Religion Magazine

A Question of Strategy

By Nicholas Baines

It is perhaps no coincidence that Parliament was gripped yesterday by the debate on whether the UK should join in bombing ISIS/Daesh in Syria and that today the House of Lords is debating the Strategic Defence and Security Review 2015. (I commented on this on its publication last week here.)The sharpest questions posed were not to do with numbers or hardware or whether such attacks constitute the UK “going to war in Syria”, but to what end these means are meant to lead. Strategy is the plumbing that leads to the achievement or fulfilment of a vision – the end.

And the haunting question behind yesterday's debates in both Houses was: if this is a strategic move, then what happens when the bombing has stopped?

I (somewhat notoriously) wrote to the Prime Minister in August 2014 to ask if there was a coherent strategy behind our responses to events in the Middle East and elsewhere – and, if so, what it was. As I observed at the time, simply repeating the mantra that “our strategy is clear” neither provides a strategy nor makes it clear. Clearly, the same concern still applies: is the UK response to terrorism and other international threats reactively tactical rather than strategically coherent?

This isn't a dig; it is a genuine question.

The debate about Syria was shadowed by lessons learned (or not) from interventions in Afghanistan, Iraq and Libya. Given that we can't later decide to un-bomb the ruins, where is the strategy to win the peace? And how realistic is the vagueness about timescales, given that the time needed for changing minds, establishing some sort of peaceful and achievable settlement, creating robust institutions and security for the people, is likely to run into decades and not months? I seem to remember that George W Bush celebrated 'Mission Accomplished' in Iraq after about three weeks.

Today's debate on The United Kingdom's role in supporting international security and stability in the light of the Strategic Defence and Security Review is haunted by the same area of questioning. Put simply, is the Government's plan a proactive step in building a flexible and adaptable security force … or a reactive response to the challenges of today that might not be those of ten years time when the hardware will be in place?

This is not to diminish or understate the complexity of predicting the unpredictable in an increasingly uncertain world. But, it is to bang the drum for greater joined-upness between arms of government (DfID, FCO, Home Office, MoD), a more clearly worked out strategic plan for achieving a clearly articulated and attainable vision, and a realistic timescale to which we must – if we decide to act – commit ourselves.

So, what are the short-, medium- and long-term plans for Syria and Iraq? And who are the key players who will need to coalesce in some way to enable this to happen? And how is the SDSR to integrate with wider military, diplomatic and politico-economic initiatives/realities in order to avoid largely reactive tactical engagement?

These are the questions that will not go away.

Posted with Blogsy
Posted with Blogsy

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • 25nis Becomes a Fight

    The government has been putting together, at the initiative of the Haredi MKs, a plan to give a life insurance policy to every avreich. Read more

    By  Gldmeier
    RELIGION, SOCIETY, SPIRITUALITY
  • Interesting Psak: It Isn't Necessarily a Duck. Or a Chicken

    Interesting Psak: Isn't Necessarily Duck. Chicken

    If it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck, it is probably a duck. But not necessarily. Rav Mahfoud goes on an annual visit to Rav Chaim Kanievsky to pay hi... Read more

    By  Gldmeier
    RELIGION, SOCIETY, SPIRITUALITY
  • A Tale of Two Fathers

    Well, we didn't see that one coming, did we? The Archbishop of Canterbury has had to rethink who he actually is. As was revealed in the Daily Telegraph last... Read more

    By  Nicholas Baines
    RELIGION, SOCIETY, SPIRITUALITY
  • Taking a Life of Its Own

    Seeing the news the past couple of days and the discussion about the Reform and Netanyahu and the Haredi parties, it seems to me that this issue has taken a lif... Read more

    By  Gldmeier
    RELIGION, SOCIETY, SPIRITUALITY
  • A New Bishop of Richmond

    It has been announced this morning that the Venerable Paul Slater, currently Archdeacon of Richmond and Craven, is to be the Bishop of Richmond in the Diocese o... Read more

    By  Nicholas Baines
    RELIGION, SOCIETY, SPIRITUALITY
  • A Peaceful Yom Kippur

    Peaceful Kippur

    After every Yom Kippur we get to enjoy the pictures posted online of the highways empty of cars, highways that are normally busy, and often bumper to bumper,... Read more

    By  Gldmeier
    RELIGION, SOCIETY, SPIRITUALITY
  • Shul as a Social Experience

    In what is most likely an unscientific poll, Bangitout.com tried to find understand why people got o shul.. Here is their inforgraphic of the results of the... Read more

    By  Gldmeier
    RELIGION, SOCIETY, SPIRITUALITY