Environment Magazine

Angry Papuan Leaders Demand Jared Diamond Apologizes

Posted on the 04 February 2013 by Earth First! Newswire
Benny Wenda, a Papuan tribal leader, says what Jared Diamond is writing about his people is 'misleading'. Benny Wenda, a Papuan tribal leader, says what Jared Diamond is writing about his people is ‘misleading’. © freewestpapua.org/Survival

Cross Posted from Survival International

Leaders across West Papua have demanded controversial author Jared Diamond apologizes for describing them in his new book as warlike, and strengthening the idea that indigenous people are ‘backwards’.

The West Papuan leaders attack Diamond’s central arguments that ’most small-scale societies (…) become trapped in cycles of violence and warfare’ and that ‘New Guineans appreciated the benefits of the state-guaranteed peace that they had been unable to achieve for themselves without state government.’

Mr Diamond makes no mention of the brutality and oppression suffered by the people of West Papua at the hands of the Indonesian occupation since 1963, which has led to the killing of at least 100,000 Papuan tribal people at the hands of the Indonesian military.

Benny Wenda, a Papuan tribal leader, said to Survival, ‘What he (Jared Diamond) has written about my people is misleading (…) he is not writing about what the Indonesian military are doing (…) I saw my people being murdered by Indonesian soldiers and my own Auntie was raped in front of my eyes. Indonesia told the world that this was ’tribal war’ – they tried to pretend that it was us that was violent and not them – this book is doing the same. He should apologize.’

Markus Haluk, a senior member of the Papuan Customary Council, added, ‘The total of Dani victims from the Indonesian atrocities over the 50 year period is far greater than those from tribal war of the Dani people over hundreds of thousands of years.’

Jared Diamond's book has come under attack for portraying tribal people as warlike and 'living in the past'. Jared Diamond’s book has come under attack for portraying tribal people as warlike and ‘living in the past’. © Survival

Matius Murib, Director of the Baptist Voice of Papua, condemned Diamond’s assertion that tribal peoples live in a ‘world until yesterday’. He said, ‘This book spreads prejudices about Papuan people (…) that indigenous Papuans still display a way of life from hundreds of years ago. This is not true and strengthens the idea that indigenous people are ’backwards’, ‘live in the past’ or are ‘stone age.’

Reverend Socratez Yoman, Head of the West Papuan Baptist Church, has also demanded an apology from Mr Diamond to the Papuan people.

Dominikus Surabut, currently jailed for treason for peacefully declaring West Papuan independence, described the relationship of indigenous West Papuans and the Indonesian state as political apartheid. In a statement smuggled out of his jail cell, he said, ‘This is the very nature and character of colonial occupation of indigenous peoples, where they are treated as second class citizens whose oppression is justified by painting them as backwards, archaic, warring tribes – just as suggested by Jared Diamond in his book about tribal people.’

Survival International and TAPOL received the messages of outrage following condemnation of the book by Survival last week. The book has since been the subject of heated debate during Mr Diamond’s visit to the UK.

Read a longer version of these statements (pdf)


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Pros and Cons of Nuclear Energy

    Nuclear Energy Pros and Cons As of today, nuclear energy is considered as one of the most environmentally friendly source of energy as it produces fewer... Read more

    The 07 March 2015 by   Rinkesh
    ENVIRONMENT
  • Top 25 Coral Reef Facts

    Coral reefs are some of the most beautiful places on Earth to visit. Even just watching an underwater documentary film about them will show you how lively and... Read more

    The 16 March 2015 by   Rinkesh
    ENVIRONMENT
  • Various Ocean Animals

    Ocean Animals Oceans cover nearly three fourth of the earth’s surface and supply roughly 97% of the earth’s water supply. They are by far the largest animal... Read more

    The 08 April 2015 by   Rinkesh
    ENVIRONMENT
  • Avoiding Genetic Rescue Not Justified on Genetic Grounds

    Genetics to the rescue!I had the pleasure today of reading a new paper by one of the greatest living conservation geneticists, Dick Frankham. Read more

    The 11 March 2015 by   Bradshaw
    ENVIRONMENT
  • Australia’s Perfect Storm of Negligence

    If, for the purposes of some sick and twisted thought experiment, you were to design policies that would ensure the long-term failure of a wealthy, developed... Read more

    The 17 March 2015 by   Bradshaw
    ENVIRONMENT
  • Australians: Out-of-touch, Urban Squanderers

    There’s a romantic myth surrounding Australia that is pervasive both overseas and within the national psyche: this sun-scorched continent home to the stoic... Read more

    The 23 March 2015 by   Bradshaw
    ENVIRONMENT
  • How to Contact a Potential PhD Supervisor

    © http://www.phdcomics.comIt’s probably fair to say that most university-based academics regularly receive requests from people around the world wishing to be... Read more

    The 01 April 2015 by   Bradshaw
    ENVIRONMENT

Add a comment

Magazine