A Short, Sharp Shock by Kim Stanley RobinsonPosted on the 02 February 2011 by Jimblack78
This is one of the hardest books I have read and reviewed. I have not read much of Kim Stanley Robinson's work. A friend (I might as well list him as "creative consultant"-Terry Kissinger) is a big fan of Robinson's Mars books. I did not want to start another series until I finished one that I already started. So I thought this short book would be a good one to try. Normally, Terry and I have similar tastes in science fiction and comic books. Imagine my surprise when I did not like this book.
It started good enough with a man with no memores waking up on a beach. The language and style of writing reminded me of Roger Zelazny's writing. Starting a story with the protagonist having no memories is very similar to Zelazny's "Nine Prnces in Amber".
The main character goes with the flow. He rarely makes decisions. Most of the chances in the book are forced on him or just happen and he goes along with them. In Zelazny's book, the character made choices and tried to accomplish goals. Robinson's protagonist seems to have no ambition. He is perfectly content just letting things happen to him. This does serious damage to the story.
Is the story all bad? No. Robinson shows off his vivid imagination and descriptive skills. He just needed to work out a story to go with the basic idea he set up. With a solid story being the frame work, this could have been a very good book.
Based on other reviews I have seen, this is a style that Robinson only used on this story. I will be reading more Robinson in the future to see if I like his regular style.
I would recommend skipping this one.
These articles might interest you :
This months top ski tips for better short turns. Keep your upper body facing down the fall-line. If your upper body is held still and your legs are turned in th... Read moreBy Surfcat
OTHER SPORTS, OUTDOORS, SNOW, SPORTS
image credit It's an amazing site - a cone of vapor appearing around an aircraft which is travelling at transonic speed. Known as the Prandtl–Glauert Singularit... Read moreBy Gerard
What makes you think? All too often we live our lives in a total reactive mode with little or no time for filtering the information that is penetrating our... Read moreBy Rodjonesartist
ART & DESIGN, CULTURE
I am leaving soon for vacation, and decided this would also be a good time to take a little blogging break for a couple, oh, I don’t know, maybe three weeks. Read moreBy Shrinkingthecamel
Out through the Peruvian dessert, through countless centuries, lies the mysterious city of Machupiccu; an abandoned ruined town that defies logic or explanation... Read moreBy Arieu
With a modern ocean steamer it’s a good twelve hours west of the coast of Chile; the island Robinson Crusoe. In the olden days it must have been quite a bit... Read moreBy Arieu
A bit smaller but much brighter and certainly more festive than the dark Anglican Church just down Ross Road, the Catholic Church of St Mary’s stands cute and... Read moreBy Arieu
MOST POPULAR FROM BOOKS
- BOOK UNDER THE SPOTLIGHT: THE SPLASH OF LADY HARRIET by Mariagrazia
- Neon Soul by Pamelascott
- Masonry: Everything Is Illuminated (Sort Of) by Ashleylister
- Weekly Wrap Up (February 19) by Cleopatralovesbooks
MOST RECOMMENDED IN BOOKS
- Masonry - Best Left to the Experts by Ashleylister
- A Dream It May Be, But The Dream Goes On! #BookReview and #AuthorInterview by Beccachopra
- Will 3D Printed Fingerprints Unlock a Phone? by Dplylemd
- Sunday Lunch at The Whitefield Arms by Cheekymeeky