Debate Magazine

A Snowflake From Hell

Posted on the 15 July 2011 by Mikeb302000
Race and the Castle Doctrine:
It is “well-documented” that defendants in ordinary self-defense cases have a tendency to emphasize the race of the assailant, if the assailant is black, in order to make the conduct seem more reasonable to jurors.[18] In other words, one is more likely to consider the use of deadly force appropriate when faced with a black assailant.[19] It follows that if expansion of Castle Doctrine laws increases the opportunity to use force, then there will be more misuse of deadly force due to racial bias.
The fallout surrounding the Joe Horn incident highlights this issue. Horn, who is white, described the burglars as being “black” to the 911 operator.[20] After the grand jury cleared Horn in the shootings, Quanell X, a local minority rights activist, stated that, “there is not a snowflake’s chance in hell that an African-American man could do what Joe Horn did and get away with it. There is no longer a need for the criminal justice system, police, judge or jury. You can be all of that on your own.”[21] Quanell X has staged protests over the incident, and over the larger issue of whether the Castle Doctrine legalizes racially motivated violence.[22]
This is not the first time that a high profile use of self-defense laws has created racial tension. Most notable is the Bernie Goetz incident in 1984,[23] which raised the question of whether race affected the jurors’ and Goetz’s belief as to what degree of force was reasonable.[24] Some critics have characterized the Geotz decision as “opening the hunting season on young black men.”[25] Similar accusations were made following the Joe Horn incident.[26]
The Joe Horn Case
when local resident Joe Horn shot and killed two men burgling his neighbor's home. Publicized recordings of Horn's exchange with emergency dispatch indicate that he was asked repeatedly not to interfere with the burglary because the police would soon be on hand

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • An Invitation from a Uighur Activist

    I was invited to the year end party on December 17, hosted by a Uighur independence activist, Tur Muhhamet. Mr. Muhammet lives in exile in Japan because of... Read more

    By  Shahalexander
  • Machupiccu - A Crystal from a Dissolved Past

    Machupiccu Crystal from Dissolved Past

    Out through the Peruvian dessert, through countless centuries, lies the mysterious city of Machupiccu; an abandoned ruined town that defies logic or explanation... Read more

    By  Arieu
  • A Letter from Japan

    Letter from Japan

    I today got the following letter from the Spanish mailing list of WTT, with a call for prayer from Japan, from March 12th, which in view of the urgency of the... Read more

    By  Luphil
  • A Jewel of A House - from Elle Decor

    Jewel House from Elle Decor

    Giulia Geranium's human friend brought my attention to this beautiful house in Morocco. Please click here for moreThe photographer, Simon Upton...wasn't he on... Read more

    By  Thecleverpup
  • Reflections from a McDonald’s Booth

    Reflections from McDonald’s Booth

    Note: This post was originally from the Hodgkins blog, but I hoped it would encourage readers here as well.I woke up this morning, grabbed my computer, and... Read more

    By  Caryschmidt
  • A Last Sunset from Nusa Lembongan

    Last Sunset from Nusa Lembongan

    Two crazy things: I am now a certified open water diver! So exciting. I’m now a little bit addicted. Tonight is our very last night in Bali. How wonderful that... Read more

    By  Leonoras
  • Looking at Manhattan's Sky from a Taxi

    Looking Manhattan's from Taxi

    this is where my taxi driver was literally falling asleep at the wheel. I noticed when he let an opportunity to move out of the jammed up traffic go by that... Read more

    By  Lily Hydrangea