Debate Magazine

Animist Theory of Mind (Nietzsche)

By Cris

As regular readers know, over the past few months I’ve been digging around the early literature on the origins, evolution, and history of what we we today call “religion.” In addition to the well known classics (David Hume, Charles Darwin, Edward Tylor, Emile Durkheim, and James Frazer), this literature includes lesser known work by early anthropologists such as RR Marett and John Lubbock.

As regular readers also know, I’m finding that these foundational figures have already thought and written about most of the things that have preoccupied cognitive and evolutionary scholars of religion over the past 15 years. The main differences seem to be that the old-timers didn’t have access to modern neuroscientific terminology or equipment, didn’t experiment with undergraduates or children, and didn’t run statistical tests on data. Other than these differences, much of what is ostensibly new in cognitive and evolutionary religious studies is actually quite old.

There was one thing, however, that I thought was truly new. This is the idea that “theory of mind” — the ability to attribute mental states to others and understand that others can have mental states different from one’s own — plays a key role in animist and religious thinking. Theory of mind research has been raging over the past few decades and continues unabated. So it must be new, right? Wrong.

Yesterday I was reading “Nietzsche’s Debt to Lubbock” (Thatcher 1983) and was chagrined to learn that Nietzsche argued this long ago:

Now man believed originally that wherever he saw something happen, a will had to be at work in the background as a cause, and a personal, willing being. Any notion of mechanics was far from his mind. But since man believed, for immense periods of time, only in persons [i.e., minds] (and not in substances, forces, things, and so forth), the faith in cause and effect became for him the basic faith that he applies wherever anything happens — and this is what he still does instinctively: it is an atavism of the most ancient origin. (Gay Science, aphorism 127).

Ancestral humans, in other words, “supposed that the mind was everywhere” and then “projected” mind onto everything (Dawn of Day, aphs. 31,17). Not convinced that Nietzsche is contemplating what we would today call “theory of mind”? Try this:

In the inner psychic economy of the primitive man, fear of evil predominates. What is evil? Three things: chance, the uncertain, the sudden. How does primitive man fight against evil? He conceives it as reason, as power, even as a person [i.e., mind]. In this way he establishes the possibility of entering into a kind of treaty with it and in general to exercise influence over it in advance — to forestall it. (Will to Power, aph. 1019).

This is theory of mind. Nietzsche clearly thinks it key to animist-religious ideation. He is in good company with modern scholars, many of whom argue the same thing with different language. I should have known.

Animist Theory of Mind (Nietzsche)

Share

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Where Did The Oracles Go?

    Previously: Interview With The Apostate The year before he and his brother were murdered, Joseph Smith taught us something valuable about the kingdom of God, an... Read more

    The 27 June 2015 by   Rockwaterman
    SOCIETY, SPIRITUALITY
  • Is Nuclear Energy Renewable?

    Nuclear energy is the energy that is in the core (nucleus) of an atom. Atoms are small particles which make up the entire universe and everything it holds. Read more

    The 28 June 2015 by   Rinkesh
    ENVIRONMENT
  • Happy Wimbledon!

    It's the most wonderful time of the year - time for Wimbledon! The Championships, Wimbledon runs from June 29 to July 12, 2015 at the All England Club in... Read more

    The 29 June 2015 by   Kselz
    SPORTS, TENNIS
  • Boots & Hearts 2015 Emerging Artist Showcase Preview: Birds of Bellwoods

    I caught up with Birds of Bellwoods last week prior to their NXNE show at The Cameron House. We talked about the Boots and Hearts Emerging Artist Showcase,... Read more

    The 26 June 2015 by   Phjoshua
    LIFESTYLE, SELF EXPRESSION
  • The Samadhis of Harrington Road!

    Recently, I was invited by a friend to speak at a Story telling event, the topic of which was Stories in and around Harrington Road. Read more

    The 28 June 2015 by   Priyabaskar
    TRAVEL
  • Review: Mr Holmes

    Turns out my father is Sherlock Holmes. In many ways I shouldn't have been surprised by this news but within the first few minutes of watching the new film Mr... Read more

    The 27 June 2015 by   Kirsty Stonell Walker
    CULTURE
  • A Great Foodie Day Out At The Good Food Show Summer 2015

    A GREAT FOODIE DAY OUTThe BBC Good Food Shows are back for 2015, bringing together a fantastic mix of seasonal inspiration, local produce and live demonstration... Read more

    The 28 June 2015 by   Hannah Staveley
    FAMILY, HOME

Add a comment