Health Magazine

Addiction in the Courtroom [Guest Post]

By Dirkh @dirk57

Addiction in the Courtroom [Guest Post]
Forensic psychology and the paradox of addiction.
The following article was written by Allison Gamble, who blogs at
The paradox of addiction presents a legal conundrum when it comes to determining the extent of a defendant’s guilt in criminal court. Although addiction is generally considered a mental health condition, it does not lie within the parameters that typically define mental illness in the courts. Though defense lawyers may present addiction as a mitigating factor--in some cases influencing the jury to vote for a lesser conviction--addiction does not excuse the defendant from being legally responsible for the crime.
Forensic psychology is a field that weaves together psychology and the criminal justice system. Oftentimes these insights prove useful for determining legal guilt or innocence. For example, if a defendant is found not guilty by reason of insanity, it is likely due to the work of a forensic psychologist. However, when it comes to crimes involving addictive behavior, forensic psychology is faced with paradoxical truths regarding addiction, and the relationship between addiction and responsibility for one’s actions.
A commonly held view of addiction is that it is a disease marked by lack of control. An alcoholic cannot stop himself from drinking. Likewise, a drug addict will do things no one in their right mind would ever do just to get the next high. All of these people may thoroughly regret their behavior when the high wears off, but that does not stop them from doing it again. Indeed, they often cannot stop without help.
Paradoxically, however, addiction is all about choice. A crucial part of treatment for addiction requires the addict to take full responsibility for his or her behavior. Addicts must recognize that their addictive behavior is, on some level, a choice, and that they can choose differently. It is not clear to what extent biology plays a role in starting an addiction. Social and emotional factors also play parts, both in forming an addiction and in continuing it.
This creates a huge gray area when an addict commits a crime related to his or her addiction. Did the person have control over their behavior? Is the addiction itself a choice, or something the addict can’t help any more than they could help catching the flu? Especially in cases where the addiction itself is a crime, such as compulsive shoplifting or narcotic use, these questions are crucial in determining the defendant’s responsibility for the crime and an appropriate sentence. Generally if these questions can be answered at all, the answer is often both yes and no, and the legal system often reflects this dichotomy: People convicted of addiction-related crimes may be ordered into treatment as part of their sentences. In some cases, especially for crimes not involving violence or repeat offenses, criminal charges are dropped if the defendant agrees to treatment. However, a defendant being treated for addiction may also be sentenced to jail time, probation, fines, community service, and/or restitution, especially if the crime involved violence or property damage. Since addiction is both under and outside of the addict’s control, someone who commits an addiction-related crime should be both held responsible and offered treatment.
Graphics Credit:

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Do You Have an Internet Addiction?

    Have Internet Addiction?

    Do you find yourslef longing to login to the Internet?Do you have a hard time pulling yourself away from Facebook? Do you feel a need to check your email? Do yo... Read more

    By  Tomretterbush
  • What BPD Means To Me– Guest Post #2

    What Means Guest Post

    As stated previously, every week I am planning to have a different guest author who suffers from BPD write about their own story of struggle and recovery agains... Read more

    By  Lisaannjarrett
  • Guest Post-Baby Sign Language-Good For Child, Good For Family

    I really love sign language. I think it’s a great and convenient tool to help babies and kids with autism to get that communication ball rolling. Read more

    By  Joysautismblog
  • The Pros and Cons of Addiction

    Pros Cons Addiction

    There really are not any pros of addiction. If, one can call feeling spectacular during the first couple of uses, and then chasing that “amazing” high for the... Read more

    By  Finallygrowingup
  • What Is REAL Addiction Recovery?

    I was doing my usual thing on the world’s most famous social website the other day – just cruising along, checking out addiction recovery groups and reading... Read more

    By  3stepstorecovery
  • Guest Post: Act Like A Kid to Find True Happiness

    Have you ever visited to a park and watched kids playing in the playground? They seem so free and so happy. Often if you look at the adults, they are happy... Read more

    By  Gjosefsberg
  • Guest Post: Healthy “Fast Food”

    This is a guest post written by Kathryn Henry, a writer for TeachStreet. TeachStreet is a website that provides online and local classes, including cooking... Read more

    By  Gjosefsberg