends are so varied, from cuts and materials to prints, that choosing the most suitable... Read more

    6 hours, 40 minutes ago by   Poundtravel
    TRAVEL
  • Gremlin (2017)

    Gremlin (2017)

    Director: Ryan Bellgardt Writer: Ryan Bellgardt, Josh McKamie, Andy Swanson (Screenplay) Starring: Adam Hampton, Kristy K Boone, Catcher Stair, Katie Burgess,... Read more

    7 hours, 54 minutes ago by   Newguy
    CULTURE, ENTERTAINMENT, MOVIES
  • Bandcamp Bonanza – Strummed By Solstice

    Bandcamp Bonanza Strummed Solstice

    What a great week at camp we had. Just as Summer solstice slams us with record heat, the camp treasure chest opens its casket to uncover a rare combination of... Read more

    9 hours, 59 minutes ago by   Ripplemusic
    ENTERTAINMENT, MUSIC
  • Carpe Carmina Celebrates VIII (feat. Yarbo)

    Carpe Carmina Celebrates VIII (feat. Yarbo)

    Let's not shed a tear for today's the antepenultimate artistic contribution carpe carmina celebrates can present to you, on the contrary let's seize the moment... Read more

    10 hours ago by   Vanessa Holthausen
    ENTERTAINMENT, MUSIC

Magazines